Finally found what I was looking for after trying out so many in the demo program. This P226 fits my hand perfectly, feels like ergonomic heaven, and the recoil is amazingly tame.
Hopefully I'll find some time this week to enjoy it on the range.
I was thinking of another Comp-Tac holster - perhaps the "infidel" will be good?
To avoid the "worthless without pics" reply, here is a quick snapshot.