I have had this Fobus magazine and flashlight carrier for about two weeks now and like it.

Pros:

1. The rubber back on the paddle really keeps it from moving around on your waist

2. good retention of both light and magazine.

3. Cheap!! only $25 shipped.

Cons:

1. It sits very low on the belt (like most paddle attachments do).

2. You have to have a light with a one inch barrell (like most Streamlights) or a clip attachment to keep it from falling through.