OD or JD paging OD or JD!
This is a discussion on 1911 Basics within the General Firearm Discussion forums, part of the Related Topics category; So I need a basic lesson in 1911 firearms. I know the very basics in that it was designed by John Browning and made famous ...
So I need a basic lesson in 1911 firearms. I know the very basics in that it was designed by John Browning and made famous by Colt. I am interested in a modern 1911 and overwhelmed by the choices. I realize everyone has their favorite manufacturer and prices can go from little to unimaginable.
What are the specific characteristics you would look for and why is better than another?
Is their a preference between the internal versus external extractor?
Will I use an ambidextrous safety / do you ever use yours?
I just purchased a Remington R1 1911 .45 5" at the Tulsa Gun Show for $650 (total cost) so far I like it a lot but I haven't got to shoot it yet, maby tomorrow.
I would recommend a Rock Island Armory, a Springfield Armory, or- the best of the best- Colt. Kimber's are nice, but expensive for something you might possibly decide you hate. I haven't had much luck with the Taurus 1911. The RIA is probably the best 'entry level' 1911. Heard of a lot of people building them into something more custom.
"Gun control should mean hitting your target every time."
Please try to remember- I have a very dry sense of humor. It usually sounds mean, but isn't meant to be.
I had a Taurus 1911 with an ambi safety but I felt like it stuck out too much. I also don't like how easy it ws to snick safety off.
Now I have a Sig 1911 Ultra and I love it. External extractor and no ambi.
Last edited by mkh; November 11th, 2012 at 09:27 PM. Reason: Spelling
Regarding the parts in bold:
1: Desired Characteristics: It's all very personal, what I may like could be very different than what someone else likes or needs.
2: Yes and no, some will like them, some will hate them...not all external extractors are created equal.
3: Maybe yes, maybe no. What do you plan on doing with the gun? If you plan on doing and IDPA or attending some more advanced training, you may want the ambi safety.
This is a long piece I wrote on 1911s, book mark it and read over it when you can.
Guns, Guns, & More Gosh Darn Guns: 1911 Buyer's Reference Guide - Revised 2012-06-16
As for specific characteristics...
I'll go with the proverbial:
A good trigger you can manage, sights you can see and a de-horning job.
To that I would add a beaver tail grip safety and elongated thumb safety.
That to me is the bare bones requirements.
I prefer steel framed guns. and a host of other specifics, most of which can be seen here: I Am Proud to Present My Nighthawk Custom Talon Bob-Rail
It all depends on how much you plan on doing with the gun and what do you want to spend.
But again, what's X vs. Y is going to be totally subjective.
A 5" gull frame gun is going to be less ideal as a discreet carry gun and a 3" Small frame gun is going to less ideal than a home defense gun etc.
JD thanks for the article great read. Thanks again
-- I don't always post from my mobile but when I do, I prefer Tapatalk.
"Rebellion against tyrants is obedience to God." - Benjamin Franklin
"Experience: that most brutal of teachers. But you learn, my God do you learn." - C.S. Lewis
Excellent guide from JD.
This link is also a great reference when selecting a 1911. Brian covers many models in different price ranges for those unfamiliar with what is out there.
Buyer's guide for all you 1911 addicts......
May you be in Heaven before the Devil knows you're dead
I would suggest that if your just getting into 1911's and not sure if your gonna like it,if you buy a RIA 1911 that can be had for around $400 ish,if you decide it's not for you you can very likely resale without losing any money,here is a list of RIA 1911's ans some are even 9mm.Scroll down to second from the last page.
Also the following site
"Outside of the killings, Washington has one of the lowest crime rates in the country,"
--Mayor Marion Barry, Washington , DC .
RIA`s Rock,some of mine at under $500 eacs.All are EDC reliable. . All in 45ACP.
I don't want to break any Forum rules by recommending another handgun forum, but I can highly recommend the 1911 Forum (1911Forum - Powered by vBulletin) if you are new to the 1911 platform. There is a wealth of information contained there and helpful information for a person wanting to purchase their first 1911. There are sub-forums specific to each manufacturer of 1911's so you can ask folks interested in a particular 1911 questions you might have regarding a specific pistol. I purchased my first 1911 (Colt Lightweight Commander) in 2011 during the centennial of the design. The 1911 is a beautiful pistol and mine fits my hand perfectly. They can become a very expensive addiction......
To me the extractor is irrelevant as long as you have proven reliability with said pistol by firing more than just a box or two of ammo. For a personal defense tool I do prefer ambidextrous safety in the case of a 1911- otherwise NO safety. That is just less movement you have to do when the SHTF. There are documented cases of people getting shot in their dominant hand. That would make using a non-ambidextrous tool very difficult.