Smith M&P 9compact vs. others?

[acroreef]

Dear Folks:

I am contemplating purchasing a Smith & Wesson M&P compact 9mm and wonder what else I should consider of similar size? Just looking to make the right choice for concealed carry and want super reliable quality. Based on your recommendations, I will rent each and decide which is the best "fit" for me. I just don't want to overlook anything in my search. I want a carry gun that is durable enough to also be a range gun (so that I can consistantly practice).

Thanks to all who respond.

Acroreef

[DefensiveCarry.com]

[Pete]

You should enjoy reading this thread comparing the G26 - XD9 SC - M&P 9C.

http://www.combatcarry.com/vbulletin...ad.php?t=22150

[Cap'n]

Try a HK USP compact in 9mm. HK makes a very high quality firearm and the USP line has proven itself to be very reliable over the test of time. I also looked at the M&P but the USPc just fit my hand better with the slightly longer grip.

[craze]

Both the Glock g26 and the xd line of compacts are similar platforms and price range as the M&P compact. I too am looking to purchase a weapon in this class and based on what I've heard and how they feel have decided on the M&P, but you can't go wrong with the other two I mentioned above either.

[ebk637]

I have the XD9SC and love it!
I have shot the g26 and i like that also.
I have not shot an M&P .
unlike the G26 and the M&P the XD has a grip safety also.

[maclean3]

Might also look at the Glock G19 and the Kahr line.
Jack

[fatboy97]

I shoot the S&W M&P 40c, along with a XD 40sc. They are very close to the same size, but I did like the M&P 40c better. I was trying to also shoot the G27 (sub compact .40), which is the same size as the G26 (9mm), but the range did not have one at the time.

I think those are the three I would consider buying if I was looking for that size gun right now.

[Adam500]

the P2000sk is another option. I have an M&P9c and like it.

Adam

[eagle5]

Acroreef, if you can hold out till this weekend, I can take some pictures of my XD9SC and M&P9c for comparison.

I do not have the G36. Maybe I should think about filling this inadequacy?

[Spiff_P239]

If you're also entertaining non-polymer framed options, take a look at the Sig P239. It's a very well-built pistol from a topnotch manufacturer.