"My" Improperly Handled Traffic Stop.
This is a discussion on "My" Improperly Handled Traffic Stop. within the Concealed Carry Issues & Discussions forums, part of the Defensive Carry Discussions category; So I finally had a "bad" traffic stop the other month, I alluded to this in another post, so here it is finally, I apologize ...
November 11th, 2008 09:48 PM
"My" Improperly Handled Traffic Stop.
So I finally had a "bad" traffic stop the other month, I alluded to this in another post, so here it is finally, I apologize for the delay in telling this, but I was waiting for some things to resolve prior to posting it, you'll get to that point later on in the post.
So Lima and I were on our way to Northern VA for a multi-state/multi-forum gathering for lunch, I've got the cruise control set just below the legal speed limit, I crest a hill, the vehicle accelerates, I come down and there's a squad car running radar, I'm now 10 over. I got that feeling that says "tag, you're it" and watch the rear view mirror, as soon as I see the lights, I hit the flashers, and am pulled over before the guy's rear wheels hit pavement.
I pull over, put it in park, turn off the radio, wrists on top of the wheel.
Officer comes up and asks for license/reg etc.
I tell him that my wallet is in my hip pocket and that is what I'm reaching for as that is my general practice, I also generally offer my CHL along with my DL. Before I can get my wallet out to retrieve my IDs, the officers asks if I am armed, I reply that I am and before I can mention the permit, I can tell that his danger switch just got thrown and he's now VERY tense, if not in a panic...
Now you know me, I love cops, I don't bash 'em, but this guy about freaked although he handled it well enough, but I could tell from his psychical demeanor that he was in oh crap mode and that kind of threw me for a loop. I saw his arm reach for his gun, and I figured I was about to be drawn on.
He did not draw, and I don't think I drew a breath until he asked where it was and if I had any other weapons, I did and told him of my pocket knife and that my gun was on my right hip.
My gun was on my right hip, strong side in an OWB with a cover garment over it, I still have my seat belt on, and my wallet is still in my left hip pocket, I've basically froze awaiting his commands that I knew would be coming.
Instead of asking me to shut of the engine he tells me he's going to open my door as he does so, then he starts reaching across me for my gun. Because he's now almost lying across my lap I have to lift my arms as he begins attempting to disarm me while I'm still seated in a running vehicle and belted in. At this time, I can see his taser, on his right side, and his gun is on his left.
Lima is in the passenger seat.
So help me, if I were a criminal I could have driven an elbow into the base of his skull, fish my left arm under his, Lima could of grabbed his right hand and I could have taken him for a ride.
He can't get my gun out while I'm belted in so he undoes my seat belt, tries tugging my gun out again and it's a no-go. Finally he gives up, backs out of the still running vehicle, asks me to exit the vehicle while grabbing my left arm to "escort" me from the vehicle.
He tells me to turn and put my hands on top of the car which I do and he finally succeeds in removing my 1911 from the holster, and asks me if I'm aware that it's cocked. I simply answer yes and tell him it is totally safe with the thumb safety engaged and that is how it is to be carried. He turns away from me facing the rear of the truck, my knife is still on me which he had to have seen while removing my gun (as it was in my right pocket), so he now has his hands full with a weapon he doesn't know how to use, and a still armed "suspect" at his back. He asks me how to decock it/where's the decocker and I about crapped my pants. I told him Please, DO NOT TRY TO DECOCK IT as there is no decocker. He is still pointing the gun at my vehicle (Lima still inside). He listens, removes the magazine and tries to cycle the slide. The thumb safety is still engaged and the slide will not move. I instruct him to lower thumb safety and he begins asking if the slide stop is the decocker. I inform him that it is not as there is no decocker and the safety is to the rear. He is still looking for it so I finally talk him through clearing the gun and he decocks it manually.
He places my gun in his pocket, allows me to sit in the vehicle, asks for DL/reg/insurance, and THEN asks if I have my permit. I tell him I do and ask him if he would like to see it and he says no that he can look it up on my DL. That's fine. (my car is still running)
He goes back to his car, runs my info.
He returns to the car, with my IDs, and ticket. He thanks me for my courtesy, compliance, and keeping calm throughout the stop (my vehicle is still running).
He says that he'd actually sorry that he has to give me the ticket, and goes into some dialog about how it's not everyday he has a courteous stop. I go into the "Dad's a retired cop, I still work with PD" thing. He then goes into some thing about if I have my speedometer tested and go to court that the judge may lower or throw out my ticket.
I DON'T CARE ABOUT THE TICKET I'm seriously concerned about his lack of safety. He doesn't know the manual of arms, fine. But had I been a felon, I could have assaulted and injured him in a number of ways before he ever ran my DL and he was scaring the crap out of Lima who could see his fumbling with my gun out of the rear passenger window using poor muzzle control and sweeping the car several times with her still inside.
As I said in a thread where the same thing happened, if he didn't know how the gun worked he should have just taken it into his car. While we were there on the side of the road and he was trying to figure out the gun, I was still armed with a knife and his attention was all on the gun, his back to me, and I had to tell him how to clear the gun. He had both hands on it, I could have rushed him knowing he wouldn't get a shot off and hacked him to pieces with the knife he left on me.
Regarding the safety of others, I can totally see this guy ND'ing a round into the passenger compartment and maiming/killing an innocent passenger.
I am also concerned for the officer's safety as the next time he encounters an armed citizen the citizen might be one of these persons that gets loud and non-compliant OR a violent offender that really doesn't want to go back to jail, either situation could get ugly.
The reason I held of on posting this was that I got into contact with the the Sheriff, not to file a complaint but to simply show my concerns regarding the safety of his officers and the possibility of a bad stop resulting in a lawsuit of his Dept.
We discussed the stop, the Sheriff was not happy, he asked for the name of the deputy, as I did not offer it initially becuase I didn't want it to appear that I had it out for the guy, and it was only my intention to inform the Sheriff of the incident. I gave him the details from the ticket and we talked for about 30 to 45 minuted about what happened. I mainly focused on how the deputy put himself at risk and touched on how the stop was poorly handled overall regarding the presance of my firearm.
I also offered to teach any of his dept/ county first responders the NRA Basic Pistol and or Home Firearms Safety (The unloading class) for cost of books if he was interested and that if he didn't want me involved, I would offer the names of other NRA instructors that I know in the area.
I didn't get the impression of being blown off, but I haven't heard anything back from the Sheriff, not that I'm surprised, if I were him I wouldn't be happy about some guy calling me and telling me how jacked up my deputies are.
The big thing for me is that I did not over react, I did in fact de-escalate the situation by not getting loud and obnoxious and stayed courteous even while instructing the officer on how to clear my firearm, AND while I did address the issue with the Sheriff, I also gave advice on how to rectify at least some of the issues, if another inicident like that occurs with someone else and it goes bad, my hands are clean.
I also now have a better outlook on the retention abilities of the open top holster with tension screw only, as the deputy still had issues trying to remove my gun from the holster once I was out of the vehicle.
I plan on following up later with the Sheriff to see if he had any retraining done.
I've discussed this incident with several LEOs locally and all of them just shook their heads and couldn't believe that the deputy tried crawling around in the passenger compartment with the two of us still in the car.
Oh yeah, I paid the ticket.
So there you have it.
Thoughts, questions, comments?
And remember, no broad brush LEO bashing.
Last edited by JD; November 18th, 2008 at 05:54 PM.
November 11th, 2008 10:00 PM
Well, you've already done what I was going to suggest, and that is talking to a supervisor... not to trash the LEO who pulled you over, but to provide feedback that might save his life or someone else's life someday.
Sounds like an entirely unpleasant experience, to put it mildly.
All I can say is watch your speed and don't trust the cruise control to maintain speed while going downhill. Guess I didn't need to tell you that, though.
That stop could have turned real bad in more ways than one.
November 11th, 2008 10:01 PM
I can't wait for the usual, "You should have done something different." "Maybe the cop was having a bad day." "He just wants to go home too." "Civilians need to learn how to deal with cops."
What is so difficult that cops CAN"T be trained in the use of firearms and proper procedure when encountering one? I've never heard of a cop being shot by a BG who identifies himself as a ccw holder, and offers up his gun.
November 11th, 2008 10:03 PM
Wow, that's really sad actually. All I can really say is he's lucky it was you (read: a lawful citizen) and not a criminal.
November 11th, 2008 10:06 PM
Wow thats all I can say. You did everything right in my book. I give you an A+
November 11th, 2008 10:07 PM
November 11th, 2008 10:08 PM
Surprising that was in VA, unless of course that was Falls Church or Norfolk. I'd like to know county it was in so I know to drive EXTRA slow through that one. Good grief. Let us know if you hear back from the Sheriff or if there's ever any confirmation of retraining.
That whole thing is just so outrageous it's almost unfathomable. Normally I think I'd be a little peeved, but I think I'd have a hard time on this one just trying to control my laughter at the stupidity of it all.
I don't mean this next bit to sound any bit of LEO bashing, but I have a slight question/statement regarding the training. It seems we have a lot of these kinds of incidents where the LEO's temporarily confiscate the firearm and may or may not attempt to unload said weapon. Problem is two-fold here...
- Don't futz with a weapon you're not familiar with.
- Why aren't LEO's trained on a more broad range of weapon systems for safety sake if nothing else?
I've personally seen a large variety of officers from varying places, not just in VA that have a general lack of knowledge when it comes to firearms.
It would seem logical to me that if you're going to put your officers into a potentially lethal situation every day they're on the job due to the inherent risk of running into either a GG or a BG that's potentially armed, that you would want them to be able to properly handle a wider range of weapon platforms safely. But then again...that's just my logic speaking again...
November 11th, 2008 10:14 PM
Sounds like you did well, JD. Unfortunately most LEO's are not "gun guys". Many may have never held a gun , much less shot one before training. Sounds as if your well thought out approach to the sheriff may help the dept and deputy in the long run. Nicely done.
"In matters of style, swim with the current; in matters of principle, stand like a rock." Thomas Jefferson
Nemo Me Impune Lacesset
November 11th, 2008 10:15 PM
It's interesting to me how different the stops can be.
Mine, which I posted, was the exact opposite. I told him I had a carry license and was armed and where the gun was located. He thanked me for telling him, asked if I needed to go near the gun to get him my documents, when I told him no, he asked me to get them, told me to keep my hands where he could see them when he went back to run my license, came back and told me to watch my speed, no ticket issued. I thanked him, told him to stay safe, and away I went.
Sorry, that yours went so bad. Is it the difference in the training the LEO's get, the demeanor of the particular LEO, or what, I wonder?
"It does not do to leave a dragon out of your calculations, if you live near him."
J. R. R. Tolkien
November 11th, 2008 10:19 PM
Glad you finally decided to post about this. I saw a [blank] county deputy that had pulled someone over on Sunday when the wife and were going to Chili's. He was out of the car, and he matched the description you gave me. I couldn't help but think of your stop as I checked my speed going downhill... yep, 10 over.
November 11th, 2008 10:19 PM
I dunno, if I had to guess, I'd say that honestly, despite his age (mid 40's to early 50s) I just might have been his first "armed encounter" and that might of threw him for a loop.
Originally Posted by Guns and more
It's also no secret that the 1911 is fading in the LEO community, like I said, I don't have a beef with him not knowing how to work the gun, but he should have tried to figure it out some place other than on the side of the road with a guy with a knife at his back...
If I had to guess, the guy knew proper procedure, but the whole thing just freaked him out and he did everything wrong.
I don't think he had a bad day, I think I did everything right (except for the speeding), and I think we all try to go home at the end of the day, and I think if your post is any indication, civilians do need to learn how to interact with cops.
Yep she was, now this is a little hairy, he asked if I had any other weapons, not if she was armed or if there were any other weapons in the car, given his demeanor, I did not volunteer the information that Lima was armed, had he asked specifically if she was armed, we would have told him, but I felt that it would have made things worse by involving another armed person into the situation. Might have been the "wrong" thing to do, but at the time I thought it was the best course of action to take. I didn't lie, but I didn't tell him everything either.
Originally Posted by PM
Originally Posted by packinnova
I'm not going to give out the name of the County in the open forum, I'll PM it to you and trust that it's confidential.
Regarding the training of officers, this is a small county=small budget, and judging by the trends in budgets across the nation re: Public Safety, they're only going to get smaller (the budgets) and training costs money.
If you look at all the different makes and models, it would be pretty hard pressed to get them a class that will familiarize them with everything, I'm just glad I wasn't carrying my HK P7 And as I've stated previously in other posts, most current LEOs just aren't "Gun People" they don't care about the gun aspect of the job and see it as a tool on the duty belt. I wish it weren't the case but that's the way it is.
November 11th, 2008 10:21 PM
Where would we be without the thin blue line? There've been altogether TOO MANY of them killed in the line of duty during my 65 years on the planet. Boy, they need top quality training.
November 11th, 2008 10:21 PM
We do? Are you serious? They must be teaching them less at the academy than they are high schoolers about US history! And I also figured most law enforcement was prior military and would have come out of that experience with at least a bit of common sense/tactics? I guess they'll take almost anyone nowadays for $35k a year. I'm sure there's not a line beating down the door.
Originally Posted by Guns and more
To the OP of this thread, I didn't figure there was enough of humanity left these days for anyone to worry about a stranger or their safety....law enforcement or not. In my opinion you're going against the grain...I don't expect you'll ever hear back from the sheriff unless you press the issue further.
November 11th, 2008 10:24 PM
Funny he was worried about the weapon. He practically handed you his head on a silver platter.
Good job keeping everything calm though. A+
I work to buy guns. Not really, but sometimes it feels that way..
November 11th, 2008 10:25 PM
Him handling your 1911 is scary, especially asking about the de-cocker.
Most importantly is the vulnerability that the deputy placed himself in, it's lucky for him that you were a GG rather than a BG.
I think you were plenty cooperative at the traffic stop; and I think you did the right thing to speak with the sheriff. Personally I don't know if I'd follow up with the sheriff on the retraining issue, you did your part by informing him, it might be best to let it lay since it's totally his call on how to proceed.
By cagueits in forum The Second Amendment & Gun Legislation Discussion
Last Post: February 3rd, 2010, 10:19 PM
By HowardCohodas in forum Concealed Carry Issues & Discussions
Last Post: March 4th, 2009, 10:18 PM
By svinfinity45 in forum Law Enforcement, Military & Homeland Security Discussion
Last Post: October 24th, 2008, 11:08 PM
By NRATodd in forum Concealed Carry Issues & Discussions
Last Post: January 29th, 2008, 10:30 PM
Search tags for this page
ccw colorado traffic stop
check the status of ccw permit in arlington va
colorado ccw traffic stops
concealed weapons traffic stop in idaho
gun carry and traffic stops forums
handgun permit traffic stop tennessee
improper traffic stops
show ccw traffic stop washinton state
tennessee carry permit traffic stop
traffic stop protocol when ccw in upstate new york
washington concealed carry traffic stop
washington state concealed carry traffic stop
Click on a term to search for related topics.