I'd vote for the J-frame, even though I don't really like mine. When I say I don't like it, I don't mean that there's anything wrong with the gun. It functions perfectly, and is a quality firearm. I just don't like shooting it. It's a lightweight gun, has a heavy trigger, and has almost nothing for sights. It's exactly what it is intended to be, and serves its intended purpose very well. For me, its intended purpose just doesn't make it an enjoyable / anything that I "like". Despite the fact that I don't "like" the gun, I'm glad to have it, and I respect its role. Likewise, it goes everywhere I go.