The common wisdom is that you don't draw when the BG has his gun trained on you.
The common wisdom is also (and data shows) that action beats reaction.
So it is better to draw ane immediately fire (action) betting that you can stop the BG before he shoots you,
or is it better to bet that he just wants your 'stuff' and won't shoot you.
Hmmmm... Lots to consider.
That's a tough spot to be in. The truth is that if multiple assailants have you dead to rights at gun point, you are probably going to get shot regardless of whether or not you are armed. But having them discover that you are armed makes them more likely to shoot you, IMHO. They are going to be PO'ed that you were armed and even if you give up the weapon without a fight, they'll probably just shoot you with it. If it is just one assailant, then maybe you have a chance.
The best way to avoid the situation would be to not allow them to get the drop on you in the first place. Which leads to another interesting question. At what point are you justified to draw your weapon and have it at your side, if you are being approached by people that make you nervous? Too soon and you could end up in jail, too late and you could end up dead. Again, a tough spot with no easy answer. You just have to trust your judgement and hope for the best.
Just my opinion, but I doubt that anyone can take comfort in assuming that an armed robbery will remain just that. Too many stories about victims surrendering everything, just to take a shot to the head, "because they can".....I will assume the very worst and try to interupt the process. Sandpiper
That being said I am no John Wayne. If the gun is pointed directly at me he gets my wallet...if he is distracted (even briefly) I would consider trying to draw.
However, if he tries to move me to a different location ("get in the alley" ..etc) I would have to consider the fact my life is already forfeit if I don't try to defend myself
We must reject the idea that every time a law's broken, society is guilty rather than the law breaker. It is time to restore the American precept that each individual is responsible for his actions....Ronald Reagan
Cooperate to the point that I had an advantage and then stop coorperating with prejudice.
I know f what it feels like to have a gun pointed at me. To keep it short, 1996, junior in highschool, miami FL. at a light in family minivan driving to arbys with my sister. Guy ran right up to my window and stuck his snub nose 357 right up my head...(I could actually see hollow point rounds in the chambers... He said moved, and I listened. I was 17. I didnt have a knife let alone a gun. I know what the shock feels like...
I couldn't believe though , the idiot had me hop in the middle row while he drove around... What if I had had a knife or a gun.
It was an amazing gift from God that my sister and I survived the whole ordeal.( He is in for 50yrs +)
I have had a few other close calls... each being different. If my family or myself was threatened, and for a second or two had an advantage...
Toss your wallet to his/her shooting side.
Trying to draw on a gun that is already pointed at you is a bad idea. I'd start dropping stuff on the ground too. If an opening arose, I might try but know the odds aren't good. They come into the situation more prepared and with a heightened level of adrenaline. Their tunnel vision might help you but who knows. There really is no good answer until you are in that position.
(from WI codes)939.48 Self-defense and defense of others.
(1) A person is privileged to threaten or intentionally use force against another for the purpose of preventing or terminating what the person reasonably believes to be an unlawful interference with his or her person by such other person. The actor may intentionally use only such force or threat thereof as the actor reasonably believes is necessary to prevent or terminate the interference. The actor may not intentionally use force which is intended or likely to cause death or great bodily harm unless the actor reasonably believes that such force is necessary to prevent imminent death or great bodily harm to himself or herself.
...when someone's holding a gun on you...you're not dealing with a thief...you're dealing with a person who's putting you in fear of your life...and has threatened shooting you to get what he wants...the property doesn't matter at that point...
...what we CHOOSE to do depends upon all the facts and circumstances...knowing our state laws regarding self defense and deadly force is step 1...having a good working knowledge of our options gives us a foundation for our decisions...and is one thing less to think through at the time...the decisions are as varied and different as we are...but in the situation described, deadly force would be REASONABLE...
If I can survive by complying then I would have to consider giving the wallet etc depending on the perps actions/demeanor. Keeping eye contact would be a must if my mind was thinking about"if I had enough time if he glances away", otherwise it depends on if his weapon is drawn and pointed at my face.I can replace the wallet,cant replace me or family
I'll pull the hood of my cloak over my head and the perps will walk away wondering what just happened.
"1. If carrying IWB, would you ever try to outdraw someone that is pointing a gun at you? I could possibly see telling them they can have your wallet while reaching back to get the gun. Right before drawing, point behind them and say, "there's a cop" and drawing when they turn to look. Obviously very risky unless you're Billy the Kid. IWB at 4:00, they would probably never know I had a gun if I gave them my wallet and cell phone."
Three pages of replies and the question I did not see asked was: Why is this posted on the Open Carry thread?