This is a discussion on Hmmm: man shoots dog, loses... within the In the News: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly forums, part of the The Back Porch category; [QUOTE=wmhawth;2432029]Not harsh enough in my opinion. Dogs can and do get loose. This doesn't mean we should just blow them away in the neighborhood. This ...
[QUOTE=wmhawth;2432029]Not harsh enough in my opinion. Dogs can and do get loose. This doesn't mean we should just blow them away in the neighborhood.
This guy is a sorry pig besides being a loose cannon in the community and a hazard to everyone. He needs to lose more than his firearms if you ask me.[/QUOTE
Unbelievable how many of you agree with someone having their firearms confiscated by the government for shooting a dog running at him. You can call the guy names, threaten him, and in general over react to the death of an animal. Simple truth, it was NOT HIS FAULT. Blame the dog owner. If you let your dog run at people something bad will eventually happen. As the dog owner, you owe it to the neighborhood, and THE DOG, to be responsible. These reactions of supporting this guy losing all of his guns are shocking to me. There are all kinds of anti-freedom people in this country who want to take our guns. I didn't think I'd bump into so many on this forum.
Dogs loose is often a problem here. In particular, my one neighbor's dogs are often over here - one tore up the cushions on my outdoor furniture. A neighbor's dog killed my ducks ON MY PROPERTY - we used to put those ducks inside every night to keep them from predators. I agree the problem is the owners. However, my one neighbor's dog had my little dog in it's mouth ON MY PROPERTY - had I been carrying I honestly would have shot it. Yes dogs sometimes get out. They're not always aggressive. But sometimes they can be.
This sign showed up at the end of my road about 2 weeks ago. (for the record I did not put it up) I don't go around gunning for every loose dog around here, but if I feel me, my family or my animals are threatened I will protect us. I'll try a nearby shot to the ground first if I can...
"Rusty was running toward their neighbor, Yee, when witnesses say Yee pulled out a gun and shot Rusty."
Keep your dogs tied up, fenced up, or on a leash and this doesn't happen. People who choose not to have pets shouldn't have to deal with yours.
My wife and I were almost the victim of a local neighborhood dog that had gotten out last year.
We thought it was a stray, it ran towards us and when it got to within 6 feet, started barking and being aggressive. It then tried to attack my wife, and I stepped in between and distracted it with my baseball cap. My wife then flanked it and we just made a lot of noise. Fortunately he backed off and we called animal control. I was not carrying at the time but have been carrying on our neighborhood walks ever since.
To continue the story. We contacted the HOA to let them know about a dangerous stray dog. One of the neighbors recognized the description and replied to all claiming it was a highly trained, very expensive hunting dog. He was indignant and abusive at the suggestion that the dog had tried to attack us.
Just as we were starting to feel we had overreacted, the dog got out again and this time bit a large chunk out of the butt of a female neighbor walking on her own. The dog was put down--and just about everyone blames the owner, not the dog.
I am just thankful that it didn't attack one of the many kids that play in our neighborhood.
Don't bring a knife to a gun fight...unless it's strapped to a gun.
That's most likely what would happen to someone here in those circumstances as well..... they'ld lose guns, be charged, etc.
The " if a dog runs at me I'll shoot it mentality" .... doesn't sell and hold salt.... unless it's truly "attacking" ... and running up to someone ... is not an attact and shooting it is a stupid act with no justification for that type of reaction.
I don't make jokes. I just watch the government and report the facts. --- Will Rogers ---
Chief Justice John Roberts : "I don't see how you can read Heller and not take away from it the notion that the Second Amendment...was extremely important to the framers in their view of what liberty meant."
Proverbs 27:12 says: “The prudent see danger and take refuge, but the simple keep going and suffer for it.”
Certified Glock Armorer
NRA Life Member
Of course the dog shouldn't be running loose. No one disputes that.
People freaking love dogs, man. It's irrational.
I wouldn't shoot a known family pet unless it bit me, but I also don't agree with taking away guns. 100 guns is a lot of money. A dog is cheap. With that being said, if some dude shot my dog when I was a kid (he's in his late teens and lives with my dad) I would have a problem with it, but I wouldn't expect the courts to do anything.
I was the guy who always thought Michael Vick got a bad rap.
Same thing with my Borzoi (Russian Wolfhound). She ran past my wife and got outside. A lady jumped in her car and was terrified. That dog also would not hurt a fly. They both wanted to play. We were much younger then (20 years ago) and make sure our dogs are kept on a leash when they need to be.
To saymight be your opinion but an ill informed one and a fallacy proven over and over again.....IMOAnyone but an 'idiot' should know the difference between a "wanna pet me" charge and an "I'm going to kill you" charge.
Then I heard the voice of the Lord saying, “Whom shall I send? And who will go for us?”
And I said, “Here am I. Send me!”
If a LEO shoots a dog inside a fenced in yard very few people say anything about it. A civilian shoots a loose dog that is acting aggressively and he should lose his permit and guns?
Interesting double standards we see nowadays.
I'd hate for my dog to ever get shot, but if I screw up and allow her to get out of our yard and she gets hostile with a person out on a stroll, whatever happens is on me. Asking for the person who shot the dog to lose his rights and possessions seems a bit far fetched by my logic
sent via iCarry