This is a discussion on Paranoid about my gun... within the Defensive Carry Guns forums, part of the Defensive Carry Discussions category; Originally Posted by itschuck Hmmm..I don't think I have ever heard of a 229 having issues unless they were the fault of the shooter. I ...
Well, I think the big reason for my paranoia is that this is one of my first guns. I had a Glock 23 for a while, but after shooting my uncle's P228, I fell in love with the SIG. I loved the ergonomics and I shot it better than the Glock as well. So, I ended up trading the Glock in for the SIG (they gave me a good deal). I do intend to get another Glock soon though (probably a 9mm this time though).
While I've handled guns for a while now, this SIG is one of the first guns I've actually personally owned and have had to personally maintain, so I guess I'm just not as well versed in what type of abuse guns can typically take as I should. The first gun I actually bought was a Glock 23 (not the one I traded for the SIG). That gun after the first few hundred rounds started giving me failure to feeds on every magazine. I took it to a few armorers who saw nothing wrong externally with the gun, and the store was nice enough to let me trade it in for a new Glock 23 at no cost (this is the one I ultimately traded for the SIG). We were able to determine that it was not due to limp wristing because I was able to shoot two other Glock 23s (one rental and the one I traded for) without a single problem. This probably is causing some of the paranoia as well - my first experience with a new gun was a bad one.
I appreciate the comments though and understand completely how ridiculously paranoid I am sounding - just need some perspective perhaps.
I recommend that you do this to strengthen your grip. Then you can shoot a Glock. 8-)
Grip workout for shooters! YouTube
Ccccccc what? Ccccccccccc Hawks!
Glocks have the rep of being flawless, yet you hear of recoil spring problems and extractor issues. My new M&P has a striker issue, and will go back to Smith after the annual shutdown. 1911s will not feed JHPs out of the box reliably (so you may hear). I have also heard of QC issues with SIG. However, the 229 E2 that I bought in April has not. I have nowhere near 700 rounds through mine, more like 100. And I carry it with total confidence. Pick a gun, any breed you like, pretend you bought it yesterday, and then search the Internet for problems with the gun you are pretending you just bought. You will find them. 700+ rounds? No failures? Listen to your gun, not the folks condemning it. You have an excellent weapon, just happens to be my favorite. If you are that stressed out about it (and you shouldn't be, as the gun has certainly proved itself), get a J frame for a BUG. No matter what other gun you may wish you had bought, that other gun has had issues. They ALL have.
But, if you don't trust it then you don't trust it. But unless you give us more info it seems like the problem is between your ears and not the guns.
Boy, I wish I could tell you something absolute, but a gun can fail no matter what it is.
1. That many rounds, it should be reliable.
2. BUT, I had one gun that I had about 600 rounds in (Not a sig) that had shot flawlessly all of the time. I carried it often. Then I went out to the range one day to practice.... it would not fire but one shot at a time, and have to chamber the next round. I sent it to the Mfgr and they "fixed" all right, they sent me a entirely new gun except for the barrel. But, my confidence in the gun was zero, even though it's been shooting consistently now, I won't carry it.
After that, I began carrying my revolvers again much much much more often, and 2 other guns that I am totally confident in.
If it's not failing, you have a 90% chance it will be reliable when you need it.
I don't make jokes. I just watch the government and report the facts. --- Will Rogers ---
Chief Justice John Roberts : "I don't see how you can read Heller and not take away from it the notion that the Second Amendment...was extremely important to the framers in their view of what liberty meant."
I would suggest you never carry a Taurus....you will end up in therapy.
Kimbers are the guns you show your friends....Glocks are the ones you show your enemies.
Your gun will show wear on the rails---it's a fact of life.
Like any other firearm that gets used, eventually ALL guns will require servicing...usually the springs.
The first thing you will usually have problems with is the magazine--this is known for all semi-automatics.
Scratches aren't blemishes....the are reflections of character of the firearm. If you're going to wrap your gun in a diaper and leave it in the safe, sell it to someone who will use it.
If you want confidence in your gun, take a multi-day firearms course. You will put about 1000 rounds through your gun.
I also have a P229 in .40 S&W....and have about 13K rounds through it. How do I know? I have 13 empty ammo cans that held 1000 rds/each
Magazine <> clip - know the difference
martyr is a fancy name for crappy fighter
You have never lived until you have almost died. For those that have fought for it, life has a special flavor the protected will never know
Practice, practice, then practice some more - malfunction drills.
Do it static. Do it moving. Do it cowering behind cover as your instructor is yelling in your "ear." Do it in the rain or with snow on your hands. Do it with gloves.
Any situation you can see yourself in - and possibly even just imagine - do it.
Methinks you need to live with the SIG and get past this feeling. You're obsessing about phantom issues and the same phantom issues will arise again if you switch guns.
Charter Member of the DC .41 LC Society "Get heeled! No really"
“No possible rapidity of fire can atone for habitual carelessness of aim with the first shot.”
Theodore Roosevelt, The Wilderness Hunter, 1893
I have a Sig P6 in 9mm and a Sig P229 in 40 (and a 357 sig barrel for it as well).
I have run about 5k rounds of 40 and about 500 rounds of 357sig through the 229 without a single issue. I bought it used so God knows how many rounds when through it before I got it.
The P6 is an old West German Police pistol made in April 1991. I have had a couple of FTF with it but was able to trace the issue back to the ammo.
Sig makes a good product. Glock and Smith & Wesson and Sig compete for market share everywhere. I would feel equally comfortable with any of the three as a defensive weapon.
All of the bug names have, at some point, had a QC issue. They learn from their mistakes and correct them & move on.
"I've seen things you people wouldn't believe. Attack ships on fire off the shoulder of Orion. I watched c-beams glitter in the dark near the Tannhäuser Gate. All those moments will be lost in time, like tears in rain."
- Roy Batty
I think everyone is missing the point this gentleman is making.
He has an issue with 'paranoia' not with his HG. It's a temporary mental problem, similar to feeling unsafe in your own home if you have a robbery, or feeling like you can't drive in traffic after having a wreck. They seem irrational, but at the time, very real.
Just note the feelings and carry on normally, it will subside over time. Remember it's not about the HG, it's your irrational feelings which came from somewhere, so you're not nuts, just hypersensitive, or 'sensitized'.