This is a discussion on Nomenclature within the Reference & "How To" Forum forums, part of the Related Topics category; That's "barrette" - just couldn't resist . I roll my eyes at this as well - "Also, is it a weapon, firearm, gun or piece?" ...
That's "barrette" - just couldn't resist .
I roll my eyes at this as well - "Also, is it a weapon, firearm, gun or piece?"
It's a handgun, it's a gat. If it's a car handgun, then it's a hoopdi-gat
The range I'm at has a "no calling a firearm a weapon" policy even tho' 40-50% of the shooters are shooting handguns with the intention of practicing for SD. About 25% of our shooters also have AR/AK's/etc. The difference is supposed to be a weapon is for shooting people, but they also would like to maintain that milsurp type rifles have "no sporting purpose". PC is for idiots. I finally got them to mostly stop (or give up) the "sporting purpose" nonsense.
I'm from Oregon.. pronunciation of that aside, I spent some time in NC a few summers back. On a quick run to Walmart, the checker in a deep southern accent asked if I'd "pull my buggy up". It took two or three repeats and some fast wheels spinning before I realized she was referring to my shopping cart.
I'm on the fence on this one. Coming from a technical background I understand the importance of being specific about what you talk about. However, English is such a ... fluid .. language that I think a bit of forgiveness is useful on common things.
Context is important and applies constraints on what level of precision is required.
On the online forums I just let that stuff slide. In face to face conversation with "gun folks" I like to use the correct terminology In hopes they may think I know what the hell I'm talking about. YMMV
Clip or magazine. If it's empty what good is it doing ya?
We call it a buggy as well.
If at the range and I am with someone and we are shooting AKs. If my buddy ask for a clip I will hand him a recharging clip, if he wants a new Magazine he will have to ask for it.
When I taught, we always used the proper nomenclature, along with definitions ie; a Clip holds ammunition and a magazine feeds ammunition, that was 25 years ago now I don't know what they teach in HALO but it might be different now, could someone elaborate.
I carry a gun cause a cop is too heavy.
Someone said clips store ammo, magazines feed ammo. Then maybe it should be called a clip when it's in the safe or your holster. Once you insert it into the weapon (not gun, because a gun is artillery) it becomes a magazine.
Now on to the other ones;
I agree, when did revolvers stop being pistols? If revolvers are not pistols, then that means my CPL (Michigan Concealed Pistol License) does not allow me to carry my snub nose 38.
While on that subject, can we stop having page after page of arguments over whether it's a CPL, CCW, CPC, PCC. etc. They are all pieces of paper that allow you to hide a gun on your person!
Then there is the argument about the term CCW referring to a crime of carrying a concealed weapon. I'm sure there must be at least one state that actually calls it s CCW license.
If it gets the idea across, the person reading it understands what the poster meant, then why not just let it slide. No reason to label someone a newbie, or ignorant just because they used a perfectly acceptable (to most reasonable people) term instead of the "Correct" term.
This post and any and all spelling errors where intentionally meant to stir up more discussion and make us all look like arrogant internet jerks.
a box magazine feeds ammunition to a firearm. It typically consists of a spring, follower, metal box and a foot plate
a stripper clip is used to load a box magazine quickly. It typically consists of a bent or stamped piece of metal to hold the rims of the ammunition cases.
in most cases a box magazine is shortened to just magazine and stripper clip is shortened to clip. IMO the 2 terms are not interchangeable.
While I don't actively correct people that call a magazine a clip I will call it a magazine. Whether or not they pick up on it is up to them.
There is something about firing 4,200 thirty millimeter rounds/min that makes me feel all warm and fuzzy inside.
I use the term clip for magazine all the time.
"The Second Amendment: America's Original Homeland Security"
A clip feeds a magazine, a magazine feeds a chamber.
All things considered, I am more concerned about ignorance of a firearm's functions than about adherence to 'current', 'PC' nomenclature. For example, I know many WWII and Korean Vets who refer to the sidearms they carried as "45 Automatics". Coming from them, I do not mind, because they surely understand the difference between a semi-automatic and a full auto. Coming from a novice or a reporter who does not understand the difference between semi-auto and full-auto, I would be much more concerned.
So, if you talk to a grizzled old guy who refers to the thingy that fed ammunition into his Thompson as a 'clip' instead of a 'magazine', cut him a little slack
Because he/they were taught that way by the military, "Automatic Pistol CAL. 45, M1911 and M1911A1."For example, I know many WWII and Korean Vets who refer to the sidearms they carried as "45 Automatics". Coming from them, I do not mind, because they surely understand the difference between a semi-automatic and a full auto. Coming from a novice or a reporter who does not understand the difference between semi-auto and full-auto, I would be much more concerned.
In Patent 984519, both John Browning and the US Patent Office refer to it as Automatic/Automatic Weapon/Automatic Weapons.
I really doubt you'd find a old grizzled USGI who would refer to a magazine for his weapon as a "clip" (unless his weapon was an M1 Garand or an '03 that accepted stripper clips), not the way nomenclature was taught in boot.So, if you talk to a grizzled old guy who refers to the thingy that fed ammunition into his Thompson as a 'clip' instead of a 'magazine', cut him a little slack
"The pistol, learn it well, carry it always ..." ~ Jeff Cooper
"Terrorists: They hated you yesterday, they hate you today, and they will hate you tomorrow.
End the cycle of hatred, donít give them a tomorrow.
Founder of the BDA Pony Club