This is a discussion on Youtube Video: Guy shoot himself on leg while drawing from holster within the Defensive Carry Guns forums, part of the Defensive Carry Discussions category; This is one reason I only CCW a DAO pistol. This guy is on a certain level of poor mechanics but the best is that ...
This is one reason I only CCW a DAO pistol.
This guy is on a certain level of poor mechanics but the best is that one older fellow that seems to pick up guns and flip them or something like a pitcher picking up a ball to throw...can't remember who it was but immediately turned off the video I was watching of him review some newer pocket pistol like the Micro DE or LCP.
Again...the holster does not have advertised mind control features--it cannot force you to do anything. Like any other piece of equipment, it requires training and discipline. If the finger is on the trigger during the draw, it's because the shooter wants it there....not because the holster "made him/her do it".
Magazine <> clip - know the difference
martyr is a fancy name for crappy fighter
You have never lived until you have almost died. For those that have fought for it, life has a special flavor the protected will never know
Given the dumb gun **** people post on the YouTube, I can't believe we don't have numerous self-inflicted gunshot wounds to look at. Maybe everyone else was a little embarrassed and took their bullet hole videos down.
It is amazing how some of you are attacking the guy for his admitted screw up. His whole intent was to possibly show someone else what not to do and that was rather upstanding of him to do so. As to the holsters and guns. I have an XD with a thumb release style holster and I have a SERPA that I use for my CZ75B so I know the two different styles. The first thing to keep in mind is that his two pistols operate totally different. In his case the Glock is a striker fired pistol in which you have to engage the trigger to move to the firing position and then exert enough pressure to break the sear. With the thumb release holster the motion is the same as any draw in that you keep your trigger finger straight and hope that your thumb hits the release properly (training). If you don't the gun does not move, it stays locked in place and you try to pull your pants up. The SERPA uses a trigger finger sweep of the locking mechanism to release and unlike what many of you are saying my finger always ends up on the slide. It does not end up on the trigger at all. Now back to the guns and his mistake. I can see where if he had done an extensive amount of practice with the thumb release that day and did not clear his head that he may have swept his thumb on the safety of the 1911. Due to the 1911 having a straight back push to operate the trigger rather than an arc and with most 1911 pistols in the 4 pound range on their triggers (if not modified?), it is easy to see in his hurried attempt to try and get the pistol out of the holster that the trigger was engaged. His proper response when he encountered the resistance should have been to keep the trigger finger away from the gun, allowed the gun to be re-holstered and then taken a deep breath, checked his equipment (safety) and tried again. He didn't, the safety had been kicked off with his draw stroke, his finger engaged the 1911 trigger and he went to the hospital. Was the fact that the camera filming away caused him to feel the need to hurry? Only he can tell us that. Lesson - be familiar with the manual of arms for the weapon system that you are carrying (gun and holster). Practice extensively with an unloaded pistol with that system. If changing the system allow enough time to adapt to the new system with an unloaded pistol to gain proficiency before going hot. It still boils down to the ultimate safety, the brain.
He is very lucky. Lessons learned...
Glock Cert. Armorer
DEFINITELY.i take from him---never move faster than you can stop.
its an old lesson, bears repeating though.
One thing that I learned from *all* of my teachers was that firearms are not toys, and when you're out on that range, as fun as it is, it's -NOT- a game. Think something is wrong? *stop*. Yes, as my proficiency increases, so will my expectations - and abilities - for rectifying "speed bumps" improve, but for the time being, I'm still on the "slow is smooth" side of the fence, and not even paying mind to the other half of that equation. I'll get there, eventually, but that will come after hours and hours...and more hours...of practice.
FWIW, I don't think that the shooter is an idiot.
I do think that he needs more attentive practice, but then again, I know I definitely do, and I'd bet that even those of you who are highly skilled in your craft - professionals or hobbyists - also think that you do, too. In many professions, we call what we do our "practice." That's to acknowledge the fact that we're continuing to learn, continuing to strive towards perfection or mastery...which, ironically, we know that we will never truly be able to reach, as there's always that next rung to be climbed.
I am thankful that this particular shooter was not hurt more than he was, and what's more, I'm thankful that he took the time, even in his obviously less-than-comfortable state, to post-up what had happened, and to share it without editing or obfuscation of the facts.
In this way, we may all learn, and I think that particularly for newbies like me, it just may save someone a limb, or a life.
I also occasionally practice drawing and firing my real guns by using snap-caps instead of live ammo. I still point them at a safe place just in case I somehow screwed up and put live ammo in them, so far that has never happened though. Unfortunately, this only simulates the first shot, because with the lack of a recoil and loud noise, it is hard to say how well or quickly you could take that next shot.
The guy reminds me of the fella that blew a hole in his foot with his 1911 .... Unbelievable.
The guy in this video is so lucky he wasn't shooting JHP, that's all I can say.
"He that hath no sword, let him sell his garment, and buy one." – Luke 22:36
"If a law is unjust, a man is not only right to disobey it, he is obligated to do so." – Thomas Jefferson
There has to be a Kimber joke in there somewhere... just kidding
I suggest he settle on a single holster design, preferably one that does not use a trigger finger squeeze.
Very, very lucky guy. Lesson learned for all.
I hope he has a speedy recovery.
What we've got here is failure to communicate.
he owns up ( he admits with a but-if and anything following that starts to sound like a back-door excuse) to making a mistake
which has little to do with equipment or how much or how different they are. it has everything to do with moving faster than he can stop and
keeping the finger off the trigger till....but we all know that rule,
paramedic--says it best with there is the potential to have an ND
not all shooter will have one. those that have 1 will not have 2.
anyone has 2 should sell their guns: seriously.
an ND during testing does not count: like a decocker on a CZ-52 or a stuck firing pin on a mil-serp;
these are under controlled conditions.
as for filling in dead air--he could have edited it. that he left it in rather goes to him meaning it and he loses me there.
You plug 'em, I plant 'em
...kid can't read at 17 (Garcia/Hunter 1985)
Lack of preparation on your part does not necessarily constitute an emergency on mine
One thing I notice in the video that I have not seen discussed yet is what he does with his pistol after shooting himself. Instead of holstering it, he lays it on the ground. Is this a correct response and is that firearm now to be considered unsecured? I believe he should have holstered the pistol.