Originally Posted by
Eldon Hickey
Where defensive firearms are concerned, I'm a firm believer in K.I.S.S--"keep it simple stupid." Most gunfights are won by the guy who gets the first solid hit, so I'm attracted to the gun I feel will give me the best chance of getting off the first shot. Drawing a gun takes time--shooting from a pocket takes less. Most defensive gunfights occur at very short range, in low light, and involve fewer than 5 shots--50 yard 10 ring accuracy isn't required....the equiavelent of being able to "hit a bull in the ass with a scoopshovel" is usually sufficient. A gun that points naturally is an advantage as you may not be able to see your sights. Your opponent may be close enough to try to take your gun away, so it's nice to provide him a minimum of leverage and not much to grab hold of. In a hand to hand situation you may need to be able to make a contact shot. In a life and death struggle, mechanical malfunctions can prove fatal....I want the most reliable weapon available. For these reasons I carry a snubnose .38--LCR, Detective Special, or Model 36 and a speedstrip and speedloader. If I'm concerned about "magazine capacity" I have the option of carrying 2 guns ("New York reload)....10 or 12 shots with total weight less than a 1911. The advantages of wheelguns are too numerous to mention here.....very quick learning curve, reliability, etc. Bottom-feeders are all the rage these days, and I shudder to think how many Carry permit holders are running around with their brand new autoloaders thinking they have a dozen rounds or so ready to go when in effect they are carrying single-shots, having failed to invest in the 500 rounds or so needed to establish reliabilty. I firmly believe that, for most shooters, it's irresponsible to carry anything other than a revolver.