This is a discussion on Help me choose please - M&P 9c vs XD9 subcompact within the Defensive Carry Guns forums, part of the Defensive Carry Discussions category; Originally Posted by Thunder71 M&P Shield sounds like it was made just for you. I have the XDM 9 Compact, M&P 9C and M&P Shield, ...
Nightstand, I've tried to carry it and I just can't do it. Shield and M&P 9C I can all day long.
I agree with with getting the M&P 9c, Made in the USA.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
"Government exists to protect us from each other. Where government has gone beyond its limits is in deciding to protect us from ourselves."--Ronald Reagan
Thanks for all the replies! Made in the USA does is definetly a plus on the S&W. It's really hard not to be impulsive with the xd in a pawn shop locally - trade in the LC9 put up a little cash and walk out with it today without my pocketbook taking a big hit- it's very tempting as I liked them both so much. I am leaning towards the S&W though.
I appreciate all the help!
Palmetto arms has a sale
m&p 9 or 40
Compact or fs for $399.
can't go wrong
Sent from my DROID RAZR
Dude, I'd hate to be behind you in line at a fast-food counter.
By just holding the M&P 9c and the xd subcompact empty in the store I was saying I like the feel of the M&P out of the 2 but wanted to shoot them before choosing, I was suprised how much I liked shooting both.
Part of me still thinks I should consider the Shield...I live in FL where it's hot most of the time. Females often have a harder time concealing than men. Everyone says it's wonderful. But I've seen women conceal larger guns and I know it can be done. I've got a couple great larger cover shirts I can throw over a tank top with shorts. I just really like the feel of the 2 slightly larger ones I've looked at.
(and although I will NEVER buy a handgun based on the color, the 9c has removable backstraps, the Shield does not. I can get glitter backstraps for the 9c and bling it out )
Check PM You can always add pieces of old bicycle inner tube to add to a small grip to aid you while braking it in or to keep on it. I use 3 piece on mine. 3/8" covered by a 1" and 2" trimmed to fit. Makes for a nice sticky grip and a bit thicker in the center of the grip too.
Reading this, a lot of people recommend the M&P, but I have the XD 9 service model (16+1, 4" barrel) and absolutley love it. Shot the M&P, but did not like it as much. I carry the XD 9 everyday IWB with no issues. Carry it all day and I know it is there, but it is not uncomfortable. I like the bigger gun over the compacts and sub compacts. However, what works for you may not work for me and vice versa. My 2 cents
To add another voice to this - I started with a KelTec PF9. It shot okay but I hated shooting it. Got a Full Size M&P45. Loved it and would still have it but I couldn't afford another gun so I traded it to my brother-in-law for his Glock 23 (he made me an offer I couldn't refuse) and then I turned around and traded it off for a M&P40c (with safety but I would prefer without but I can live with it to be back in the M&P). Bought my wife the M&P shield 9mm and I got a chance to fire it and a Shield 40 side by side and the recoil was such that I couldn't distinguish a difference. For me, I love the 40c but if I could go with a Shield 40, I would do so because it is just a bit easier to conceal and is lighter. I will eventually buy one, but this time I'm keeping the 40c and will ADD the additional gun when I can afford to. And I'll be getting a full size M&P45 again at some point.
I just love the feel of the handle in my hands compared to all others I've felt. I went to a gun show recently and I tried everything I could get my hands on and nothing felt as good to me. So, of course, I would say get the M&P. It is so easy to take down and clean and I even like it better than the Glock because I hated the little spring loaded thing you had to press on the Glock whereas the takedown lever on the M&P just is easier to use in my opinion.
and I like the looks of it.
Last edited by accessbob; June 19th, 2012 at 12:36 PM. Reason: add additional text and pic
EDC - M&P Shield .40, Ruger P90, OR Ruger SR1911 CMD AND
Ruger LCP in Desantis Pocket Holster (backup)
Member - SAF, OFF,
NRA Life Member
i love my M&P9c. i think i found my perfect CCW.
got the DeSantis mini scabbard for it. wish i would have discovered this holster a few years ago.