"Caliber wars" are on-going, and have been debated to death. Mouse guns vs larger guns is another on-going debate.
When I'm working I've found that a pocket pistol works very good for me. I know it's not the best choice but that's the way it works. I always have my LCP, if I anticipate going to a "threatening" area I often ramp up by choosing a more appropriate CCW.
When I sent my LCP off for the retrofit, I substituted my NAA .22 mag for pocket carry. Once again, and like the LCP, I'm "relying" on a marginal CCW for EDC, I know it's not the best choice, but those pocket guns keep me armed when I leave the house.
FWIW, in answering your question, personally I'd choose the Bobcat.