I just got a Kydex holster for my G23 and like it. Holds well, comfy, fast to clear.
However, I'm not sure if I would like it for CCW. It really makes a definite "clunk" when removing the firearm. There may be times when it's important to unholster quietly - like when a BG is not directing his threats/actions at you directly. That noise seems to be a bit of a giveaway. Even if the BG doesn't know what that "clunk" is, it may draw attention and I never like attention.
Thoughts on this ? Valid concern ? No big deal ? Am I just a luddite leather guy ?