I wasn't aware this was even a full fledged debate. I got lost in the 38 is better than 380, 9mm is better than both, and the you're a little girlie man if you don't CC a full sized 1911 chambered in .45 debates to notice.
There are more arguments in the firearm communities than I've ever seen anywhere else. I think the Baptists vs Lutherans find more common ground than we do. lol