This is a discussion on Lcr, 642, 442??? within the Defensive Carry Guns forums, part of the Defensive Carry Discussions category; Originally Posted by oneshot Wow^^^^^^^ Wish I would have saw that before I went to the local GS and bought a 642 & 442 for ...
NRA Certified Rifle/Pistol Instructor
Accuracy ALWAYS WINS! So carry what you can hit with.
If you find yourself in a fair fight your tactics stink.
I have owned both a 642 and LCR 357. The 642 and 442 are essentially the same but different color.
I loved the trigger on the LCR, but it's fall from grace for me was how easy it was to short stroke the trigger.
I now own and and carry a 340pd(basically a 442 but shoots .357) daily.
I would have to handle the LCR and the 442 and then make up my mind , though I'm leaning towards the LCR.
The LCR would also be my choice. I would also be interested in the 22lr if they had a 22mag conv. version.
I debated this recently and got the 642, although I liked the trigger on the LCR better. The 642/442 is smaller and lighter and in the end none of them are range guns so the slight trigger difference doesn't matter.
Sent using Tapatalk, thanks for supporting it on this site.
I carried a 442 as back up until the LCR357 came out. I like shooting and carrying 357 Snubs. The LCR makes shooting 357 easy for me so it took over the back up gun position. I still carry the 442 once in a while but prefer to carry Two 357 Subs.
While Ruger and Smith both make good guns, I personally prefer the S&Ws. I have a 642, which is my summer/cargo shorts/tank-top carry gun. I chose it over the 442 simply because of finish durability. I actually like the looks of the 442 better, but was told by the LGS that the finish would scratch. So, I bought the 642. I've had/have several S&Ws in various calibers, and love every one of them. Just my .02.
Live to ride, ride to live. Harley Road King And keep a .45 handy Kimber Custom TLE II
I have both a 642 and an LCR .357. With .38 Special and plus P ammo, I personally am far more accurate with the Ruger. As a caveat, that could be due in part to the larger Hogue grip. I like the trigger pull better on the Ruger as well as the sights. I carry the LCR in a pancake holster and it works well. If you want to pocket carry, the Smith has an edge due to the smaller grip. As another poster pointed out, one could always put a smaller grip on the Ruger for easier pocket carry. You can't go wrong with either weapon.
I have a 642 and added the Crimson Trace LG 405 laser grips. I find those grips to improve my actual grip on the gun, accuracy, and recoil management. And those improvements have nothing to do with the laser capability.
"Everybody wants to go to heaven, but nobody wants to die." Joe Lewis
I wanted to buy a snubby revolver and so I went to the range here in Georgia. I put 50 rounds through all 3 of the rental guns in the Ruger LCR, Smith 642 and Smith 442. I kinda had my mind fixed on the Ruger as I like the Ruger revolvers as I have a couple of Security and Police Service Sixes. But, I also have a Smith Model 65-3 3" as well. Anyways. I shot all 3 and to be honest, the 642 shot the best for me. Now, these are range guns that have been worked over and both the Smith's were the No Lock, No Dash version so early 90's models not the new ones with the lock. The Ruger shot well too. I just didn't like the feel of it while shooting it even with the grip. Now, I wanted to say, Pachmayr makes a presentation grip that makes shooting the 642/442 much much better to shoot. I found an older model 642 with no lock for $325.00 out the door at a pawn shop, found some Pachmayr J-Frame grips at another pawn shop for 5 bucks and it's my EDC now in front pocket. It's a true stainless too not the matte stainless. I eventually got a 442-1 for $300.00 out the door and it's my backup/truck gun. I put a set of Pachmayr's on it as well and it shoots well just have to work the trigger in some to make it smoother.
If you guys don't like the Uncle Mike's Conceal grips get a set of the Pachmayr Presentations and it'll make it much much better to shoot.
Just my $0.02
It's really a case of pick your version of awesome. All great guns. I carry the LCR and it's tiny, THIN, light weight, and has a sweet trigger. Hard to go wrong with quality snubbies.
I've owned two smith snobnoses and My preference is a Ruger revolver.Ruger are overbuilt and little rough on the trigger if you don't shoot it alot.A trigger job may go a long ways for the fussy 10 percent.Price point is similar,so you pickem.
I've got both, an LCR .38 and a S&W 642. Both have Crimson Trace on them, and I'll say that with the CT grip and +P, that combination hurts (at least it hurts me). With non +P, both are great, but I choose the LCR for the trigger.
Glock Certified Armorer