Choosing A 1911 For Duty Use

Choosing A 1911 For Duty Use

This is a discussion on Choosing A 1911 For Duty Use within the Defensive Carry Guns forums, part of the Defensive Carry Discussions category; Please forgive if this is old news but i just read it and wondered what your thoughts were. This article can be found here: ...

Results 1 to 8 of 8

Thread: Choosing A 1911 For Duty Use

  1. #1
    Member Array Dihappy's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2006

    Choosing A 1911 For Duty Use

    Please forgive if this is old news but i just read it and wondered what your thoughts were.

    This article can be found here:


    (bold added by me)

    Before we begin our discussion, it is important to understand that the requirements for a duty 1911 are significantly different than those of a 1911 used for competition or CCW. What is acceptable for one application is not necessarily desirable or even appropriate for another.

    A competition gun will typically expect to see a very high round count but relatively little actual carry. A weapon selected for CCW use by a private citizen can expect to be carried only in a concealed manner, and not typically exposed to weather and impact in the same manner as most duty weapons. By its nature, a competition or CCW gun tends to be at the center of its owner’s attention, as it is a special and singular tool.

    Depending on the LEO’s assignment and duties, the duty pistol may be only one of many pieces of kit requiring maintenance and attention at the end of the shift or mission. The adage of “just take care of your gear” has a different meaning for an officer assigned to a tactical unit, as the pistol may be competing for maintenance time with a host of other critical equipment such as body armor, helmet, gas mask, eye protection, duty rig, radio/commo equipment, primary entry weapon, secondary/specialty weapons (breaching guns, sniper weapons, gas delivery platforms), and other specialty equipment.

    Ideally, the duty 1911 should not require a disproportionate amount of maintenance time for the end user with such an assignment. So which 1911 to choose for duty? Agency policy permitting, your budget will pretty much determine what you can have in your duty holster. Remember that these things will ride in an exposed holster and be subjected to rain, sweat, constant handling, and the hard knock life of being around work vehicles, concrete walls, and gun lockers at the jail.

    Further, if you are involved in a deadly force incident, your 1911 may be held as evidence for some period of time. You may want an identical backup in the event that you are off admin leave and back on the street without your original pistol. If you are choosing for a department or team, this can also change things for you.

    Lastly, if you are a diehard 1911 aficionado, you should be ready to accept that you could buy two to four of any other modern service pistol for the price of one 1911 that is good to go. You will not find any true bargains, nor should you be looking for one when your safety or that of your men is on the line.

    First off, if you are truly serious about running a 1911, it needs to be a full sized 5" gun in .45 ACP. There certainly are any number of examples of Commander and other compact 1911s that work or can be made to work just fine, and for CCW use they can be a viable option for some users. However, take a look at the history of unit issue service 1911s – LAPD SWAT, USSOCOM, USMC Det-1, USMC MEUSOC, FBI HRT, FBI SWAT, and let’s not forget over 95 years with all the branches of the U.S. military - and you won't find ANY major units that use anything other than the original full sized gun.

    Why? After you field 50 or 350 guns at once and run thousands or even tens of thousands of rounds through them during training cycles, you'll figure it out. By virtue of their design, the shorter format 1911s reduce the window of functional opportunity for the magazine and slide to work together to feed, chamber, extract, and eject. This is an incontrovertible fact of life. Proper weapon setup, spring rates, and magazine maintenance are critical in running the shorter guns.

    Keeping after a few 1911s as a single hobbyist or aficionado is different than running a bunch of guns for a large unit. Remember that weapon down time equates to lost training and operational time. You want to minimize your maintenance issues, not increase them.

    Lastly, a full sized 1911 is very arguably a more efficient shooting and ballistic delivery platform than a smaller sized variant for the majority of users.

    Here are the basic specifications to examine for a duty 1911:

    •Full sized Government Model 1911 format with 5" barrel length and
    steel frame for increased reliability and durability.
    •Chambered in .45 ACP, as that is the caliber in which the gun was
    designed and functions best. The greatest number of magazine
    options are available in .45 ACP.
    Standard Browning barrel without integral feed ramp. Ramped barrels
    typically have very steep feed ramps that don't feed well. Wide
    mouthed hollowpoints can also catch at the bottom of the integral
    ramp, creating further feeding issues.

    •Standard milspec short recoil spring guide rod and plug.
    •Recoil spring rating of 17-18.5 lbs to improve durability with full
    power duty loads.
    •Availability of ambidextrous safety for left handed users.
    •Type of firing pin safety system, if any. See below for further.
    •Light rail or standard dust cover.
    •Type of finish.

    The quality of the factory components will come into play when looking for a gun to use more or less out of the box. MIM (Metal Injection Molded) components, which have received an excess of attention in recent years, tend to vary in quality like anything else, but they can generally be expected to have a useable service life of 5,000 to 10,000 rounds.

    Some quality MIM components work exceedingly well, and I personally have witnessed a large number of guns with MIM small parts where service life has exceeded 30-40,000 rounds. However, if planning for a comprehensive rebuild, the small parts quality can be considered secondary to that of the slide and frame since most of them will be replaced.

    Firing pin safeties typically fall into the Colt Series 80 pattern which are actuated by the trigger (Colt Series 80, Para Ordnance, Sig GSR) and the Swartz style safety which is actuated by the grip safety (Kimber, Smith & Wesson).

    Of all the firing pin safety mechanisms on the market, the original Colt Series 80 - in a Colt - is the most reliable of them all. The platforms utilizing the Swartz safety are a less than ideal choice across the board due to the inherent reliability problems of the design.

    The Swartz safety is extremely sensitive to the fit of the grip safety to the frame and the timing of the grip safety's trigger blocking arm. Tolerance issues can also lead to a Swartz safety that will time properly when the grip safety is depressed a certain way, and time differently when depressed a different way.

    This will typically be a product of loose fit of the grip safety to the frame tangs and/or loose fit of the thumb safety shaft through the grip safety. It is possible to have the grip safety timed such that the trigger will be able to release the sear well before the firing pin safety plunger has been moved far enough to clear the firing pin.

    Problems with improper timing of the Swartz safeties can lead to a situation where you get a "click" when you wanted a "bang." That's a serious problem. Unless department policy mandates a firing pin safety, I would choose a 1911 without one.

    It is possible to have a drop safe 1911 without the firing pin safety, and given the potential reliability problems with a poorly executed system, the perceived risk of drop safety is outweighed by the real risk of a failure to fire.

    My feeling is that a duty 1911 absolutely needs a light rail interface. There are a host of choices, all of which feature some variation of a Picatinny rail. As long as you use a common light such as the Surefire X200, you will have duty holster choices. The ubiquitous Safariland 6004/6280 family is available for most of the common rail guns in conjunction with the Surefire X200 and Insight M3/M6 lights.

    The finish of the weapon will be of importance for reducing maintenance headaches for the user. Traditional polished blue finishes are very pretty, but tend to fare poorly in humid or wet environments. If you are working out in the rain, it is usually not an option to stop what you are doing to either cover your gun or wipe it down with an oily rag. It is not unusual to observe rust forming right on the weapon during a long patrol or operation in a wet environment.

    For a carbon steel gun, I recommend matte Parkerizing as the bare minimum finish for duty use. Parkerizing is very functional and cheap to reapply when worn. For even better corrosion resistance, an excellent choice would be one of the various thermally cured spray on finishes such as KG Gunkote, Cerakote, Birdsong Black T, or Nighthawk Permakote. Remember that exposed metal will rust, no matter what the manufacturer of the finish claims.

    Matte stainless usually works quite well, but remember that the porous surface of the steel will trap moisture and can still rust if neglected. Matte hard chrome and some of the newer vapor deposition finishes such as Tungsten DLC offer excellent abrasion resistance and corrosion protection, but can be hard to properly apply and will need to be stripped and reapplied in the event of a weapon repair or rebuild. I prefer a simpler finish that can be reapplied without incident, as duty weapons should expect several rebuilds during their service cycle.

    Now that we have addressed the various points of consideration, let’s move on to available weapon choices. My recommendations, which follow below, are not meant to be a comprehensive examination of all the industry offerings, but rather my particular thoughts on certain 1911s based on my experience and personal preference.

    The Springfield MC Operator, which is the "Loaded" grade gun with a green and black paint job, is a leading option. Anecdotal research on these models in the field provides typically positive results in high round count duty settings. T

    he correct Picatinny spec light rail, corrosion resistant finish and overall configuration of the MC Operator lends itself well to duty use. The parkerized or stainless Loaded model is also an acceptable duty gun in a normal dust cover format. Note that some generations of the fixed sight Springfield Loaded guns tend to shoot anywhere from 6-12" low at 25 yds with the factory sights, necessitating the immediate replacement of the rear Novak sight with a taller unit.

    The newer Springfields are coming from the factory with higher rear sights to correct this problem. If you are able to hand pick a sample, try to select one that has a pinned ejector. While a glued-in ejector works just fine, it is cheap insurance to have a pin.

    If you want to bridge the gap between a full blown hand built custom and a lower priced/entry level production 1911, the Springfield Professional is an excellent choice. I have seen a lot of these guns and have a few myself.

    Statistically, there are more of the Professional Models out in real street service than any other factory custom 1911, so the quirks are pretty well worked out. They have consistently improved since the original run of guns, and overall are very nicely done. They offer cleanly executed checkering (some of the best on a production type gun), a nice beavertail fit, a blended S&A mag well, premium grade components, real Novak sights with Trijicon inserts, and excellent accuracy from the match fit Nowlin barrel.

    These guns typically work very well right out of the box, though they should be monitored closely during their break in period. It is available in a standard dust cover format (PC9111) and with the shortened Operator light rail frame (PC9111LR). If you find one of these on the secondary market, it is preferable to pick a later production specimen that has the Trijicon sight inserts and pinned front sight.

    Very early (low three digit CRG 1xx serial numbers) guns had IWI sight inserts and no pins in the front sights. While these were good guns, the sight inserts do not wear very well and you will want to replace them with Trijicons. Each run of guns differs as to whether their ejectors are pinned or glued, but the Springfield Custom Shop will pin the ejector if you desire.

    A new contender in the high end "production custom" market is Nighthawk Custom. I am obviously biased in mentioning them, since I helped design the 10-8 model for them. Shameless plugs aside, the Nighthawk shop puts out an excellent product at a fair price for what you are getting. The Nighthawk 10-8 is a fine hand built 1911 that is suitable for duty and is readily available. Read all about it here.

    If you must have a Colt, your options include the new production 1991A1, Series 70 reproduction, XSE Government, and Colt Gunsite Pistols (CGP). The CGP seems to be out of production, but you'll still find them floating around. The first three are available in both stainless and blue. If policy dictates that you need a firing pin safety, then choose a 1991A1 or XSE. The Colts have great small parts quality, but their main issues include ridiculously sharp edges and poor assembly. Note that the Colts do not feature an integral light rail, and your most viable options for an attached light are the addition of a Dawson Rail Adapter or the use of a Surefire MR07 light mount.

    What are the main pitfalls of running a 1911 for duty? Weapon maintenance and end user responsibility are the two big issues. The end user needs to be dialed in to the gun's quirks to be able to run it effectively. The day of handing out rack grade 1911s to the masses and using them for duty are pretty much over. A unit, team, or department that is looking at running 1911s needs to seriously consider having the following:

    1) Two 1911s issued to each user, to allow for continuity when one
    weapon goes down for service. Lacking this, the issuing unit needs
    to have a pool of spare guns to lend out to users when a gun goes
    down for maintenance.
    2) Dedicated and skilled armorer support. Being able to maintain the
    weapon is key, and it requires more than a one day armorer school
    to learn how to effectively change parts in this gun.
    3) Transition training for the end users so that they may learn the
    unique manual of arms and proper maintenance of the 1911.

    Magazines are a big issue, and users need to try not to become married to a set of magazines. When they stop falling out, stop locking back, or the first time they stop working, they need to either be addressed or replaced. The mags are the weak link, so get over it and throw them out when they give up on you.

    Extractor tension is another problem, and stovepipes and double feed (Type 2 and 3) malfunctions are not to be tolerated. Replace the extractor when these start to occur, as retensioning the existing unit is only a temporary fix. I expect only a 5,000 round service cycle on a standard Browning format extractor. They will easily last 10,000-15,000 rounds or even longer without incident, but I start looking hard at them at 5,000. If you can, replace them every 5,000 rounds and you probably will not have too many headaches.

    Proper fitting is critical to extending the service life of the extractor. A properly designed external extractor would solve the extractor related problems, but the choices are currently limited and the track records of the designs vary in success.

    Do you need to have your gun customized or worked over in order to carry it for work? Not necessarily. You really need to shoot the gun for 1000-1500 rounds, to include about 500 or more rounds with duty ammunition to have a good feel for what the gun is doing. Do not just put "200 flawless rounds" through the gun and declare that it is "completely reliable." That is not a statistically significant cycle of service. You need to be able to fire 1000-1500 rounds through the gun without any malfunctions.

    Cleaning and lubrication every 200-400 rounds is an acceptable interval of maintenance while evaluating the weapon for suitability. The 1911 is a design that requires hand fitting for maximum performance, and while a hot rodded or tuned gun (by a skilled 1911 specialist, not your local range hack) will always be better in many ways than any factory gun, a stock gun will often do the job if the hand fitting at the factory was done right.

    The 1911 is an aficionado's weapon, and still has a place in the modern arsenal for those who are dedicated to it. With proper setup and maintenance, the 1911 can serve you like no other weapon.

    Good shopping and good hunting.

  2. #2
    Distinguished Member Array AKsrule's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2004
    IMHO - the Vast Majority of street cops in this country will never
    be trained enough by their AGENCYS to be Proficient with a 1911.

    This is why they will be issued Glocks or M&Ps.
    -SIG , it's What's for Dinner-

    know your rights!

    "If I walk in the woods, I feel much more comfortable carrying a gun. What if you meet a bear in the woods that's going to attack you? You shoot it."
    {Bernhard Goetz}

  3. #3
    Lead Moderator
    Array rocky's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Also SA , short light trigger pull is not desirable by political types (nor is it advisable for the less proficient handlers). Finally, low round count makes the 1911 less desirable for duty use.
    "In matters of style, swim with the current; in matters of principle, stand like a rock." Thomas Jefferson

    Nemo Me Impune Lacesset

  4. Remove Advertisements

  5. #4
    VIP Member Array BigEFan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2007
    Central California
    I read this same article quite a while back when I was considering buying the MC Operator. Not because I will use it for Duty use but because I was interested in the pistol itself and its strengths and weaknesses.

    For what it is worth, and I have said this here before many times, I highly recommend the MC Operator. I think it is a great pistol and unless you want to fork out the extra dough for a TRP Operator, which offers a few more bells and whistles, those looking for a nice 1911 might want to consider the MC.
    Lex et Libertas — Semper Vigilo, Fortis, Paratus, et Fidelis!

    "Not only do the people who put their lives on the line to protect the rest of us deserve better, we all deserve better than to have our own security undermined by those who undermine law enforcement." -Thomas Sowell

  6. #5
    JD is offline
    Array JD's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2006
    Central Iowa
    A very good read, I was happy to see him plug the Spingers seeing as how he is somewhat affiliated with NHC. Everything in the article is what I expected to read. If I wanted a railed 1911 I'd go with the above mentioned TRP Operator, only becuse I'm addicted to checkered front straps and dislike green guns for everyhting else other than doing secret squirrel missions.

    If I hadn't found my Baer at such a good price I was going to go with a Springfield Pro or a TRP. I'll probably end up with one eventually anyway.

  7. #6
    Ex Member Array BikerRN's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    State of Discombobulation
    I like the article and I've used it to help me select my next 1911.

    I may start carrying a 1911 again, but first I'll either run to Gunsite, Thunder Ranch or LFI and train with it first. I had a bad expirience with a 1911 way back when. I "forgot" to take the thumb safety off in a high stress encounter. I'm lucky, I'm not dead and no shots ended up being fired but it could've very easily turned out differently.

    I've carried so many "point and shoot" weapons over the years that I question my ability to work the 1911 in a high stress environment. That's why I say, take the gun and go take a class with it. That will be the determining factor for me.


  8. #7
    Member Array kahrboy18's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2007

    Get a Glock

    I have owned 20 or so, Colts.Great pistols, as arule. Had a NIB 80 Gold Cup go full auto due to a crimped sear spring though.

    Sadly, go Glock G21 with a steel recoil rod or Sig 220.

    Love my custom LWC and toltaly stock GM 38 Super-if they will buy the ammo go 38 Super-Corbon gives you a 10 shot 357 Mag in a pistol.

  9. #8
    Senior Member Array sheepdog's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2006
    I think it's excellent info. I would steer anyone looking to the 1911 for serious use or carry to it...have done so several times. From what I've read, Mr. Yam knows his way around 1911s and see a lot of them/builds them and probably has a good idea what works and what won't. Several of the points I've heard elsewhere, from other knowledgeable folks.
    What Would Gumby Do?

Sponsored Links

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts

Similar Threads

  1. DA/SA or DAO on-duty & 1911 off-duty?
    By TheGreatGonzo in forum Defensive Carry Guns
    Replies: 11
    Last Post: September 8th, 2009, 01:24 AM
  2. 1911 or SIG/220 MagPouch Safariland Level III Duty Rig [PA]
    By QKShooter in forum Member Buy, Sell & Trade
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: January 7th, 2009, 09:06 AM
  3. Choosing a 1911
    By spooter66 in forum Defensive Carry Guns
    Replies: 36
    Last Post: November 1st, 2008, 11:14 PM
  4. Taurus 1911 Duty Holster
    By Kid1911 in forum Defensive Carry Holsters & Carry Options
    Replies: 13
    Last Post: July 4th, 2008, 12:51 PM
  5. Need help choosing a .22
    By Freedomofchoice in forum Defensive Carry Guns
    Replies: 32
    Last Post: April 24th, 2008, 05:47 PM

Search tags for this page

1911 duty weapons
1911 for duty use

best 1911 for duty use


best 1911 pistol for duty

best duty 1911

choosing a 1911 for duty use

is the 1911 suitable fit for duty
nighthawk for duty 1911
reasons for choosing a 1911 pistol for duty
replacing extractor 1991a1 compact
should i remove type ii safety on my 1911 duty weapon
what's the best 1911 pistol for duty
Click on a term to search for related topics.