They are both great shotguns. If money is no object get the 870P. I have a Mossy500 7shot 20" that was about $225 and has never let me down and I am not scared to abuse it. I also have a Remington Wingmaster for hunting that has also preformed flawlessy, but I treat it like a queen. I do love Remington's if they are the right models and the police version is very nice.