This is a discussion on Heavier 9mm JHPs within the Defensive Ammunition & Ballistics forums, part of the Defensive Carry Discussions category; Before you do that you might want to read http://www.neiassociates.org/caliber.htm Itís my understanding the heavier rounds are made for sub machine type weapons with longer ...
Before you do that you might want to read
Itís my understanding the heavier rounds are made for sub machine type weapons with longer barrels instead of handguns.
This test report seems to indicate differently fine short barrel (3.5") performance.
Some PD actual shooting results.
I love and agree completely with this part of your link:
In the final analysis, safety and being able to shoot the weapon accurately are the two most important aspects in the selection of a law enforcement handgun.
Spend few minutes learning about my journey from Zero to Athlete in this
Then check out my blog! www.BodyByMcDonalds.com
Cupcake - 100 pound loser, adventurer, Ironman Triathlete.
I think we are looking at two different test. The following links are my reference.
Federal HST 147gr
Comments: Finally, my favorite (and ccw carry ) round. The Federal 147gr HST. So powerful, it could take your head right off. Well er, hopefully.
Too many Dirty Harry movies lately :) Decent penetration, with the typical HST huge expansion, they continue to impress me with their performance.
For 9mm, I used the following rounds.
127gr Winchester Ranger T, +p+ pressure, factory load.
147gr Federal HST, standard pressure, factory load.
147gr Winchester Black Talon, standard pressure, factory load.
For 357 magnum, I used the following rounds.
158gr Speer Gold Dot, loaded by Double Tap. Does about 1400fps based on prior testing out of my 686.
125gr Remington Golden Saber, standard pressure, factory load.
The HST performaned as expected. In other words, fairly deep with excellent expansion. The one HST did look pretty deformed, but it was intact, so I have no doubts it would of done the job on a hostile. The Ranger's kinda surprised me this time. Shot #1 was very deformed, the core was almost bent back on itself. Shot #2 suffered a core/jacket separtion. I've seen this before with the ultra high speed Rangers, but the surprise factor was how badly bent back the sharp petals were on both rounds. This cut down on their overall expansion compared to the HST's, but gave some really deep penetration. I believe that these rounds during this test spent excessive amounts of energy penetrating at the cost of expanding. I suspect the 147gr Rangers would work a lot better, something to test in my next round of denim shots. Finally the Black Talons. Despite the MASSIVE hype I've heard about these rounds, they didn't do anything really shocking. They penetrated and expanded ok, but not near as good as the more modern rounds. I'm not real surprised about this result, though I admit the Black Talons did perform better then I would of guessed.
What about that says poorly?
When seconds count, police are only minutes away!
Buckeye Firearms Assoc. supporter
Life Member NRA