My first holster for my G19 was a Tucker. A very fine quality holster but it rode a little high on me. I felt as if I was dislocating my arm when drawing. I then tried the Fobus holster but felt it was a little tight for the gun. I attempted to loosen it but to no avail. I then tried the Glock holster. I liked this one. It seems flimsy but really works well for me. I then bought an Uncle Mikes. This one is also very nice retaining and releasing the gun but keeps the gun a little too far from my body. So I use each one for different situations. Nothing is ever perfect.