I finally got some of my holsters from John Ralston at 5 Shot Leather 5 Shot Leather, LLC and they're great. I got a black CP (Concealment Pancake) with crocodile trim and matching mag pouch, and a brown UL (Uncle Lou) IWB with shark trim, all for my S&W M&P 45. He's also making me another holster for my 3.5" S&W 29 but I won't see it for a couple of weeks. He has to alter his pattern to accomodate the odd barrel length, but he was very willing to work with me and charged nothing extra.
The holsters are absolute works of art, everything I could have expected. I had heard nothing but good things about John and now I see why his work is so highly praised. He's got a pretty good backlog but it was worth the wait. I'm sorry to say that he's not currently taking orders, but hopefully that will change soon.
Here's some pictures of the holsters:
Black CP with crocodile trim
SMP mag pouch with crocodile trim
Brown UL with shark trim and loops