Which do you prefer?
This is a discussion on Best CCW Platform within the Defensive Carry Guns forums, part of the Defensive Carry Discussions category; Which do you prefer?...
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: State of Discombobulation
Carry Gun: Off Duty 22-4
I prefer a Double Action Revolver, and that's what I carry Off-Duty.
I last carried and qualified with a Revolver for Duty Carry back in 1997. Now I'm stuck using the "issued" bottom feeding piece of junk. I shoot it when they tell me I have to, not because I want to. I don't even practice with it as I feel that I can hit what I need to hit with it, when I need to hit. My Qualification Scores will reflect this.
I shoot a DAO Revolver better than I do the DAO Autoloader as I've spent more time with them. I'd really like to carry a 1911, but having missed the thumb safety one night in a high stress scenario I learned that "point and shoot" type weapons tend to work best for me.
Now just because I carry a Revolver doesn't mean that I'm limited to six rounds. I also carry a BUG that holds five rounds. I also carry a reload for each gun, giving me a total of twenty-two rounds carried. I may start carrying a third gun as well, but no reload for it.
"If I was an extremist, our founding fathers would all be extremists," he said. "Without them, we wouldn't have our independence. We'd be a disarmed British system of feudal subjectivity."
Auto, no manual safety-point and shoot, oh and it should be L.H.
I think the best for the best is a 1911. For the masses, I would have to say Glock or Sig.
Its a highly subjective question with no wrong answer.
Last edited by SIXTO; October 27th, 2007 at 10:49 PM. Reason: it would be pointless to type my reason for editing.
"Just blame Sixto"
M&P Doc- Just ask.
I like small auto loaders in 9mm and the Sc/Ti J-frame revolvers.
My choice in each are:
HK P2000sk LEM
My small collection varies...but my preference is the 1911...
"That I cannot do."
"Give this to, uh, Clemenza. I want reliable people, people who aren't going to be carried away. After all we're not murderers in spite of what this undertaker thinks."
Certified Glock Armorer
NRA Life Member
DAO. Draw and pull the trigger. No safety to worry about. 1911 requires alot of training that most people tend to ignore. I prefer J frames and any standard DAO/TDA semi auto Glock/S&W/Sig
One that 's 100% reliable and can be carried always and comfortably. Nothing else matters, really.Best CCW Platform
For me, I'm also a lefty, so that narrows the field by quite a lot given the simple fact that controls meant to be operated by the thumb don't always work so well via fingers. My choice: CZ P01 9mm (DA/SA), IWB or OWB, with at least a couple of spare magazines of 14rds; plus BUG, depending. I'm accurate and consistent. The DA pull is not bad, and the SA is crisp and wonderfully good. Have had it tuned by a 'smith.
"Best" ??? - Haha - there is a can'o'worms!!!
For me DA/SA per my SIG 226 - and I like full size too!
For most tho - what is 100% reliable, shoot well for them and make concealment other than a problem. This is all boat-floating
Chris - P95
NRA Certified Instructor & NRA Life Member.
"To own a gun and assume that you are armed
is like owning a piano and assuming that you are a musician!."
http://www.rkba-2a.com/ - a portal for 2A links, articles and some videos.
I'll throw in another vote for the 1911.
Best for me is the 1911 platform.
"The pistol, learn it well, carry it always ..." ~ Jeff Cooper
"Dilgentia Vis Celeritas"
For the specific question, I prefer a semiauto, for the capacity. Also, I seem to be able to shoot higher calibers in the semiauto over the revolver. I had a nice S&W .357 magnum back in the late 70's. The friend that sold it to me (he had a gun shop), took me out to teach me how to shoot. First, we ran 36 .38 special rounds through it, and I put 35 shots in the 10 ring, with 1 in the 9 ring. When we loaded .357 rounds, the first shot cut the X in the bullseye perfectly. The rest of my shots couldn't hit the back stop! It's good that there weren't any low flying planes around! I shot the first just like I did the 38 rounds, but after that, I was flinching like crazy. I tried other times, with the same results. I had to sell that gun during my divorce, and didn't get another until 2005. I had decided on semiauto, and started out with 9mm, which I figured would be comparable in recoil to the 38. My first was the Beretta 92FS, then added a Glock 19, a Glock 26, and a Kel-tec P11 (which jammed so frequently that I sold it). For the heck of it, last year I rented a 45. And I found that the recoil was quite manageable. I ended up buying the XD 45, which is my primary carry gun. I may give revolvers a try again, but I really like the semiauto. As far as more specifics preferences, I love the XD. I'll eventually get a 1911, but I much prefer the XD-lighter, but with a comparable grip angle, better than the Glocks. And I like the higher capacity, along with the loaded chamber indicater, the tactile striker status indicator, and the trigger safety. That and the grip safety make the regular safeties unnecessary, and I don't have to remember to flip it off if I have to draw and shoot.