Which old S&W would you choose?

[C hawk Glock]

Here is the deal...

I have a friend that had a major life changing event. He and I met because of our love and passion for S&W wheel guns. We both belong to a shooting club and shot the shat a long with targets quite a bit. He has a few years on me and a few guns on me. We have really hit it off over the last few years as he has showed me his collection of wheel guns because he knew how much I appreciated them.

He is now moving out of the country and to a place in which he cannot take any of his firearms. He had offered me pick of the litter. I want to reach out to my fellow revolver guys and ask what I should pick.

If you could have any of the classic models that are either mint or unfired what would they be? Note* all display boxes and parts are included. They are truly amazing.

[DefensiveCarry.com]

[red13]

All of them? M29, for sure.

[C hawk Glock]

All of them? M29, for sure.

I can only swing the cost of about two of them.

[msgt/ret]

It would be a toss up between an M-29 or a M-25 in either 45LC or 45ACP.

[C hawk Glock]

It would be a toss up between an M-29 or a M-25 in either 45LC or 45ACP.

He has both!

[msgt/ret]

He has both!

In that case I would have to go with the M-25 preferably in 45LC, around here M-29s are plentiful but M-25s are as scarce as honest politicians.

[pogo2]

I also like older S&W revolvers, have a number of them, and believe your friend's offer is a rare opportunity for you.

I would suggest that an N frame S&W, like the models 29 or 25 you are discussing, would be an excellent choice. I am also partial to the model 27 in .357 magnum. If your friend had the 3.5 inch model or the 8-3/8 inch model in mint condition I would be very tempted by that.

I have owned the 8-3/8 inch model 27 for 40 years. I bought it used in the late 60s and it is not in mint condition, but it is a remarkable gun for shooting. The trigger is impeccable, and given its long sight radius and heavy weight, it is like shooting a rifle rather than a handgun.

[rainmaker]

How about a 38/44 ? Nice old classic revolver, not sure what if any model number. Had one once upon a time - ate everything you could stick in.

[glockman10mm]

M19, M10. I think that the k frames have the very best actions Smith ever produced, 357 and 38 are infinitely usable and cheaper to feed. Also the M15 would be a great aquisition.

[Glockwatcher]

It's probably too tedious, but a listing, or better yet, pictures of what you have to choose from would be interesting.

But so far the Model 25 seems most interesting to me.

[21bubba]

Model 19 in any barrel.

[automatic slim]

I have a M-29-2 6.5" Blue thats strictly a safe queen, a M-25-5 in .45LC also a safe queen. I used to have a M-27 with 8 3/8" barrel, but I always wanted the version with the 3.5". I haven't seen one in at least 20 years.

[gasmitty]

Did I miss something? No link or pics to the collection...

[C hawk Glock]

Did I miss something? No link or pics to the collection...

Hi,

I don't have pics yet. I will try to get some posted this saturday. This has been a tough time for my buddy and even though he is really wanting a couple of these to go to me, I am trying to be respectful, but frankly I feel like a kid in a candy store.

[MNBurl]

See if he has a registered magnum. That is what I would choose.
A Model 19 2.5, 3 or 4"
A Model 15 2" snubbie is always a great find

I love K-frames.