sig v H&K

[SigNY]

I have 2 HK's(P2000 and P2000SK) and 1 Sig(P220). The Sig was the first handgun I ever bought so it has a special place in my heart. I have never found a Sig that I didn't like. I love the LEM trigger on my HK's and I conceal them better. So with that being said I don't think you can go wrong either way. They are both pricey in my eyes.

[DefensiveCarry.com]

[retsupt99]

My leanings of your choices would be Sig, but I would not discount the extra looks at a Glock-19...I'm just sayin'...

[AmmoSphere]

If the Navy Seals are using them it's good enough for me. Try shooting the P226 and the P228 I shot both and I have to say I'm more accurate with the P226. I think the slightly heavier barrel helps with accuracy because it doesn't kick as high as you fire.

[TWO GUNS]

I would go for the Sig 228.I have one and it is my favorite 9mm.As for a 45 I like the full size USP-45. But get the Sig it will be a great carry gun for you.

[bkenut]

Between the two..Glock. Sorry couldn't help myself. Sig!!!

[dee]

HK by far. Just do the poll on the Sig. forum itself and the HK or even Glock would be the clear choice. Sig is not what it once was as far as Quality Control. I do hope it can become a quality and "reliable'' gun like the name once carried.

[21bubba]

Holy 22 month old thread!

[TWO GUNS]

This one has rose from the dead.

[Guns and more]

I went to the LGS a while back with the intent of getting a Sig 226.
But when I actually held it, it was way too blocky in my hand, and was heavy and even more front heavy. Long reach to the trigger.
The wise salesman asked me to try the H&K P-30. It was like it was made for my hand. Even without changing the grip panels, I knew it was for me.
I bought one. It may be the finest firearm I own as far as quality.
I still want to try a Sig, but I'm looking at the P-225 now, single stack. So far, I can't find one to hold.

[pogo2]

I have two H&Ks and 5 Sigs, and think highly of both brands. But I personally have a slight favoritism for the Sigs, especially the models P220 and P229. I think the Sigs have the best feeling triggers and they are slightly more accurate for me. I also tend to favor metal guns over polymer.

[C hawk Glock]

This thread has been a major surprise in that it's still open! haha... It's stayed pretty civil at this point haha.... By the way, how in the heck did Glock make it in the conversation? Oh and I vote Sig.

[HKnGlock]

All three are very competent guns without doubt. I prefer the HKs because the ergonomics feel better to me. The P30 grip is without equal IMO...I'd get that one... first. All of my Sigs and HKs have been excellent pistols.

The P 30 ergos are unmatched i like HK' and shot them for many years never a failure. Sigs forum has some very unhappy Sig owners especailly the newer ones. I do not want to risk so i will stay with HK, Glock or CZ's all been flawless for me.

[KoB]

1 HK PISTOL?!?!?! I HK PISTOL?!!?!?!?!?!? MADNESS!!!!

…quote taken from my recent post on HKPRO…

So far: HK45C v1 & P2000sk .40 Light LEM (new EDC)…AND COUNTING!!

…please help me…I'M STRUNG OUT ON HK's

[HKnGlock]

I believe you bought the Best Production 9mm/.40 made. I'm into the USP's since they first came out but will get a P30 9mm oneday. Congrats

I went to the LGS a while back with the intent of getting a Sig 226.
But when I actually held it, it was way too blocky in my hand, and was heavy and even more front heavy. Long reach to the trigger.
The wise salesman asked me to try the H&K P-30. It was like it was made for my hand. Even without changing the grip panels, I knew it was for me.
I bought one. It may be the finest firearm I own as far as quality.
I still want to try a Sig, but I'm looking at the P-225 now, single stack. So far, I can't find one to hold.

[swiftyjuan]

I have a Sig P220 and an HK USP compact. Both are great shooters, but I carry the Sig far more often than the HK; it just feels better!