This is a discussion on Same shot placement, do you think 9mm, 357 Sig, 40, 45 offer equal incapacitation? within the Defensive Ammunition & Ballistics forums, part of the Defensive Carry Discussions category; I see people claim that there is not any significant difference in the incapacitation potential of the "service calibers" 9mm, 357 Sig, 40, 45. Do ...
I see people claim that there is not any significant difference in the incapacitation potential of the "service calibers" 9mm, 357 Sig, 40, 45.
Do you agree?
9mm +P minimum. 357 Sig, 40, 10mm or 45 preferred.
Of course not - but a whole lot closer than most will ever admit.
NRA Life Member
Charter Member (#00002) of the DC .41 LC Society - "Get Heeled! No, really!"
He that cannot reason is a fool. He that will not is a bigot. He that dare not is a slave. - Andrew Carnegie
Another calibre thread? Hold on, let me get my beer so I can more thoroughly enjoy the 'debate'.
Please read Rule 9:Rule 9 says there isn't much difference...........We also discourage "caliber war" threads and strongly encourage you not to post a thread starting one. Regardless of your level of experience, caliber is a personal preference and what is right for you may not be right for others.
ΜΟΛΩΝ ΛΑΒΕ: Buy These Stickers Here
"A man without ethics is a wild beast loosed upon the world" Albert Camus
Some caliber of bullets make bigger holes than others...just saying....
The poll... I answered yes, because I assume you mean good shot placement. If you shoot a completely non vital area, something like a 45 might have more impact on the person than a 9mm. If you mean a shot to a vital organ, then there is probably not enough difference to matter.
I answered no, too many variables.
USMC Shooting Team
Distinguished Pistol Shot Badge - 1986
Texas CHL since 1996.
Iraq 2004 to 2011.
Afghanistan 2012 to present.
I answered no, but it really depends on where that same shot is placed. In some places they would all yield the same results, in others, not so much.
Let your plans be dark and impenetrable as night, and when you move, fall like a thunder bolt...... Sun Tzu.
The supreme art of war is to defeat the enemy without fighting........ Sun Tzu.
Depends what you are shooting at.. A heart I would want the largest caliber to do the most damage. An engine block I would want the penetrating power of .357 sig. The important thing is finding a balance of power and recoil that works best for you to make you an accurate shooter as quickly as possible.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Be polite, be professional, but have a plan to kill everybody you meet. – Gen James Mattis USMC
If shot placement is between the eyes then all 4 are equal! However add a barrier I would base on our test of ballistic glass I would go with the 357 Sig or 40 S & W. But if it is a pelvic area shot I would say the 45ACP! But I carry a 357 Sig and shoot it very well so DON'T corn-fuse me with all those personal preferences! Any of the 4 will service you well if you train with them and can have rapid follow up shots! JMHO!
But then again maybe a 10mm or 50AE?
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
“It does not take a majority to prevail … but rather an irate, tireless minority, keen on setting brush fires of freedom in the minds of men!”
"In an insane society a sane man must appear insane." Spock & Movie "Serial"
Does the round make a difference? Yes! Does rage drugs sense of duty shear cussed meanness make a difference? Yes! If you over emphasize any one factor to the exclusion of others can it bite you? You betcha!
I answered yes, but only because I wanted to keep the results close.
All things being equal- same shot placement same number of shots delivered- I'll go with the bigger hole every time. But we don't live in a world where all things are equal. A platform will hold more 9mm than 45 ACP. Thus I'm left with a bit of a personal conundrum. There's a reason I own both. There's also a reason I've moved away from 40/357 Sig platforms- compromises don't give enough of any upside to mitigate the downside... to me.
Caliber preference is a personal decision. People that somehow wrap their self worth up in the caliber they pick are only fooling themselves. I'll keep carrying a 9mm with 124 gr +P Gold Dots on duty and off duty I'll sometimes pick a gun with the same load and sometimes I'll go with the 230 gr 45... because that's what I picked for myself that day.
"The only people I like besides my wife and children are Marines."
- Lt. Col. Oliver North