opinions on the glock 23 or Sig p229 both 40 cal.

[eagleeye]

If you were to pick one for carry which one would it be and why?
Thanks

It's not help me decide anything just real curious.

I have hearing a lot about these two guns and just want some different opinions from a different source.

thanks

[DefensiveCarry.com]

[Cold Shot]

Glock or sig

[apvbguy]

it all depends on which one feels better in your hand and which one you shoot better

[eagleeye]

[QUOTE=Cold Shot;2181844]Glock or sig[/QUOTE


I know I started that but this question is now on two specific guns for carry the g23 or the sig 229 only.
That was a question on reliability and durability and surprisingly te poll is coming out almost even.

[eagleeye]

it all depends on which one feels better in your hand and which one you shoot better

It doesn't matter what feels good or shoots good from my hands I'm just asking for what you think.

[claude clay]

think of the children

i mean your grand kids sitting around in 50 years admiring gran-dad's really cool Sig
...now substitute 'glock' for 'sig' and how does it read?

[eagleeye]

think of the children

i mean your grand kids sitting around in 50 years admiring gran-dad's really cool Sig
...now substitute 'glock' for 'sig' and how does it read?

Do you really want me to answer that?!

[Cold Shot]

[QUOTE=eagleeye;2181850]

Glock or sig[/QUOTE


I know I started that but this question is now on two specific guns for carry the g23 or the sig 229 only.
That was a question on reliability and durability and surprisingly te poll is coming out almost even.

o, you started that one, too. weird. wouldn't have expected that. just pick one.

[eagleeye]

[QUOTE=Cold Shot;2181860]

o, you started that one, too. weird. wouldn't have expected that. just pick one.

Whats weird about that?

I'm just asking a ? about two specific guns .

[AZ Hawk]

Seriously, choose one and be done with it. You've seen the poll results from your last thread, and this thread will be no different.

think of the children

i mean your grand kids sitting around in 50 years admiring gran-dad's really cool Sig
...now substitute 'glock' for 'sig' and how does it read?

It reads the same minus the substitution of one word.

[OldVet]

All else being equal, Glock for the lighter weight.

[Old School]

I carry a Glock-23 for CCW and have for over 10 years. I carried it for a uniform duty weapon for 3 years before going over to a Glock 21 and only because the G-21 was required.

Resonable cost, reliable, easy to maintain, as accurate as I can shoot and from personal expierence great customer service.

I like Glock.

Regards,

OS

[eagleeye]

Seriously, choose one and be done with it. You've seen the poll results from your last thread, and this thread will be no different.



It reads the same minus the substitution of one word.

Seriously if my threads bother you I'm sorry but just ignore if thats te case.
this is different then the poll I started here I am asking opinions on two specific guns as I have said before.

[DaveJay]

I like Sig...I own and carry a Glock 23...

If you want a recommendation, go with the Glock...

But that's just me...

[AZ Hawk]

Seriously if my threads bother you I'm sorry but just ignore if thats te case.
this is different then the poll I started here I am asking opinions on two specific guns as I have said before.

They don't bother me per se, it's just that the opinions from the last thread are all still valid and mostly unchanged here.

For example, here is my opinion from the last thread, nearly word for word:

My current EDC is the Gen 4 Glock 23. If I'm not carrying it, I'm carrying a Gen 3 Glock 19.

Why do I like my Glocks? Here are some the reasons:

They are lightweight, thin (for a double stack magazine), extremely reliable, resistant to corrosion and rust, require little maintenance, have significantly fewer parts than other semiautomatic pistols on the market (less things can break), low bore axis = lower felt recoil and the Gen 4 dual recoil spring reduces felt recoil further, parts are cheap and available making them easy to stock up on, etc.

Sig makes fine firearms, too, but I love my Glocks.

(One more thing: the "low" price of Glocks has allowed me to purchase a backup of both the Glock 23 and the Glock 19 for practice and/or replacement in the case of a problem with a main. Also, if you have to shoot someone in SD, you won't see that gun for a very long time, not to mention that anything mechanical can fail. Assuming that higher price = higher reliability is a fallacy. Look no further than BMW's and Range Rovers...).