Question for the Engineers & Scientists ?
This is a discussion on Question for the Engineers & Scientists ? within the Defensive Carry Guns forums, part of the Defensive Carry Discussions category; There are frequent posts about the "breakin period" for new semiautomatic handguns. Most wonder about how many fired rounds predict reliability. A worthwhile question, since ...
5Likes

April 9th, 2011 09:28 AM
#1
Member
Array
Question for the Engineers & Scientists ?
There are frequent posts about the "breakin period" for new semiautomatic handguns. Most wonder about how many fired rounds predict reliability. A worthwhile question, since one's life may be involved.
From a PURELY STATISTICAL STANDPOINT (and I barely passed my college statistics course several decades ago) is there an answer?
If a brand new semiautomatic handgun, properly cleaned and lubricated, using fresh quality ammunition, fired the first 15 shots without any malfunction, what is the statistical probability it will fire the next 15 shots without malfunction?
Does that probability increase significantly if it fires the first 100 shots without malfunction. If so, how much?
If it isn't too complex, please show us the formula....
THANKS.
JERRY

April 9th, 2011 09:28 AM
Remove Ads

April 9th, 2011 09:51 AM
#2
Senior Member
Array
Simplistic probability dictates that the probability of the first 15 rounds fired is 1 (P(fire) = 15/15 = 1). Given there are no other factors influencing the outcome then the probability of the next fifteen rounds firing would also be one (P(fire) = 30/30 = 1)
At this point your probability can't increase, it can only go down. If your first 100 shots are fired without incident, they you're still at 1. If however, you have a misfire somewhere in the next 100 rounds, then your probability is now P(fire) = 199/200 = .995 Now from here it can go up. For example if you fire the last 800 rounds without incident they your final probability for 1000 rounds is P(fire) = 999/1000 = .999

April 9th, 2011 09:59 AM
#3
Senior Member
Array
I like simple.
The next logical step would be to break this down by ammunition type and individual magazine.
LEARN something today so you can TEACH something tomorrow.Dominus Vobiscum <))>(
Where is the wisdom that we have lost in knowledge?" T.S. Elliot

April 9th, 2011 10:14 AM
#4
Senior Member
Array
Some people really worry me

April 9th, 2011 12:51 PM
#5
VIP Member
Array
Voltage & Wattage are different <g>
Originally Posted by
highvoltage
Simplistic probability dictates that the probability of the first 15 rounds fired is 1 (P(fire) = 15/15 = 1). Given there are no other factors influencing the outcome then the probability of the next fifteen rounds firing would also be one (P(fire) = 30/30 = 1)
Have to disagree with your application of the formula.
A gun that's 95% reliable (i.e. misfires on one out of 20 shots, average) has a 46% chance of firing fifteen consecutive rounds without a malfunction. The 15/15 that you stated in the first equation is NOT "P(fire)" (a probability)  it is an outcome.
You could, after your first 15 shots, conclude that the probability of a misfire is something less than 1/15 (0.0667), so the probability of the next 15 shots being successful is .9933^15 (= 35.5%) or better.
If you've fired 100 consecutive good shots, then the probability of a misfire has been established at less than 1/100 (0.01). So, the probability of the next 15 shots being successful is 0.99^15 (= 86%) or better. The chance of the next 100 shots being flawless, on a purely statistical basis, can only be determined to be around 36% (0.99^100) or better. No matter how many times you fire a gun, you can never prove that it has a 100% chance of firing on the next shot, 'cause it just ain't so.
Hope this helps.
Regards,
Jim
Last edited by Kilowatt3; April 9th, 2011 at 12:56 PM.
Reason: Left out a decimal point.

April 9th, 2011 01:32 PM
#6
VIP Member
Array
Really not a question that can be answered simply. There are too many variables involved. Caliber, material the gun is made out of, and the manufacturing tolerances used are all going to play into it.
Freedom doesn't come free. It is bought and paid for by the lives and blood of our men and women in uniform.
USAF Retired
NRA Life Member

April 9th, 2011 01:34 PM
#7
Senior Member
Array
As I like to say, every break in shot puts you one closer to the first failure.
For a group of people as safety obsessed as to fear an empty gun shooting us, it's a paradox how much we fear a loaded one going "click".
I'm not a lawyer or a LEO, just a pantload with a computer.

April 9th, 2011 02:09 PM
#8
Senior Member
Array
I am not a scientist nor do I play one on TV, but my answer is very simple. Everytime you pull the trigger there is a 50% chance it will work and another 50% it will not. It does not matter if it is a Glock, HiPoint, etc. I hope this helps. God Bless

April 9th, 2011 02:16 PM
#9
VIP Member
Array
Missed in all of the above to some extent, the science of statistics involves conducting an experiment, collecting results, collating and analyzing the results, and drawing inferences, usually in the form of probability, from the results of the experiment.
What can be gleaned from an experiment depends on whether or not the experiment is adequate to the task of arriving at an answer.
Firing 15 shots and collecting a single percentage of results really gets you nowhere. Similarly, firing a single series of 100 consecutive shots and trying to extrapolate to the future from what is really only one result, won't get you anything.
Finally, nothing but experiments with lots of shots fired can incorporate the effects of wear, tear, accumulated dirt, on long term performance, which common sense tells us will degrade over time. In short, no matter what the results are with the first 100 to 1000 rounds, mechanical devices degrade with time and the results for the second 1000 rounds will possibly be a bit (or perhaps a great deal) worse.
Ever notice how the auto dealers like to tout the numbers for "initial reliability" or "initial customer satisfaction." These say nothing about what the car will be like after 3 years. Even a piece of junk might hold together for 10,000 miles.

April 9th, 2011 03:54 PM
#10
VIP Member
Array
A man boards a train carrying a gun going Eastbound.The train is doing 50 MPH................... ah forget

April 9th, 2011 04:32 PM
#11
VIP Member
Array
Originally Posted by
HKinNY
A man boards a train carrying a gun going Eastbound.The train is doing 50 MPH................... ah forget
Oh, you met my Algebra teacher.

April 9th, 2011 05:19 PM
#12
Member
Array
Get a good quality revolver....No breakin period,,,,less to go wrong,,,,,,,and since they are not as much fun to shoot as a semiauto, it will probably still be like new when you drop dead of old age.

April 9th, 2011 05:41 PM
#13
Ex Member
Array
Thing is, it isn't always "linear" like that. Some guns are super reliable up to a few hundred rounds, then have some part break that renders it inoperable. Your statistical projections would be useless in such an instance.
It's also why it's always worth waiting, with new guns, for someone to test it out for several hundred to thousands of rounds to see if something breaks. It's easy to watch a video or text review where the author fired maybe 100200 shots and had no failures, but it's going to suck when you buy it thinking it is reliable, only to have a trigger bar, recoil spring, or something else fail after 300 shots.

April 9th, 2011 06:26 PM
#14
VIP Member
Array
Originally Posted by
paul34
Thing is, it isn't always "linear" like that. Some guns are super reliable up to a few hundred rounds, then have some part break that renders it inoperable. Your statistical projections would be useless in such an instance.
It's also why it's always worth waiting, with new guns, for someone to test it out for several hundred to thousands of rounds to see if something breaks. It's easy to watch a video or text review where the author fired maybe 100200 shots and had no failures, but it's going to suck when you buy it thinking it is reliable, only to have a trigger bar, recoil spring, or something else fail after 300 shots.
This really raises an interesting question, I think. I've had one gun in which the recoil spring and guide rod failed dramatically after about 3 K rounds. I have another where I had to replace a manufacturer's original recoil spring with a Wolf spring, maybe with only about 1 K through it.
These experiences have made me think twice and three times about doing a lot of shooting with an SD gun. It is sort of like keep two guns handy, just in case. Or, go the revolver route. (And neither gun was a "poor quality" elcheapo.)
My experience would lead me to advise keeping 2 handy or sticking with a revolver. I do neither though, and I can't say that I really am all that comfortable relying on my two auto loaders.

April 9th, 2011 06:30 PM
#15
Senior Moderator
Array
If a brand new semiautomatic handgun, properly cleaned and lubricated, using fresh quality ammunition, fired the first 15 shots without any malfunction, what is the statistical probability it will fire the next 15 shots without malfunction?
If the gun in question is a "High Point", there is an excellent probability that something will break in the next 15 rounds.
Does that probability increase significantly if it fires the first 100 shots without malfunction. If so, how much?
Practical application and experience with various "High Point" pistols, would seem make that fact a near impossibility. While the math may seem to make it possible that it could in fact happen that the High Point could shoot 100 rounds without malfunction, it would be about as possible as walking both coasts and finding an ancient gold coin washed up on the beach. Sure it happens, but not often enough to be of any real concern.
I would rather stand against the cannons of the wicked than against the prayers of the righteous.
AR. CHL Instr. 07/02 FFL
Like custom guns and stuff? Check this out...
http://bobbailey1959.wordpress.com/
Posting Permissions
 You may not post new threads
 You may not post replies
 You may not post attachments
 You may not edit your posts

Forum Rules
Search tags for this page
how do the police prove you shot a gun at a certain point and time
,
how many round to break in a new semiauto
,
how often to change recoil springs inn ruger lcp
,
i am an engineer because i stayed at a holiday inn
,
percentage chance on hand gun misfiring
,
taurus scientists engineers
,
what is the percentage chance for a gun misfire
Click on a term to search for related topics.