This is a discussion on Can I legally shoot a suffering/dying animal? within the General Firearm Discussion forums, part of the Related Topics category; Originally Posted by DeathRales Don't waste a bullet, slit it's throat. I'm not going to get anywhere near an injured animal. A deers hoofs are ...
Freedom doesn't come free. It is bought and paid for by the lives and blood of our men and women in uniform.
NRA Life Member
^^^^^^^^I wouldn't do that to a big-un^^^^^^^^^^
You might THINK that its incapacitated.
You might THINK that its just about breathed its last.
And just about the time you get the folder out,kneel down next to it, it just might decide your head is gonna look better with its hoof prints in it.
Where I live, or along a desolate highway, I might go bang?
If you want to make God laugh, tell him your plans.
Washington didn't use his freedom of speech to defeat the British, He shot them!
Politics is the art of looking for trouble, finding it whether it exists or not, diagnosing it incorrectly, and applying the wrong remedy." -- Ernest Benn
Check the "game laws" and animal related laws in Okla.... in Kansas it is legal unless it's a deer, then it's legal... BUT ... better be on the phone with 911, as local law enforcement or the Hwy Patrol have to be informed (due to the tag requirements on deer). Can't shoot inside the city limits of a city.
Call ... your Hwy Patrol or Game Commission, and I'm sure they can tell you .... that's the best 2 sources. Don't know if you have any issues there if it's on tribal lands, that could be an issue unto itself.
I don't make jokes. I just watch the government and report the facts. --- Will Rogers ---
Chief Justice John Roberts : "I don't see how you can read Heller and not take away from it the notion that the Second Amendment...was extremely important to the framers in their view of what liberty meant."
It largely depends on the laws in the state where you are located. Several years ago I struck a deer that came running from the side of the road in Albemarle County, Virginia. The County police were called due to the damage and the fact that the deer was still alive. The officer took all my information for his report then went to ease the deer. They were carrying 40 S&W caliber pistols at the time. He had fired 4 shots by the time I left the scene and I'm not sure if he fired any more. The 40 may not be good for deer or the officer was a very poor shot. My guess is he was a poor shot.
Sadly I've dispatched quite a few injured/sick animals. I do hate to see them suffer; however I have rescued, healed and released those that I could save as well.
I had a thread going here awhile back about an owl trapped in my fireplace. Before I rescued him, I called the local game warden and told him what was going on and my intentions to release him if uninjured. He said fine and call him back if I had any problems.
A few years ago I had a big buck run out in front of me one night, I braked as hard as I could but still hit him broadside with a Pathfinder at about 30 mph. He hit the pavement and slid forever, while my wife was screaming forever. At the moment, I felt he'd be very injured and I remember thinking I won't let him suffer until someone got there, I'd do it myself. That big buck jumped up and ran off like nothing happened. So you never know. BTW some local guys happened to tell me about a somewhat crippled buck they recently killed. From their description/location I'm pretty sure that was the buck that ran off.
Shooting a dying animal is a pretty broad question. Does the dying animal belong to you, is it a game animal, or does it belong to someone else? What's the legalities about shooting on or near the highway, or within so many feet of a residence? Could "euthanizing by gun" be seen as animal cruelty to a pet in your state? I'd say there are definitely pitfalls that could haunt you in the aftermath, much depends on the LEO and the prosecutor.
I helped out at a local wreck on a bridge one night. While we were waiting around for a wrecker, we happened to look down at the creek bank and there lay a good-sized mocassin. Once all the activity died down I went to my house and got a .410 and asked the deputy if he wanted me to kill the snake. Although it is illegal here to shoot on the highway, he said it would be fine and to go ahead. We had all realized that had the car gone a bit farther we could have easily encountered that very snake while dealing with the vehicle.
The law is the law, and it varies state to state, and the circumstances around all of this has a big variation. I'm not suggesting doing anything illegal whatsoever, but I do feel sorry for a suffering animal.
Turn the election's in 2014 to a "2A Revolution". It will serve as a 1994 refresher not to "infringe" on our Second Amendment. We know who they are now.........SEND 'EM HOME. Our success in this will be proportional to how hard we work to make it happen.
This was one of the first questions I asked in PCW class... The answer was If you have called 911 and the sheriff en route is too far away he may allow it... stay there once you've done it... And state DNR would frown on it...
I asked because I'd hit one, broke both it's back legs and had to drag it off the road... If I'd even had my knife, it was small enough I could have slit it's throat... I had to let it die of its internal injuries... Wasn't happy about it...
Politicians, take note of Colorado 9/10/2013."You are elected to service, not power.
Your job is to "serve us" not to lord power over us."
This question asked by the OP cannot be answered in a satisfactory manner because what is acceptable in one place, may not be in another.
Where I live, hardly a day passes by that we do not see dead deer on the road. The road that turns off to my house, (a 1/2 mile long dead end road) is a major deer crossing area. The road there stays bloody. As a Deputy it is quite common for me to count at least 20 deer on a shift in city limits. Our city sees several deer a week killed on the roadway.
Lately, I have been using a suppressed .22 to put them down. I too hate to see any animal suffer. It is common for us to do deer/collision reports for the incidents that take place, some are required by Insurance companies. Much property damage as well as personal injury occurs because of deer. One episode involved a 4 wheel drive truck with large tires hitting a pretty good buck. That buck came through the windshield at around 65 MPH and hit the driver square in the face. He spent over a year in the hospital and underwent many surgeries to reconstruct his face. To those of us that knew him, he looked very different when it was over, almost unrecognizable in fact.
We get enough calls that if the dispatchers asks us if they affected party can put the deer down, we almost always let them do it. I just tell the dispatcher to make sure that they have a good backstop. Out town is fairly rural, so its not usually an issue. As for the Game and Fish, they would rather have you do it than to bother them.
The thing is, its common. It happens almost every day. We can predict the "RUT" due the increase of deer vs. vehicle collisions, when the bucks go berserk and show themselves during the day.
what happens here in my hometown in Arkansas and passes for the norm, may not somewhere else. It may be that you are required to call the law, or that you cannot discharge a weapon from a highway with out fear of getting written up by some Yahoo with a badge and no common sense.
Its different every where you go, so the advice of those on the forum is for the most part worthless. I'm as guilty as anyone else of giving advice when I forget that my world is not the same as everyones else's.
The only thing that matters is the LAW were you are located and it has been stated many times on this forum that ignorance of the law is no excuse.
To the OP, yeah...we are fortunate to live where such things like dispatching a wounded animal is minor in the big scheme of things. Out side of Springdale city limits you should be good to go, but there is always an exception to the rule. You might get spotted by the one idiot on the force that wants to make an issue of it.
On the other hand, you must do what is right. I'll not stand around and watch a deer, or any other animal for that matter suffer. You have to do the right thing.
Illegal? Probably not, but I cannot say with any certainty because I don't know the law in Springdale. Stupid? Only if you put others in jeopardy. Since no traffic was coming in either direction...I'd say go for it.I would have likely shot it in the head with my .40 after making sure there was no traffic coming in either direction that would see the gunfire. Would this have been illegal and/or stupid?
Freedom of speech means nothing to those who are too weak in their convictions to speak out against the evil that eating the heart of a nation like a cancer- Billy Graham
AR. CHL Instr. 07/02 FFL
Maker of cool things to shoot
Reminds me of that old joke:
"911, what's your emergency?"
"I just killed a jogger with my truck!"
"Sir, are you sure he's dead?"
"Yep. He's dead."
911, what's your emergency?"
"My husband just collapsed! I think he's dead!"
"Dead? Are you sure?"
"I'm pretty sure."
"Ma'am, I need you to make sure he's not still breathing."
"Okay. Hang on..."
"Okay. He's not breathing."
Bersa Thunder Plus .380
Bersa Thunder Plus .380