I don't have an Eagle, but I do have 2 Laredo's and they hold very close to the body. The one I have had for the longest is for my Smith 1066. I have it on right now. It sits at about 5 o'clock and the grip presses right into the hollow above my kidney.
Kevin does great work and either would work well. P95Carry (Chris) has an Eagle and loves it. There are several pictures of him with it on and it too pulls the grip in tight.
For me the Laredo works great because I work odd hours and dress in two different styles most days. Being able to come home and swap the holster to a pair of jeans that already has a belt in place is a time saver.