This is a discussion on Klein's Rules Of Engagement within the Concealed Carry Issues & Discussions forums, part of the Defensive Carry Discussions category; This is an excerpt from an article entitled "Rules of Engagement and Disengagement" from the July 07 issue of Concealed Carry Magazine. The full article ...
This is an excerpt from an article entitled "Rules of Engagement and Disengagement" from the July 07 issue of Concealed Carry Magazine. The full article is posted on the USCCA web site, but, alas, it is only viewable in its entirety by USCCA members, so I've posted the "meat" of the article for the benefit of DC members who do not belong to the USCCA.
Sorry for the length, but it's well worth reading.
"In order to justify the use of lethal force, i.e., establishing the defense of self defense, the discharge of a firearm at another person shall be instituted only when ALL of the following apply:"
1. "You were not at fault or did not create the situation that gave rise to the taking of another's life."
2. "You believe you were in danger of imminent death or great bodily harm."
3. "You must not have violated any opportunity to retreat or avoid the danger."
4. "You have exhausted all other means to avoid the use of deadly force."
5. "The use of deadly force presents no substantial risk of injury to innocent persons."
Rule #1: You were not at fault. "You can't start the fight or egg someone on so that when they attack you, you then bring out the hardware." You have to stay cool at all times! You must know how to back off and back down if necessary. "Because you're carrying the ace-in-the-hole you must never be the aggressor." Anything you do to escalate the confrontation adds to your responsibility for what ultimately happens.
For example, another driver with road rage thinks I cut him off. He pulls up beside me at the next stop sign and aggressively demands to know why I cut him off. I capitulate by telling him, "I am sorry. I thought I had enough distance. I didn't mean to cut you off. I am really sorry." He drives away. If I didn't capitulate, and the situation turned really bad, I could be deemed the aggressor in the eyes of the law. On the other hand, if he did not accept my apology, and he got out of his car, I could drive away.
Rule #2: You believe you were in danger of imminent death or great bodily harm. The key is what you believe to be the case at the time. Do you have reasonable grounds to believe the threat is real?
Firstly, does the attacker appear to have the ability to cause you irrevocable harm? Here we are talking about disparity of force. Ability can refer to: (a) force of numbers, i.e., more of them than you; (b) able bodied against the disabled; (c) male against female, i.e., men are typically stronger and more aggressive than women; (d) young against old; (e) bigger and stronger against smaller and weaker; (f) trained vs. untrained, i.e., if your opponent is known to you to be a boxer, special forces, black belt, etc. prior to your using your firearm. Note: You cannot use this criterion if you did not know your opponent's training prior to killing him! Secondly, does the attacker have the immediate opportunity to cause you irrevocable harm? Is he capable of immediately employing his power to seriously hurt you?
Thirdly, is your opponent acting in such a manner (by words and by deeds) that a reasonable and prudent person would conclude that he harbors intent to kill or cripple you? In other words, are his actions placing you in imminent jeopardy?
Rule #3: You have not violated any opportunity to retreat or avoid the danger if you can in the first place. Firearms trainer and author, John Farnam, teaches that you must do what you can to disengage safely at the earliest point in a confrontation or potential confrontation. The best sort of disengagement is to not be there in the first place! Avoid confrontations by making your exit at the first hint of trouble. Farnam teaches that avoidance has several layers. The first layer is to not be where the confrontation is in the first place. The second layer is to leave before a potentially bad situation turns worse and goes in the toilet. The third layer is functional invisibility. This means you should try not to turn heads. Live a "stealth existence" below the radar. Finally, the fourth layer is to act in a decisive, deliberate, confident, and assertive manner so that you are consistently de-selected for victimization.
Identify the exits every time you enter a place. Look around the room and notice who is noticing you. Never turn down eye contact. Look decisive, alert and strong. Keep your head up. Also, immediately before and after you get in and out of a motor vehicle, look around. Parking lots and driveways are places where victims are often selected. That is where people unwittingly tend to get distracted as their focus is divided and they are not paying attention----so their level of awareness goes down.
If you are in a restaurant or movie theater, leave at the first sign of trouble. Don't just look around. --See! Study everything carefully. The other day, I was eating in a diner with my wife and daughter when a man at the next table began to get loud and belligerent with his companions. I told my wife and daughter "let's get out of here" and we got up and left. Should that problem have escalated, I wanted us to be far away before the situation went into the toilet. In fact, we have an agreement that if we are any place where there is any indication of developing excitement, we are out of there! The kind of witness we want to be, if ever questioned by the police, is the type who left at least five minutes before the thing happened!
This advice is especially important for the elderly, women and children children--as these groups are typically selected by predators for victimization.
Rule #4: You have exhausted all other means to avoid the use of deadly force. You are not justified in shooting a knife wielding aggressor if you can drive away. If you cannot, that is another story. But, you must avail yourself of other options if you safely can before you resort to using deadly force.
So, let us say you are selected for victimization. You want to disengage at the first opportunity if possible before the situation escalates. Most predators want easy prey. Don't make it easy for predators!
John Farnam teaches that if you are walking down the street and you are approached by a stranger, keep moving. Walk right on through. Do not stop in the spot that the potential predator has chosen. You are probably being set up. Politely dismiss him with pre-rehearsed verbal tape loops. And do not answer his questions.
These tape loops should be practiced so that they can be reeled off whenever the need may arise. For example, you are asked for spare change. Your response should be something like: "I'm sorry sir. I can't help you." Or, let us say you are approached for directions. Your response should be something like: "I'm sorry sir. I can't help you." The point is that whatever the request is, your response should be the same. And you should keep moving as you respond verbally and make brief eye contact. Be firm but polite, and radiate strength. Remember that prey behavior excites predators. So act assertively and confident. Right action--right mind. A timid voice and bearing project weakness and confusion of purpose.
Failing that? Farnam wisely points out that you want to divide the potential predator's focus and disrupt his plan. So, you can point down at the ground just behind the person, with your support hand and away from your gun side as you verbalize with excitement something to the effect of "Oh--oh! Look out!" Then move around him.
Failing that? Escalate the ante. Verbalize something like "Get away from me! Leave me alone!" Then break contact and disengage.
Failing that? Some intermediate, non-lethal form of persuasion may be called for, such as a blast of pepper spray in the predator's face. If you carry a gun, you should carry pepper spray.
Remember your goal is to keep from getting hurt. You work your way up the force continuum if that is safe and possible. If you have no other option than to resort to deadly force, you still want to find a way out of the gravest extreme if safely if possible. If you have time and can draw your firearm and not use it, this is infinitely better than the grave alternative. Just because you draw your gun does not mean you have to shoot. It means you must be prepared to shoot if you must (i.e., you have no other viable choice). If there's time, and it's still safe to do so, drawing on the threat and shouting a challenge such as "Please! Don't move! Drop your weapon!" and then evaluating your situation is infinitely better than letting it rip. Announce your orders with a loud, aggressive, self-assured voice. Be convincing!
Rule #5: The use of deadly force presents no substantial risk of injury to innocent persons. What if deadly force is your only option? You still must consider where you are and who is around you. But keep in mind that you, the lawfully armed and trained citizen with a moral conscience, present a much safer bet of protecting innocent bystanders if the situation goes in the toilet than does the amoral criminal predator.
When you’re wounded and left on Afghanistan’s plains,
And the women come out to cut up what remains,
Just roll to your rifle and blow out your brains,
And go to your God like a soldier.
ALWAYS carry! - NEVER tell!
"A superior Operator is best defined as someone who uses his superior
judgement to keep himself out of situations that would require a display of his
Thanks for the post. Good info to know.
CRIME..... LAW DEFINES, POLICE ENFORCE, CITIZENS PREVENT!
FOUR BOXES KEEP US FREE:  SOAP  BALLOT  JURY  AMMO!
Great points but to remember to check your state laws. Some states will require more effort on your part to retreat.
You have to make the shot when fire is smoking, people are screaming, dogs are barking, kids are crying and sirens are coming.
Ego will kill you. Leave it at home.
Good rules but be sure to modify them for you state
A real man loves his wife, and places his family as the most important thing in life. Nothing has brought me more peace and content in life than simply being a good husband and father.
I started a thread in the a student of mine had to shoot a knife wielding attacker out of his truck...that dealt with this very thing.
I would rather stand against the cannons of the wicked than against the prayers of the righteous.
AR. CHL Instr. 07/02 FFL
Like custom guns and stuff? Check this out...
good stuff to know, thanks!
"Wear a gun to someone else's house, you're saying, 'I'll defend this home as if it were my own.' When your guests see you carry a weapon, you're telling them, 'I'll defend you as if you were my own family"
I have to disagree with some of this guys advice. If I am faced with a menacing person, I am not going to walk right on by. I will turn around and leave if possible. I think we have all seen enough COPS episodes and You Tube to know that pepper spray will not stop every BG. Sure, pepper spray has it's uses. I am not denying that. I agree with leaving an area of escalating violence. But some of what this guy states as fact leaves a bad taste.
Georgia thankfully passed a law last year(?) that said when you are in fear for your life that you do not have to attempt to retreat before using deadly force and as long as you have not broken any laws while doing so you can not be prosecuted or sued in civil court. I strongly feel that you should avoid shooting anyone if at all possible, but I refuse to be stabbed or shot in the back while trying exit the situation. Thanks for the post.
I'd like to say that this was very well written and made for thoughtful reading. Full of great points. With that being said I'd like to take a little time to say I don't agree with the stranger "verbal tape loops". I think that it is important that people take time to help strangers because helping others restores faith in humanity instead of writting each stranger off as a BG waiting to jump you. Helping someone you don't know, and taking that chance is what makes helping strangers so special; that, and you don't owe them anything, you're just doing it b/c you're a good person. As for me, I'll contine to help people, and I would advise everyone else to as well, and if they turn out to be a BG... well thats why we carry. I do have to admit, I'm not much of an easy target; though, I have been targeted.
"A government is like fire, a handy servant, but a dangerous master." -- George Washington
In principle I have to agree - and have met many good folks just that way.I think that it is important that people take time to help strangers because helping others restores faith in humanity instead of writting each stranger off as a BG waiting to jump you.
I would tho add a rider to that which is the ''BG group scam'' - one good example being the roadside ''maiden in distress'' deal - which when GG stops to render assistance results in an attack from a team of maybe two or more others.
Thus, much has to depend on our appraisal of any situation and hopefully too - manage to invoke some degree of ''spidey sense'' to detect when all does not feel right. Over and above that - be very prepared to act in case a seemingly innocent situation turns nasty.
We need to hopefully find a balance - that's the hard part.
Chris - P95
NRA Certified Instructor & NRA Life Member.
"To own a gun and assume that you are armed
is like owning a piano and assuming that you are a musician!."
http://www.rkba-2a.com/ - a portal for 2A links, articles and some videos.
I live in Georgia and they passed a castle doctrine bill that has to do with not having to retreat from aggressive behavior by an attacker. It is a good law and every person who carries should get on the bandwagon and fight for laws like this. People violating your rights and attempting to bully you don't merit consideration.
SI VIS PACEM, PARA BELLUM
Basically a good reminder BUT:
Bad Stuff usually happens a lot faster than you might imagine. Even with good situational awareness and avoidance it goes down fast....have an evasion/response plan.... always.
Pepper is OK but slow to deploy unless you have extra time.
Some close quarters combat defensive and offensive moves are better .... goggle Koppo Stick.
Command Voice, as needed ... Back Off , Get Away from Me Now ... combine with a FENCE:
Expect and practice for at least 2 attackers.
In my state we are authorized to stand our ground during an attack which makes total sense. The victim has enough to deal with during a deadly attack without consciously delaying the response to look for or attempt to escape .... attempted escape probably would in some cases increase vulnerability.
Old testament....Shooting to Live 1942
Newer testament... Kill or Get Killed 1976/1987