I've waited all these posts to make my suggeston. I know you said pump, but as a different option to consider...
I have a Stoeger Coach Gun Supreme (in 12 ga.) as my HD gun.
Stoeger Coach Gun Supreme in 12-Gauge
I'm still armed with my Kimber at home, but I can pull out the 'initial welcome wagon' for the individual(s) kicking in a door or window...then Mr. Kimber comes calling.
I had the gun reworked for smooth operation and ease of ejecting shells. I can shoot and reload fairly quickly.
How many shots do you need at home?
OMO and I know others will vary a lot!