This is a discussion on Snub Nose v. Semi within the Concealed Carry Issues & Discussions forums, part of the Defensive Carry Discussions category; I've read many entries that state there times you would want a snub nosed revolver over a semi pistol. I don't own a small revolver; ...
I've read many entries that state there times you would want a snub nosed revolver over a semi pistol.
I don't own a small revolver; can someone provide some examples of when a snub nosed revolver would be a better carry option than a semi?
Always Carry, Never Tell
Certified NRA Instructor
Certified LTC Instructor
Don"t let stupid be your skill set....
And Shepards we shall be, for Thee, my Lord, for Thee,
Power hath descended forth from Thy hand, So that our feet may swiftly carry out thy command,
And we shall flow a river forth to Thee, And teeming with souls shall it ever be,
About the first time your semi Jams....
Retired Private Detective
S&W Model 19 2.5" .357
The original point and click interface was a Smith & Wesson.
I wouldn't mind carrying one in an ankle rig vs a semi. More centralized weight with the light weight J-Frames etc due to the ammo being carried in the center of the gun instead of the bottom/rear and if you ever end up on your back with an attacker on top of you, bringing your leg up to keep them off you will get a back up gun where you can get at it easier and have better ability for an inches away shot as a revolver can function @ contact range without risk of being pushed out of battery unlike a semi.
It's all personal preference. I've carried both and I'm comfortable carrying a snub. Not sure why you need more than 5 shots. Another thing to consider is the single stack semis tend to have limited ammo. Why not go with a snub instead since there are far fewer problems that can occur? You really aren't sacrificing much if you take a 5 round .357 over a 6 or 7 round 9mm semi.
Put the wrong ammo in a semi and it can be jam city. A revolver, snub nose or otherwise, would never know the difference...and neither would you. Revolvers are inherently more reliable and accurate.
Inherently accurate...I'll buy that but humans are not inherently accurate shooters an the quality of trigger in most "defensive" revolvers is contrary to the mechanical accuracy.
If we are to compare directly to single stack compact autos, I'm with you.
I alternate depends on mood and dress sometimes both at the same time
For a quick point of reference:
Smith 360PD .357 Magnum, 5 shots over a Springfield XDM-9 @ 19+1
Not a huge difference in size. The biggest detractor of the XDM-9 is the longer grip, but with a grip chop or alternate model you can still carry 13?+1 on board and not be that much larger than a 5 shot revolver.
If I can escape my other duties later tonight I'll take some pics in relation to a G19, G26, and P2000SK.
Advantages of a snub-nose:
1.. Ammo variability becomes essentially a non-issue, because the ammo is not a functional part of the feeding mechanism.
2. More powerful rounds for the same size and weight.
3. Impossible to limp-wrist, regardless of injury, firing from unusual positions, etc.
4. Can be fired from inside a coat pocket without jamming.
5. In a muzzle-contact shot, cannot be knocked out of battery.
6. In a muzzle-contact shot, much less likely to jam due to blood entering the weapon.
7. No magazine to be accidentally released.
8. Can obtain a higher grip for less muzzle flip, due to the lack of a slide.
That's all I can think of off the top of my head.
"...there is no arguing with such snivelling puppies, who allow superiors to kick them about deck at pleasure."
– Captain Bellamy
For me I think I would have the need to defend myself either at the gas station, bank, or parking lot it would be up close and I can jamb my snub in someones chest an pull the trigger more than once anything over 20 to 30 feet away I will be looking to take cover or drive away I am not rambo but if attacked I want the opportunity to end it in my favor.
My Smith & Wesson J-frame AirLite is convenient. It's the only one of my guns that I can carry in a pocket holster comfortably. So, I can grab it and go when need be. It conceals easily. Like others have said, it doesn't have feeding or ejection issues.
But, it's not the perfect weapon for every occasion. Nothing is really.
Can be fired from inside a pocket.
No safety to get in the way.
Until the late 70's, most everyone was carrying a revolver. The S&W 36 was one of the favorite pocket guns. Autoloaders were heavy and bulky. Then came the cheap plastics and the Glocks along with their KaBooms. So those growing up now never knew the feel or dependability of a revolver nor did they learn how to shoot a 1911.
A 9mm might expand but a .45acp never shrinks.
"The problems we face today are there because the people who work for a living are now outnumbered by those who vote for a living."
I tried several small semi's. I tried PF9 I like it but recoil was stiff and I would drop the mag in recoil. I tried CM9 I loved it but the baseplate of the mag would come off and dump the rounds. The main reason I went back to a snub is I simply I shoot snubs better than I do the micro semi's. I also find a j frame easier to grab from a pocket than a square grip
They both have their place for me.