This is a discussion on Rate My Carry Ammo within the Defensive Ammunition & Ballistics forums, part of the Defensive Carry Discussions category; .32 - Hornady 60 gr. XTP (Seecamp) 9mm - 124 gr. HST (PM9, EMP, CZ 75 Compact) .40 - 165 gr. Gold Dot (Glock 23) ...
.32 - Hornady 60 gr. XTP (Seecamp)
9mm - 124 gr. HST (PM9, EMP, CZ 75 Compact)
.40 - 165 gr. Gold Dot (Glock 23)
.45 - 230 gr. +P Black Hills (5" Steel 1911)
.357 Mag - 158 gr. Buffalo Bore High Velocity (SP 101, 686)
all are HP's
Freedom of speech does not excuse those who are free from thought.
I can only comment on your .45 ACP load.
Why do you need +P in a full size 1911?
But that's only my opinion. It's your pistol.
When you’re wounded and left on Afghanistan’s plains,
And the women come out to cut up what remains,
Just roll to your rifle and blow out your brains,
And go to your God like a soldier.
If it's reliable, I can't argue with your choice, but... I fired those XTP .32s into everything from wet newspaper to water to the "test tube" goo and never got one to expand. I ended up trying the longest barrel I had in .32 (a Savage) and nothing even at contact range. The Hydra Shok was almost as bad. I use Cor Bon in my BUG .32. I prefer some expansion in my defensive ammo, even in the small stuff. If you prefer the deeper penetration in the smaller calibers, I think it will be better than FMJ in that it will dig into bone rather than skip off should it hit a rounded piece of bone like a rib or skull.
As for the other stuff, if it's reliable and you can hit with it where you need to hit, you have good ammo choices.
About the only thing I would change would be to go with the Buffalo Bore Hard Cast Flat Nose in your Seecamp.
The B Bore is probably the hardest hitting 32 ammo out there.
I'd choose the Buffalo Bore even if only for the good reduction of muzzle flash.
Liberty Over Tyranny Μολὼν λαβέ
I know for a fact that those .40 165gr Gold dots are good stuff.
Mixed Martial Arts Record= 2-0.......Kyokushin Karate Record=5-0
USMC.....helping enemies of America die for their countries since 1775
A person could LIVE with all those choices. As has been said, accuracy is so important.
I'd personally feel just as protected with a standard velocity 230 grain loading in the .45 ACP as I would with a +P loading.
I applaud the choice of the 158 grain load for the .357. If I regularly depended on this cartridge for self defense I'd go with something heavier than the 125 grain loads that get all the attention.
The only one I'd throw out is the weenie light bullet load in the .32 ACP. If I were toting a pistol so chambered I'd go for bullet weight and penetration over expansion. If. as has been mentioned, this load doesn't expand reliably despite the higher velocity derived by the light weight slug I'd toss it for sure. Trouble is, I seem to recall that the Seecamp originally had some special ammunition requirements that included light weight expanding bullets of some sort.
The Seecamp was originally listed for (Winchester) Silvertip only. IIRC FMJ was too long for the magazines.
All seem to be good choices. If they function and are reliable in you guns of choice. About the 32 I have a kel-tec p-32 and tried a few loads in wet newsprint. And got suprising results. Fired from 7 yards all the xtps expanded and penetrated 9 to 91/2 inches. Silvertips went 7 and none expanded. Hydra shocks 7 inches one expanded one didnt and one only halfway expanded. Im getting ready to try gold dot and the cor-bon We'll see hoe they do.