Which had more revolutionary impact: Colt 1911 or Glock? - Page 3

Which had more revolutionary impact: Colt 1911 or Glock?

This is a discussion on Which had more revolutionary impact: Colt 1911 or Glock? within the Defensive Carry Guns forums, part of the Defensive Carry Discussions category; Revolutionary Impact. 1911 or Glock. Hmmmm. 1911 Swinging link that unlocks barrel from the slide. There were plenty of other semi auto around at the ...

View Poll Results: Which had more revolutionary impact on handguns: Glock or Colt 1911?

Voters
140. You may not vote on this poll
  • Glock

    14 10.00%
  • Colt 1911

    102 72.86%
  • They were equally influential

    24 17.14%
Page 3 of 4 FirstFirst 1234 LastLast
Results 31 to 45 of 48
Like Tree19Likes

Thread: Which had more revolutionary impact: Colt 1911 or Glock?

  1. #31
    Member Array Ecucmgt's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Location
    Nc
    Posts
    35
    Revolutionary Impact. 1911 or Glock. Hmmmm. 1911 Swinging link that unlocks barrel from the slide. There were plenty of other semi auto around at the time and many different breech locking mechanisms. The swinging link system is in probably 90% of the non blowback semi autos. The glock barrel cam is the same action as the 1911. Beretta uses a locking block or rotating barrel on some models. So I'm gonna have to say 1911 has that revolutionary design feature. The grip safety was added later at the request of the cavalry. The original safety was pretty small. A tiny tab that is nothing like the later more refined versions. The grip on the 1911 feels great but I would not call that revolutionary. I love the 1911 but that is all I think is Revolutionary.

    Now to the Glock. What is revolutionary. A guy with no experience with guns assembles a group a designs a masterpiece on the first try. Brownings father was a gunsmith and browning had several attempts untill he got the 1911 right. OK so Gaston had the advantage of new technology. Yes Browning was a more mechanical genius without question. Gaston wanted to produce a gun for his countries armed forces. So did JMB. Here is what's revolutionary. Using plastic grip frames with good triggers and offering extreme relibility. The HK VP70 was the first plastic framed handgun and had high cap 9mm magazines. But from what I can tell, the really bad trigger pull, high cost, and limited marketing caused poor sales and led to its lack of sucess. They Glock frame would not rust or show wear like steel or aluminum.

    It also happened to weigh alot less than even aluminum. It has actually proven better suited to heavy loads versus the steel 1911. Remeber the Colt Delta Elite 10mm auto. They eventually crack from all the battering. While the Glock 20 with a plastic frame is the only gun that continually handles the abuse. Ok next on the revolutionary side. Gaston used a non firearm finish. The Tennifer process that gets into the metal is amazing. In 1986 no other gun manufacturers had anything like this. So there is revolutionary. After that the rest of the indusrty tried to come up with better process's than 200 year old chemical rust finishes. I have seen a glock evidence gun that the police recovered after being submerged over 8 months in a river. The only spot that had any rust was three spots on the slide where rocks had finally worh thorugh to the bare metal. The gun was cleaned up after being sold back to a dealer. The rest of the finish was great. The 1911 won't do that. JMB didn't use stainless either. OK what else. Gaston added simplicity to the design and manufacture of the gun.

    They overall cost of the weapon was low with the quality being high. Somehow Gaston got his gun to function with huge ammounts of dirt and abuse yet still be reliable and accurate. The 1911 that JMB made was a much loser fit gun to allow for functioning under battlefield conditions. The super tight 1911's we have today won't handle the dirt like a glock will. Also everything you read about the first 1911's is that the have soft steel. Heat treating improved between WWI to WWII. So the glock has a more revolutionary frame. He used a material that people didn't think was worthy and changed the whole freakin industry. How many gun companies are making frames out of polymer now. Heck even the High end STI 1911 wide body race guns have plastic grips.

    The 1911 is a great gun. The Glock is even better. John Moses Browning was a brilliant innovator that built plenty of variations of the same theme. He did not have the ability to make plastic frames that would stand up to recoil better than steel. But if JMB were still alive today hw would not be like gun snobs of today and hold something against a pistol that had a plastic frame. I think he would take a long look at the design and execution and congratulate Gaston on a fine piece of weaponry. Yes the 1911 is more beautiful than the slab sided utilitarianess of the glock. The glock has grown on me just as pure function being beautiful. When I look at the other polymer guns out there today. They have slides and frames that are being designed to be more stylish or sexy. But without much added function. I love the 1911 but Glock has done a better job and imagine how refined it will be in 100 years.
    Last edited by JD; April 20th, 2012 at 05:14 PM. Reason: spaced out text.
    bmcgilvray likes this.


  2. #32
    VIP Member Array glockman10mm's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Location
    Kentucky
    Posts
    9,131
    Don't forget the Luger, almost, became this countries service handgun.
    bmcgilvray likes this.
    Ignorance is a long way from stupid, but left unchecked, can get there real fast.

  3. #33
    Member Array Walden's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2012
    Location
    Texas
    Posts
    171
    Quote Originally Posted by Kilowatt3 View Post
    I would argue that the BHP was the first "Wonder 9", in 1935, but for some reason, the concept never really took off until the '70's with the M92 and the CZ75.
    The Hi-Power was a great gun, no doubt. However, it weighed 1000 grams. Compare that to the 630 gram weight of the Glock 17 (what I consider to be a true "wonder nine"). The development of modern 9mm JHP ammo also helped spark the flame of the wonder nines, and this better ammo was not available in the years of the BHP
    "Though defensive violence will always be a 'sad necessity' in the eyes of men of principle, it would be still more unfortunate if wrongdoers should dominate just men." - St. Augustine

  4. #34
    Distinguished Member Array RevolvingMag's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Location
    Rock Hill, SC- Across Town From Where All the Homicides Happen
    Posts
    1,269
    Gotta say 1911. Browning did an amazing thing- he created the semi-auto handgun. There were others before it, but... That design had been copied, and produced 'new' for over 100 years. How can you REALLY compare a tupperware handgun to that?


    In all fairness, and honesty, I think Glocks are great guns- just not for me.
    "Rock and load, lock and roll... what's it matter? FIRE!!"

    "Gun control means hitting your target every time."

    Please take everything I say with at least one grain of salt- I am a very sarcastic person with a very dry sense of humor.

  5. #35
    Distinguished Member Array Spec's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2009
    Location
    Metro Detroit Area
    Posts
    1,716
    I voted 1911 because of the history and time that it came about. the 1911 saved a lot of lives during the World Wars, the old service revolvers that were under powered and under capacity for war. That is why I voted for the 1911... but Mr. G. Glock did do a great thing. With out him I don't know if I'd have my awesome polymer framed M&P the way it is now.
    NRA Certified Rifle/Pistol Instructor
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G18CFw0lnD8

    Accuracy ALWAYS WINS! So carry what you can hit with.

    If you find yourself in a fair fight your tactics stink.

  6. #36
    VIP Member Array 357and40's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2011
    Location
    St. Charles, Missouri
    Posts
    2,398
    Comparing these two is like comparing Tavern on the Green to Dennys. 1911 all the way.

    Do NOT blaspheme in the church of JMB.
    RevolvingMag likes this.
    "I've seen things you people wouldn't believe. Attack ships on fire off the shoulder of Orion. I watched c-beams glitter in the dark near the Tannhäuser Gate. All those moments will be lost in time, like tears in rain."
    - Roy Batty

  7. #37
    Member Array diesel44's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2011
    Location
    Wisconsin
    Posts
    130
    Got to consider when both were released. The 1911 back then was a technological genius and the Glock was the same back in the 80's. Like another poster stated. When Glock has stood the test of 100 years as the 1911 has, then we can compare the two. Just my opinion.


    Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

  8. #38
    VIP Member
    Array C hawk Glock's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2009
    Location
    W. Washington
    Posts
    3,552
    I would have to say that David and he rock and sling had them all beat!
    Ccccccc what? Ccccccccccc Hawks!

  9. #39
    Senior Member Array kerberos's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2012
    Location
    Arkansas
    Posts
    747
    Owe my existence to the 1911...

    Guess that had more "impact" for me personally.
    "Death is lighter than a feather, but Duty is heavier than a mountain" Robert Jordan
    USMC veteran
    Glock 19 Gen 4
    Si hoc legere scis, nimis eruditionis habes

  10. #40
    VIP Member
    Array archer51's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Location
    VA
    Posts
    21,870
    Quote Originally Posted by diesel44 View Post
    Got to consider when both were released. The 1911 back then was a technological genius and the Glock was the same back in the 80's. Like another poster stated. When Glock has stood the test of 100 years as the 1911 has, then we can compare the two. Just my opinion.


    Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

    When Glock celebrates 100 years, the 1911 will be pushing the 200 year mark and still be going strong.
    Beans likes this.
    Freedom doesn't come free. It is bought and paid for by the lives and blood of our men and women in uniform.

    USAF Retired
    NRA Life Member

  11. #41
    Moderator
    Array bmcgilvray's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2007
    Location
    Texas
    Posts
    10,173
    Quote Originally Posted by glockman10mm View Post
    Don't forget the Luger, almost, became this countries service handgun.
    Great handgun! Fun handgun, but I'm sure grateful the Luger was bypassed in favor of the 1911. Still, wouldn't it be great to have a .45 Luger?


    Ecucmgt's enjoyable post is a well-crafted read on his thinking of why the Glock should be considered the more revolutionary pistol.

    The Glock is great for those who love it but it is mostly an amalgamation of design concepts previously introduced including a surprising number of major features that pre-date World War II. Gaston borrowed heavily when pulling his concept together.

    Besides, there are still those dinosaurs among us who loathe plastic, don't consider the Glock trigger to be good at all, dislike the fact that Glock is lighter in weigh and the fact that it has a top-heavy balance, don't care for the factory chamber leaving as much or more of the case head unsupported than the 1911 thus rendering the Glock no more suitable for heavy loads, don't wish to be limited to shooting only jacketed bullets using the factory barrel, leaving out the cast lead bullet handload, and who find the Glock's appearance as unattractive as the Hi-Point's.

    A lifetime of using plain ol' steel guns in wet conditions finds that carbon steel isn't such a problem to maintain except for the lazy so stainless steel or special coatings are nothing more than a nice convenience, at least for the civilian user. Most don't contend with leaving their firearms submerged for 8 months either.

    This business of the early 1911 being made of untempered "soft steel" has been greatly magnified since the rise of the internet firearms forum. They were and are serviceable with factory type loadings. Besides, there are very few early production military contract 1911s or their civilian contemporary Colt Government Models still seeing regular use. I can think of one though and it lives here. Many times more 1911s and their clones have been made since advances in steel composition and heat treat technologies were introduced than were fabricated to steel specifications that predate World War I. The 1911 design cannot be criticized unfairly because early pistols were made of so-called "soft steel." There are too many modern 1911s about.

    The "loose" military contract 1911 will still group inside of a coffee can lid at 25 yards so there's nothing wrong with the "looseness" of the military pistols.

    Compare the 1911 design's continued popularity to the automatic pistols fielded by other nations' military establishments in the first decades of the 20th Century. We don't see either continued production or a market demand for newly made pistols built to design of the Bergman-Bayard, P'08 Luger, C96 Mauser, Glisenti M1910, Nambu, Astra Model 600, Mexican Obregón, Roth-Steyr, Steyr M1912, Lahti, Frommer Stop, or even Colt's own earlier efforts at producing automatic pistols. All these pistol designs were fielded between 1900 and 1935. The 1911 was their contemporary but has outlasted all of them and it's due to the superior goodness of the basic 1911 design and its continued suitability for use today. A design that remains in demand 100 years after its introduction has to be considered revolutionary.

    The 1911 was more revolutionary for its time than the Glock was when it was introduced.
    oneshot likes this.
    Charter Member of the DC .41 LC Society "Get heeled! No really"

    “No possible rapidity of fire can atone for habitual carelessness of aim with the first shot.”

    Theodore Roosevelt, The Wilderness Hunter, 1893

  12. #42
    Member Array kaboomkaboom's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Location
    United States
    Posts
    186
    I think, personally and with no disrespect, this is a silly question. There is only one answer really...The first successful military semi-auto handgun, it served as the standard U.S. sidearm through four major wars and countless police actions. As popular today as ever, maybe more so, it is still carried by some law enforcement personnel and countless civilians. The most customized handgun ever, An entire industry based on parts, accessories, custom gunsmithing, training centers and formal competition has grown up around the Model , and today the design remains the world-wide standard for competition pistols. NOW THAT is Revolutionary! Which am I speaking of? The glock, or the 1911?

  13. #43
    Senior Member Array Fausty's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2012
    Location
    oshkosh wisconsin
    Posts
    959
    Quote Originally Posted by Kimberpackn View Post
    Have to see where Glock's design is in a hundred years. Short term Glock has made a major impact on gun design.
    this. they each came out in different eras. apples and oranges.

    now, peacemaker vs 1911? there's a debate.
    357and40 likes this.
    My metal band: Born under Sirius

    Glock 23, mic holster, clipdraw, abdominal carry.

  14. #44
    VIP Member
    Array oneshot's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2009
    Location
    +42.893612,-082.710236 , Mi.
    Posts
    8,358
    [QUOTE=MrBuckwheat;2236548]all at the same time? and is one of the smiths a 629?[/QUOTE]




    ^^^^^^^Nope^^^^and^^Nope
    If you want to make God laugh, tell him your plans.

    Washington didn't use his freedom of speech to defeat the British, He shot them!

    Politics is the art of looking for trouble, finding it whether it exists or not, diagnosing it incorrectly, and applying the wrong remedy." -- Ernest Benn

  15. #45
    los
    los is offline
    VIP Member Array los's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Location
    Corpus Christi, Tx
    Posts
    2,487
    What we've got here is failure to communicate.

Page 3 of 4 FirstFirst 1234 LastLast

Links

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  

Search tags for this page

1911 swinging link

,
colt 1911 .45 acp carry gun 2012 gun forum
,
colt 1911 or glock
,

colt 1911 vs glock

,
colt impact on military
,
discovery colt 1911
,

glock vs colt 1911

,
powered by mybb about.com paintball games
,

powered by mybb auto technology

,

powered by mybb british military weapons

,

powered by mybb impact statement

,
powered by mybb paintball games online
,
powered by mybb paintball stuff
,
powered by mybb third rock from the sun
,
which is better colt m1911 or glock
Click on a term to search for related topics.