I say go for it...besides...you might need the different options...and one can be your "nice holster" and the other the "work holster"
...well...at least that'd be my justification....and just to prove it...I've got a K&D thunderbird on order...should be here at the end of Feb, but until then I am enjoying the Supertuck...and will continue to use it even after the K&D gets here...different occasions call for different holsters
