First off, I am and have always been a CTAC guy. I've bought and sold a dozen holsters and have always, always, gone back to my CTAC holsters. When the MTAC came out it intrigued me, though it looks enormous compared to my CTAC. Then a friend recently told me about his experience with the Crossbreed Supertuck, this is also intriguing as I've heard its more comfortable.
In looking at the two holsters I'm concerned the MTAC and ST are too wide for me, I'm a small to average sized guy, 5'10" and 170lbs, and I just dont want either of them protruding on either side of me. How well do they bend around the body initially, that is a big question in my mind. Also how big are they, they look enormous and would seem like they'd be easily noticed through the pants.
There are pros and cons to each, I've heard the ST is more comfortable, is thinner (less bulky) and yet still carries the weight of heavier guns better. I also like the horsehide and combat cut options. I am a Velcro-clip guy and both holsters have that option. One big plus with the MTAC is the ability to switch out the Kydex so you can use the holster with multiple guns. In the end I'm just not sure. Do I order another CTAC for my 30SF, an MTAC or ST? I just don't know.