I have them both for a 5" 1911 and can honestly say I would never sell either one of them. Get them both and spend the next year deciding which one you like
.
For clarification, I have the regular In-Cognito in cowhide trimmed with stingray across the top. It's not the deluxe so I can't comment on the suede or kydex. The VM-II stays open a bit more when the gun is drawn, but a one handed reholster is equally doable with either one of them. They ride about the same on the belt, I haven't noticed a big difference. The belt loops on the In-C rotate on the snaps and the VM-II's loops don't. The In_C covers more of the gun above the belt than the VM-II. There are some other differences but none of them make one better than the other to me. Here's a picture of them both on a belt so you can see how they ride. Left to right is the Alessi PCW, In-Cognito, and VM-II. Good luck, you can't go wrong with either one of them.
