Any thoughts on XD-subcompact VS Glock 26 ??

[dben002]

Was in the process of obtaining a G-26 in the next 3 weeks, however this XD subcompact 9 has caught a twinkle in my eye...As I have no experience with or any really detailed knowledge of the XD what do i need to know here?

Thanks

[DefensiveCarry.com]

[TX expat]

I carried an XD sub .40 for a while. What would you like to know about them?

The XD sub is a little larger and heavier than the G26, to the point where I think it's actually more comparable to the G19.

Mine was very accurate for a 3" barrel, never had any jams or other issues. My grip did cause the slide lock to not engage sometimes, but that's obviously me, not it. I think the trigger was pretty good, no better or worse than my Glock.

[dben002]

I carried an XD sub .40 for a while. What would you like to know about them?

The XD sub is a little larger and heavier than the G26, to the point where I think it's actually more comparable to the G19.

Mine was very accurate for a 3" barrel, never had any jams or other issues. My grip did cause the slide lock to not engage sometimes, but that's obviously me, not it. I think the trigger was pretty good, no better or worse than my Glock.

Thanks, I was really interested in the trigger pull as compared to the 26...if it was about the same or had more play..also the accuracy..

[TX expat]

Thanks, I was really interested in the trigger pull as compared to the 26...if it was about the same or had more play..also the accuracy..

It's a little different, but I can't honestly say it was much different. It's been about a year since I shot one, so I can't really remember the fine details of how it felt, but I didn't have a huge learning curve when I switched to the Glock, so it couldn't have been that different. It's fine for accuracy.

[Tala]

I like full size Glocks fine. Didn't seem to appreciate their grip in subcompact size. Personal choice.

[wondering]

I was looking at these two myself and liked the grip safety on the XD...but I just couldn't get past the high bore axis on the Springfield sub-compacts. I thought it would make for more muzzle flip.

I ended up with the G26 and with limited shooting with it so far (ammo is so hard to come by) its shot well for me. I've enjoyed it.

[TX expat]

I was looking at these two myself and liked the grip safety on the XD...but I just couldn't get past the high bore axis on the Springfield sub-compacts. I thought it would make for more muzzle flip.

I ended up with the G26 and with limited shooting with it so far (ammo is so hard to come by) its shot well for me. I've enjoyed it.

Yes, it does have a higher bore axis but in 9mm, assuming you have a proper grip, the change in bore axis shouldn't make that much difference.

[12 gauge]

I found a significant difference in muzzle flip between my XDM and G26. Glock seemed faster to recover from. I also had a few problems clearing chamber in trying to work with the grip safety. Sold the XDM9, still have XDM45, but don't shoot it much.

[BugDude]

I've shot both and bought the XD40sc. It fit my hand better and I shot it better. It has been my primary EDC for 3-4 years. Very accurate shooter. Great trigger. The g27 grip hit my strong hand wrong and was uncomfortable to shoot. It comes down to personal preference and fit. Both are good weapons.

[wondering]

I think a lot of the Glock grip issue will change for many with the Gen 4 adjustable grips. I test fired a Gen 3 before buying my Gen 4 and there is a difference. The Gen 4 is more comfortable for me.

TX expat-
The muzzle flip in a 9mm would definitely be easier to deal with than a .40 or .45 but I was thinking with a sub-compact anything that would help prevent muzzle flip would be worth considering.

[Bill MO]

I carry a XDsc 9 EDC sometimes two, mirror AIWB. I don't like any gun for primary gun to have shorter grip than what I can get all fingers on. The XDsc with the finger extension works for me.

If I was just starting to CC (knowing now what I know on CC guns) I would buy a Glock 19, learn to love it, and never look back.

[TX expat]

I think a lot of the Glock grip issue will change for many with the Gen 4 adjustable grips. I test fired a Gen 3 before buying my Gen 4 and there is a difference. The Gen 4 is more comfortable for me.

TX expat-
The muzzle flip in a 9mm would definitely be easier to deal with than a .40 or .45 but I was thinking with a sub-compact anything that would help prevent muzzle flip would be worth considering.

Yeah, I agree. In the .40 cal it was fairly noticeable. That's one of the main reasons I moved to a 9mm. My other .40 was easier to get back on target, although it is a full frame pistol, so it has two factors working for it.

[00z28]

I'm not a fan of the XDs grip safety. I have seen numerous times where my friend (xds 45) failed to ire because his hand wasnt just right on the grip. Absolutely love shooting the gun, but if it were a SD or CCW, I'd have to see the gun not fire because my hand wasnt exactly right.

In its defense, I never had this trouble, but I did see the gun owner dip the barrel, anticipating recoil, with no shot because of the grip safety

[dben002]

I'm not a fan of the XDs grip safety. I have seen numerous times where my friend (xds 45) failed to ire because his hand wasnt just right on the grip. Absolutely love shooting the gun, but if it were a SD or CCW, I'd have to see the gun not fire because my hand wasnt exactly right.

In its defense, I never had this trouble, but I did see the gun owner dip the barrel, anticipating recoil, with no shot because of the grip safety

Thanks for that bit of info...I was curious about the grip safety thingy....never had one...not sure I like the idea.....thinking on it....

[txron]

It is like asking whether you like brownies or chocolate chip cookies. Both are good. But you have to rely on what works best for you.