pirate

Both will work for whitetail deer in NC, but your ranges that you quoted are not realistic for these rifles. Most dear in our state (NC) are taken at ranges less than 100 yards no matter what "tall tales" from other hunters you may hear. I have taken several dear with miliatry surplus rifles and the Mosin Nagant's (91/30, M38 and M44) can do a good job within limits. The 7.62x54R is compairable with the 30.06, but the typical Mosin Nagant (its pronouned like MOseen NAgon) is only capable of 3 inch groups at 100 yards in my opinion. The 7.62x39 round is ballisticly slightly less powerful thanthe 30-30 but will work at "bush gun ranges"
Here is a M38 Mosin Nagant with a ATI stock and Extended Eye Relief (EER) 2.5X scope mounted to the rear sight base. If you use a "standard scope you will have to drill and tap the reciever. I personally like the EER (scout scope) setup on this rifle and I can keep the rounds in the black at 100 yards with this scope.


Mosin Nagant M38


Other options with better accuracy include:
Yugo 24/47 Mauser with 2x scout scope mounted


Swiss K31 with EER scope


I like the scout scope mounted to the rear sight base of these Milsurps because I can have them back to the oiginal configeration in 30 minutes and it does not permanently alter the gun in any way.

__________________
Why own a "(G)block" when you can drive a Kahr!

When I leave the castle:
S&W 642 Airweight, CZ RAMI, Springfield XD 9mm, Kahr PM9, Kahr CW40, S&W Model 10-7, SIG P6, Ruger Police Service Six, Browning Hi Power, Star Firestar 9mm, CZ82, Colt Commander

Shadowsbane

First of all I would like to thank you all for the responses, great information has been passed on to me. I especially found the caliber comarisons to be quite helpfull in weighting the pros/cons.

And now a bit of information concerning my question.


Due to various reasons including my putting my wife through college, her inability to work next semester (there by loosing her free unlimited meal plan on campus), and rising cost of rent, insurance, and well just about everything else my hunting is not just for sport this season, but is (at this time)the most viable option to keep my family well fed, and a roof over our heads. Money is going to be tight after the summer so I am trying to plan ahead, before things get "too tight". That is why I asked about the Nagants and SKS firearms as I have heard they were dirt cheap and reliable as all hell, but I had heard nothing more than that so I went to the "men on the mountain" so to speak to search for information, and once again I was well rewarded with a good deal of information so thank you.



And now to respond to the comments.

I have hunted bear in the past with a 30-30 winchester, by all means it is not my prefered option, but shot placement rules all in the end and I did not feel underguned in that senario. However I also beleive that the power of the 308 or equivelent is far more suited to such an endeavor.

The 200-300 range is on abandoned farmland that I have recently given permission to use for hunting, I have not seen it yet but the owner has stated that the distance pertaining to the safest field of fire I can obtain is about 300-400 yards long. (As in there are no residences for a good distance on that part of the land). My preference is nice and close, for anything that cant shoot me back, but I wanted to have the option if it was the only one available. This distance also only pertains to deer as any location I could hunt bear would offer a much smaller range opportunity.

Accuracy is my biggest issue, as the last thing I want to do is give some poor animal a slow death with a wound in the gut. I was told that 00 buck in a full choke would harm my shotgun and as stated in the first post a new barrel cost more than a "new" rifle. That being said seems like the options I presented appear to be a crap shoot at best as to their ability to group nicely.

I know nothing at all about weapons in 8mm, except it was the caliber of the kar98 (I think) It sounds like a good possiblity if I can find one cheapish. As does the 308 savage.

Hmm seems like I need to do some more searching, but in the meantime looks like its time to get my fishing gear out.

Thank you again for all your suggestions and advice. It was all great food for thought so to speak.

__________________
Now, we must all fear evil men. But there is another kind of evil which we must fear most, and that is the indifference of good men.