This is a discussion on USMC Snipers May Be In Trouble within the Law Enforcement, Military & Homeland Security Discussion forums, part of the Related Topics category; I personally do not care if our Marines take a porkchop & bacon dump on dead insurgents. But, we live in a new world where ...
I personally do not care if our Marines take a porkchop & bacon dump on dead insurgents. But, we live in a new world where information bounces all across the globe in a matter of seconds.
You HAVE to keep this in mind now. They didn't and they're gonna pay big time.
If ye love wealth better than liberty, the tranquility of servitude than the animated contest of freedom, go from us in peace. We ask not your counsels or arms. Crouch down and lick the hands which feed you. May your chains sit lightly upon you, and may posterity forget that you were our countrymen.
Not that I believe this to be "right", but the only one(s) who should be punished is the one who took the video and the one(s) who published it. If you have never been in combat you may not understand.
LEARN something today so you can TEACH something tomorrow.Dominus Vobiscum <))>(Where is the wisdom that we have lost in knowledge?" T.S. Elliot
This is COMPLETELY unacceptable, why did they let this photographer anywhere near this event?
War is hell!
I always find it amazing that 'bleeding hearts' want to make a big deal out of such an episode, but when the enemy takes our troops and hangs them on bridges to burn their bodies or cuts their heads off while still alive...oh, well that's just war?
While I do understand the higher standards we should uphold, I do not see much of a story here...call me cold-hearted, I guess.
Our military can take care of this internally...story over!
Proverbs 27:12 says: “The prudent see danger and take refuge, but the simple keep going and suffer for it.”
Certified Glock Armorer
NRA Life Member
The only issue I have here is that when they swore their oath, they agreed to live by the Uniform Code of Military Justice, and further, Marines pride themselves in keeping themselves held to a higher standard and honor. I have two sons in the Marines and one in the Navy.
urinating on a dead body would basically be desecrating the body, perhaps not by real physical damage, but it is still an act that we, hopefully living under a higher set of moral values, should not stoop to committing.
Our enemies often have no problem committing atrocities. We, as a people, should not allow ourselves to be dragged down to their level.
However, war has a way of bringing out the worst in any person, especially when you see day in and day out what evils are actually out there in the world.
I do not worry that this will make the Taliban or Al Queda hate us any more than they already do. We are infidels in their eyes and deserve whatever they do to us.
What I will say is that I don't ever seem to hear any of the leaders of Pakistan, Afganistan and all of the Arabian/Muslim world coming out in the headlines decrying every last barbaric act committed against non-muslims in the name of Islam and demanding they all be brought to justice for their crimes. Makes one go, "Hmmmmmmmm....."
Oh, and as to atrocities, check the Old Testament: Then Saul said, ‘Thus shall you say to David, “The king desires no marriage present except a hundred foreskins of the Philistines, that he may be avenged on the king’s enemies”‘. [1 Samuel 18:20-25 (NRSV)] I doubt that they were taken from Philistines after a Brit milah..... O_o
Fortune Favors the Bold!
We should have just killed them all, bred their woman, and declared it the 51st and 52nd states. Built a Protestant and Catholic church and opened up a Starbucks and McDonalds.
Then asked who wants to be the next country to harm one hair on one Americans head, cause your next.
" Blessed is that man, who when facing death, thinks only of his front sight"
I must be in the minority, and that's ok. Just to address what I personally teach my children...
While I teach my children about love, respect, discipline...and show them by example....I also teach them with equal resolution the cold hard facts of life. Life is tough, people are mean. You have to be even more mean (at certain times) to survive and to come out on top.
I have two daughters. If I accomplish my goal...neither will ever be a victim.
I am a combat vet, LEO, 2nd degree black belt in Aikido. As I said before, while I may pass for "Joe Normal"...I know how harsh this world is and what it takes to survive and what it will take to survive the coming decades.
Both of my daughters will be black belts by 9. Both will be proficiently trained in handguns and rifles by 13. I guess not many others would teach their 4 year old the "alternate" use for a #2 pencil if a stranger approaches her when mommy & daddy aren't around. When she gets to grade school and starts using pens I will teach her the effectiveness of a Bic to the jugular.
So in short...would I teach my children it is ok to piss on the enemy in war? Yes. There is no room for weakness in this world. It takes a balance of compassion and cruelty to survive.
We don't have to ask who wants to be next...it appears we pick them by lot.
Those are cold hard facts, not from a left wing fruit cake rag of a magazine.
You ask who is next...what about Iran. Sure.
Bottom line is that the act violated orders, which are made clear to everyone upon arrival in country. Any enemy dead are to be treated with respect. Marine infantryman are expected to be professional warriors (the sniper rifle makes it clear these are grunts), they were not acting as professionals IMO.
Anyone who thinks this is okay should go read about what a strategic corporal is.
Fortes Fortuna Juvat
Former, USMC 0311, OIF/OEF vet
NRA Pistol/Rifle/Shotgun/Reloading Instructor, RSO, Ohio CHL Instructor
All of them have had the appropriate briefings. They knew the propraganda risks of this. They should have known better? And on top of it all a photographer to document this, good grief?
Hope it does not cause another beheading from these animals.
My WI. CCW Permit Statistics
Applied & Hand delivered to DOJ: 11/01/2011
Check # 4548 Cleared: .............. 11/07/2011
Permit #39 received via USPS: .... 11/02/2011
Last edited by HotGuns; January 12th, 2012 at 10:27 PM. Reason: langauge workaround
“I am consistently on record and will continue to be on record as opposing concealed carry.”
- Barack Obama Chicago Tribune, April 27, 2004
Those Marines picked a very bad time for their stunt and video. The US is backing a power sharing deal between Karzai and the Taliban: It's related to the withdrawl from Afghanistan strategy. Recently Biben said the Taliban is not the enemy: Duh.
Pentagon condemns MarinesDefense Secretary Leon Panetta on Thursday harshly condemned alleged behavior in a video that appears to show U.S. Marines urinating on the corpses of Taliban fighters. The Pentagon chief said he'd ordered a full investigation into the alleged incident, which comes amid sensitive diplomatic initiatives to try to advance reconciliation talks with the Taliban.
Well I sure dont have a problem with a sniper team showing thier contempt and disrespect for the enemy..They can do what ever they want with them...Hope the enemy fears them...Imagine the enemy these juys missed grousing about thier mates getting urinated on....really...What if the reality is that the spin-up over their "outrageous" act gets these guys a hot shower and messhall food ??..and they are ok with that??..what if they are really good at what they do...really ...sniper teams turn the enemy into meat and every one (lots and lots of politicans at least) is SO outraged about the team urinated on them...nothing has been said about the grief those urinated bodys represent.....thats just crazy...what if that sniper team is doing what is expected by the locals...because they hated and dispised by everyone breathing god's good air....if I was there I'd been sure those men got well hydrated, and didnt lack for anything I could provide...and the cleanest spot in that vid is the deadmans chest
Last edited by HotGuns; January 12th, 2012 at 10:26 PM. Reason: language workaround
Back in the day when you could actually tell a man from a woman and not have to argue about, we wouldnt have wasted time taking a whiz on them, it would just dry off eventually.
We would have just cut their heads off and put them on a stick. We didnt care if the weenies in this world got offended or not. They werent the ones out there doing the shooting, so their opinions meant nothing.