9mm sd ammo
any input on federal classic hi-shok jacketed hollow piont in the 115 grain , i was thinking about the cridacal defence ammo , but have read some disappointing reviews , like not for shooting through a windshield, sheetmetal , basic s/d stuff ::scratchchin::oh , sorry i got some of this info from firearms tatical.com should have said tha the first time :embarassed:
It is because a 115 grain bullet is easily defelcted by windshield, recommend 230 grain! :gah:
Kidding.... I use 124 grain gold dots, have not shot either of those you mentioned but I would be careful about those who quibble over windshields and such, you job in a fight is to survive and if they are hiding you have opportunity to retreat to brick and mortar which is a far better cover, there are countless stories about the 45, 40, 9mm, 380, 32, 22 and all the others being the best or the worst; IMO buy a quality name brand hollowpoint in 9mm/40 make sure it feeds 100% in your gun and you shoot it well because different ammos do shoot different and then buy enough to practice and have on hand just in case they stop making that version...
Read this: Best Choices for Self Defense Ammo
Choose any one of the loads listed under 9mm, keeping in mind that they are listed in no particular order, and you may find that some of them are consdierably more expensive and/or harder to find than others.
Buy a box, and see if you pistol is 100% reliable with it, and if it shoots with what you consider acceptible accuracy and control. Shoot at least one or two entire magazines of every mag you plan on carrying/using for SD purposes. If it works, and you're happy with it's performance, you've found a good carry load; stock up.
Good advice above from "cmb". I shoot Winchester Ranger T 124 grain +P in my 9mm. I don't know about Federal Hi-shok, however I do shoot Federal Hydra-shok in my .44mag. no complaints. I think just about any QUALITY SD round that your pistola feeds and eats without fail, will do the job. Just my $.02
Originally Posted by cmb
All the talk about 115,124,40.cal 45.,it doesn't matter,just remember one thing,MULTIPLE STIMULAS on the affected area cures all.
well i thank you all for the in put , :smile:
I use a mag full of either GLASER or MAGSAFE only in South Florida for the sole reason of it being bounce proof. I don't worry about over penetration even in a 45, I worry about a miss in a very crowded environment and that slug bouncing around before coming to rest in an innocent person. If I miss (God forbid) the round will powder against the first solid object it hits. If I do my job and hit center mass, in south Florida (lightweight shirts, etc) I'm not worried about getting deep enough to stop, unless it's somebody like the weight I USED to be at 310+ then I'll be shooting for sure much higher in the chest plate than center mass. Now I weigh about 160 so, lol a harsh wind blows me away. Anytime the weather turns lousy or I move north for vacations in reciprocity land, I switch to 230gr in either Gold Dot, Federal HSP2 or Winchester Rangers. I don't ever shoot any COR-BON DPX since it seems to be problematic for jamming in some of my carry guns. Something to do with the bullet seating depth making it longer than normal.
Once, a long time ago, when my father in law was still living he ran inside from his airplane hangar at his north Florida retirement "castle" and said there was a rattler in the hangar and the kids were nearby. I snatched my 1911 and sprinted down there ... and sure enough a pygmy rattler was all coiled up and nestled into a warm corner of solid concrete and I would have worried about splash but I remembered the first slug was a Glaser. I got right close so I could be sure of a head shot without coming close enough for him to strike. Blew the head clean off and not a single fragment splattered anywhere. I have heard a lot of folks scream about MAGSAFE and GLASER or RBCD as frauds but I'll keep my own counsel thank you. I load all three of those into a primary mag and the gun feeds them 100% with no malfunctions, ever. Muzzle flash is low and so is recoil. I hit what I aim at and as I said, if I do my job on shot placement, then bullet configuration won't matter too much and if I don't or some other factor intervenes, then not bouncing shots will matter a lot. That's my plan and I'm stickin' to it!
That sounds all well and good, til your magic bullet turns to powder on the bones of your attackers arm that lies between your gun and his vitals. The FBI 12" penetration minimum exists for a reason.
Originally Posted by ExSoldier
I liked corbon 115g +p jhp when I used to have a 9mm. I also liked speer 124g gold dots. Plan on putting 3 or more of either of those at center mass, and you'll be good to go.
And reiterating the wonderful thing about all of this is that it is STILL my decision and not yours. Did you read the part of my last post where I said that I know that folks don't like 'em but that's okay, because I choose to keep my own counsel on things like this. I have a lot of training and experience and I'm pretty sure I know what will work best for me. Right? Anyway, when it comes to 9mm, after a mag of MAGSAFE, I'd go with 124gr Gold Dot.
Originally Posted by Texag
Critical defense is made to go through heavy clothing and still expand every time. It is not meant to pass through barriers and compete in the FBI tests. According to Hornady's own published info it does about 11" in cloth coverred gel. It seems to dump most of the energy in the first 8". It will get the job done if you are surgical with the application of lead.
Originally Posted by shadow38
The Federal hi-shok is an older design and has been said to clog through clothing. I haven't used it but there is a good write up here.
Originally Posted by Cuda66
Barnes XPB 115gr HP (35515) loaded by Cor-Bon (DPX09115)
Winchester Partition Gold 124gr JHP (RA91P)
Winchester Ranger-T 124 gr +P JHP (RA9124TP)
Winchester Ranger-T 127gr JHP +P+ (RA9TA)
Winchester Ranger-T 147gr JHP (RA9T)
Winchester Bonded 147gr JHP (RA9B/Q4364)
Speer Gold Dot 124gr JHP +P (53617)
Speer Gold Dot 147gr JHP (53619)
Remington Golden Saber 147gr JHP (GS9MMC)
Federal Tactical 124gr JHP (LE9T1)
Federal Tactical 135gr JHP +P (LE9T5)
Federal HST 147gr JHP (P9HST2)
Except Hornady CD doesn't expand every time; there's plenty of examples of it failing to expand.
Originally Posted by MikeNice
The only place it expands 100% is in Hornady's commercials.
Cuda, I haven't seen any test where it failed to expand. If you could point me in the direction of a few I would appreciate it. I was actually thinking of changing to CD for home use.
I currently carry Winchester Ranger Bonded 147gr. I was thinking of switching when my kid moves to their own room. The CD doesn't seem as likely to pass through two walls, mirrors, and a medicine cabinet with a lot of energy left over. Neither bullet probably would, but eh . . . I'm a dad I worry about these things.
Hornady likes to make a big deal about CD not clogging when shot through clothing and having flash suppressing powder. I guess they're counting on no one mentioning that the same has been true of other proven designs for years, and those designs are ones I can trust if I have the misfortune of having to shoot someone through an intermediate barrier.
ExSoldier-you go right ahead using ammo that is designed to do the exact opposite of what has been proven effective in testing and in actual shootings. For those interested, Brassfetcher has tests of magsafe and glaser rounds in .40 flavor. The results are predictably poor when compared to conventional JHP ammo.
ETA: Mike, if you're worried about overpenetration through walls, a rifle in .223/5.56 makes sense. With ammo that still meets FBI penetration requirements in bare gel, a 5.56 rifle will have the least amount of penetration left after going through wallboard. rounds like 75gr TAP are readily available and perfect for this scenario. In addition, they will cause much more damage to the target than a pistol round.