Thanks for all the feedback folks.
Very well done, and thanks for your hard work. This is a subject near and dear to me as I am a revolver guy from way back. I use a Dan Wesson .357 and have for over thirty years, what I like about a revolver is when you pull the trigger it's going to go bang just about 100 percent of the time, in fact in my 30 plus years I have never had one fail to fire. Semi auto pistols are great fun to shoot, I have several different ones of different calibers that I shoot regularly but when it comes to protecting my life, my wife, kids and grand kids I just feel more at ease using a revolver because I know it will go bang when the trigger is pulled. Thanks again for your hard work.
I think the highlighted portion sums it up very well. A novice shooter who will probably never practice again (unfortunately a higher % of gun owners than we would like to admit) would be much better served with a revolver. Nothing to manipulate, just point and press the trigger. An often overlooked advantage of a revolver is that you can leave it loaded for a much longer period of time without having to worry about magazine springs taking a set (if you worry about that kind of thing, that is).
I cut my teeth on a .22caliber Ivers Johnson top break super 8. ( Thanks Grandpa ) It now resides in my safe when not at the Range. ( Thanks Dad ) My first hand gun purchase was a S&W police special .38, which I later sold to buy a Ruger Super Red Hawk .44 for hunting.
Long live the revolver
Another job well done JD.
Awesome post, JD.
JD - good job. The only thing I would add is that removing the lock from a S&W is child's play. I removed the locks from my 640 & 642. Neither procedure took longer than 15 minutes. The second one was done in under 10. Sure, you still have the lock hole, (it looks the same as before you took the lock out), but if that does not bother you, then they are easier to find.
Not only is removing the lock from a S&W trivially easy - a 10 year old could do it in a few minutes - but you can get a very nice insert that matches the frame metal and finish and eliminates the hole in the frame. You can order here. (registration required)
This being the case, a lock is a non-issue on a new Smith. All my Smiths were bought NIB pre-lock, but I'm pondering a 2.5" 638 and if it has a lock I have a plan.
Excellent post, thoroughly enjoyed the read. Much of what you covered is exactly why I now carry the revolver as my primary CC gun.
I'll tell you what's funny is that at least twice since posting this as I've been dry practicing with two different autos I've either been sliced open by the rear sight of an XDM or sliced open by the ejection port of an HK45, neither are known for being "edgy" but I've torn up my left thumb pretty good each time. Tap, rack, band-aid, :rant::censored::rant:, bang. I imagine it's harder (not impossible) to beat your self up with a revolver. :yup:
Nice job. Thank you taking the time to do this.
Great post !!! As the boomers age, I am 55 , I am finding shooting my revolvers are much more enjoyable than the auto. Various heath issues have
made raking the slides on the auto's difficult.I own glock,spingfield1911,springfield-walther99,ruger lcp,s&w sigma (don't laughthis has over 2k rounds no failures of any kinds)
My ruger security- stainless i bought 1983 357 I love shooting this revolver.
Charter bulldog 44spl (son of sam) 1977 Weighs 21 oz empty. Kicks like a mule with defensive loads.
Kudos to DC for allowing a revolver forum. I noticed that on another Internet forum today a guy was banned simply for posting why he thought the revolver was a superior way to go. This on a forum that constantly prides itself on being all about "I am the warrior" and being able to fight with what you have.
A revolver might not be the way I would go but to ban somebody just for talking about a revolver because it doesn't fall in line with your Glock 17 red dot pistol view of the world is pretty shallow.
Again, thanks DC.
Thank-you, I enjoyed it immensely. I have a Taurus .44 stainless 6.5 inch produced in 1997 that has been flawless in form and finish.
I have more recently purchased a Taurus .357 4 inch primarily for the 8 round capacity which I feel is a nice compromise between a six shooter and a semi-auto without sacrificing stopping power.
The detail on the newer one (.357) doesn't seem as crisp as the .44, and defintely not on par with the comparable model S&W, but it has proved reliable for a not so frequent shooter like me and I have confidence in it as a self defense piece.