Defensive Carry banner

1 - 20 of 80 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
11,499 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Monday on my way home from work I stopped at Costco and picked up some stuff. I had the back of the Cherokee loaded down pretty well with milk, canned foods and other items so when I got home and pulled into the garage I left the garage door up and opened the Cherokee up and had the kids help me bring everything inside. I was handing them items and they were bringing the stuff into the house.

After we emptied the Jeep out, and I had closed the back and was locking it I heard a voice from out on the street say "Excuse me." I turned and saw a man at the base of my driveway looking up at me (our driveway sloped up to the garage a bit)

He asked me why I had a gun on (XD .40 in a Blackhawk serpa). And in response, I asked him who he was and why it mattered to him.

Now get this, he says he is new in the neighborhood, is a police officer and wants to know if I have a permit. I told him that I did have a permit and ask him if he is a Shelby County Sheriff's Deputy (since we live in the County) and this guys says no, he is a Memphis City officer!

At this point I got a little indignant. I was actually in my garage, on my property and this clown stops while walking by my house to harass me. So, I tell him that even if I didn't have a permit, I am on my property and don't need one to open or conceal carry on my property and since he is way, way outside his jurisdiction, maybe he shouldn't try to be the neighborhood cop and just be a neighbor.

At this point I get a bit of attitude from a guy standing in my driveway, harassing me about something he obviously does not like (I can tell this guy is not in favor of us private peons carrying) and so I tell him to tell his story walking and to get the hell off my property.

He did but I expect to get some dirty looks when I ride my bike around the neighborhood now. And I will be sending them right back at him.

So my first bad OC experience is with an off duty, Memphis PD officer who lives out here in the sticks with us and who wanted to give e me a hard time about OC'ing on my own property. What an idiot.

And yes, I am trying to get his name so I can complain to his commander.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,484 Posts
Hold the line.

Now that I'm back in West Tennessee, we need to meet up some time.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,945 Posts
Not having been there I can't second guess you but it would seem you might have cut him some slack and with a small amount of courtesy perhaps even made an ally of him. He was obviously out of line but winning that battle might not profit you much.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
358 Posts
wow...what a jerk.:blink:


sometimes i just wanna...........!!!!!:rant:!!!!!.........grrrrr
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,507 Posts
I'm torn Mike. While I agree a neighborhood ally is always great, I really don't like being told I can't do something (you can tell my time in the Army went well :blink:).

I guess its one of those "you just had to be there" moments. after work, from the store unloading all the grub and then some stranger new to the area questioning your exercising of a God given and Constitutionally backed right.

The more I type the more I am getting annoyed for ya.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
792 Posts
Not having been there I can't second guess you but it would seem you might have cut him some slack and with a small amount of courtesy perhaps even made an ally of him. He was obviously out of line but winning that battle might not profit you much.

I agree he was way out of line,. But I agree with this post,. I think I would have asked to see his badge (only right if off duty) and showed him my permit to make him happy,. If he doesn't like people carrying, then it wouldn't have done any good, but ya never know,.. Making enemies out of neighbors has never done me any good at all,... In fact just the opposite for sure..
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,106 Posts
TN Mike,
I'm usually the first to step up and say cooperation is the best route. But I am with you 100%. You are on your own property, minding your own business, and somebody claiming to be an off-duty officer from another jurisdiction starts hassling you? Not cool...not cool at all. I can't help but wonder if he is a rookie. Rookies tend to sniff around for trouble. Unfortunately, they often find it. I would have done exactly what you did. Told him to enjoy his walk and to get back to it. If he wants to find some illegal guns, his time would be better spent back in the town where he works. Let him start shaking down a few of the gangbangers running around south Memphis...he will find more guns than he knows what to do with.
Gonzo
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
862 Posts
Crazy! Well hopefully he'll come around. Good luck either way.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
631 Posts
I would have done 2 things as soon as he said he was a cop.

Ask to see his badge

Ask if he has a warrant.

No badge: go away

No warrant: Get the hell off my land.

Find out his name and report his over-reaching self to his commanding officer. "Supercop" we don't need anywhere.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
7,465 Posts
As much as I'm a staunch believer in cc, I'm completely with you on this one, TN Mike.

This guy was wrong on so many levels, it's just ridiculous. However, even though my first reaction would be to follow up with his supervisor as a concerned citizen, you also have to weigh the consequences of further harassment from this bozo. Perhaps the smart thing to do is shrug it off and hope it was a one-time event. You can always pursue it later, if you need to.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
113 Posts
Monday on my way home from work I stopped at Costco and picked up some stuff. I had the back of the Cherokee loaded down pretty well with milk, canned foods and other items so when I got home and pulled into the garage I left the garage door up and opened the Cherokee up and had the kids help me bring everything inside. I was handing them items and they were bringing the stuff into the house.

After we emptied the Jeep out, and I had closed the back and was locking it I heard a voice from out on the street say "Excuse me." I turned and saw a man at the base of my driveway looking up at me (our driveway sloped up to the garage a bit)

He asked me why I had a gun on (XD .40 in a Blackhawk serpa). And in response, I asked him who he was and why it mattered to him.

Now get this, he says he is new in the neighborhood, is a police officer and wants to know if I have a permit. I told him that I did have a permit and ask him if he is a Shelby County Sheriff's Deputy (since we live in the County) and this guys says no, he is a Memphis City officer!

At this point I got a little indignant. I was actually in my garage, on my property and this clown stops while walking by my house to harass me. So, I tell him that even if I didn't have a permit, I am on my property and don't need one to open or conceal carry on my property and since he is way, way outside his jurisdiction, maybe he shouldn't try to be the neighborhood cop and just be a neighbor.

At this point I get a bit of attitude from a guy standing in my driveway, harassing me about something he obviously does not like (I can tell this guy is not in favor of us private peons carrying) and so I tell him to tell his story walking and to get the hell off my property.

He did but I expect to get some dirty looks when I ride my bike around the neighborhood now. And I will be sending them right back at him.

So my first bad OC experience is with an off duty, Memphis PD officer who lives out here in the sticks with us and who wanted to give e me a hard time about OC'ing on my own property. What an idiot.

And yes, I am trying to get his name so I can complain to his commander.
WOW

Well some people really have the nerve to stick there noses where they don't belong.

Maybe you should have called 911 if he was on your property. HAHA
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
36,326 Posts
So my first bad OC experience is with an off duty, Memphis PD officer who lives out here in the sticks with us and who wanted to give e me a hard time about OC'ing on my own property.
Isn't it a wonder that he's living all the way out in Arlington? Not really. And he's got the gall to question you about the wisdom, sanity or right you have to carry firearms ... on your own property, no less? WTH went wrong with his training, or has he simply been blind all these years in the Memphis PD? He needs only open his town's newspaper for a week, to be horrified by how much crime passes for "normal" on any day of the week, in Memphis. Or, does he think you aren't aware of it, that you're going to leave the safety and security of your family to whim, chance and a PD that believes like he does??

It would be interesting to hear his commanding officer's viewpoint on why you're getting the sticky end of his attitude.
 

·
Administrator
Joined
·
21,179 Posts
So what happens to the next OC'er in Memphis that this guy runs into? Or the one his buddies run into after hearing about that guy open carrying with an attitude?

What happened to this guy whose posts I love reading?

I do care how they (the sheeple) feel to an extent. I carry openly but I do it in the utmost responsible and safe manner. I use a level II security holster. I dress in a presentable manner and I am polite, even if someone were to have an adverse reaction to my openly carried firearm. I think of myself as an Ambassador of Open Carry to the uninformed. I have had interactions with people (mostly from a state other than Tennessee) who come from an anti mind set and have left after speaking to me with at least a different opinion of people who carry. It's because I didn't rant about my right to carry and how I didn't care if they liked it or not, even if that is exactly how I feel.

Bark'n is right, we may not agree with the sheeple, but they vote and are citizens of the USA as much as we are. To just treat them as scum just because they don't carry or don't support our right to do so isn't exactly civil or in our best interest.
Sorry Mike, I respect you a lot, but you let me down on this one.:9:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,006 Posts
After we emptied the Jeep out, and I had closed the back and was locking it I heard a voice from out on the street say "Excuse me." I turned and saw a man at the base of my driveway looking up at me (our driveway sloped up to the garage a bit)

He asked me why I had a gun on (XD .40 in a Blackhawk serpa). And in response, I asked him who he was and why it mattered to him.

Now get this, he says he is new in the neighborhood, is a police officer and wants to know if I have a permit.

This is where I ask to see a badge.
then state "I am on my property and don't need one to open or conceal carry on my property."
have a nice day and good by.

I say good job mike!!
He SHOULD know the laws he swore to uphold.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
36,326 Posts
So what happens to the next OC'er in Memphis that this guy runs into? Or the one his buddies run into after hearing about that guy open carrying with an attitude?
Unwillingness to be steamrolled on one's own property, you mean?

Could have happened for any reason. It happened because the passerby saw a firearm. He's just as out of place as if he were to be bitching about the use of the color red on the John Deere mower, which is just as relevant to a passerby attempting to dictate terms and deliver Q&A to a homeowner.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
180 Posts
So what happens to the next OC'er in Memphis that this guy runs into? Or the one his buddies run into after hearing about that guy open carrying with an attitude?

What happened to this guy whose posts I love reading?



Sorry Mike, I respect you a lot, but you let me down on this one.:9:
I might agree except TN Mike said he likes to be an ambassador of OC and educated the uninformed. In this case it was a police officer that does or should know the law. Mike was on his property minding his own business. If a civilian neighbor were to ask he could have used the opportunity to inform them of the law. As it was he shouldn't have to teach the law to the officer of said law so to speak.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
2,939 Posts
Your land. The guy was out of his jurisdiction.

You saw and read his body language, something none of us here did. I trust your reception of his nonverbal indicators.

I'd have told him to shove it also if I sensed he was being a jerk.

His was the attitude that needed adjusting, not yours.

What business is it of his if you have a permit? Plus, like you said, you were on your property so you didn't need a permit.

You'd think with him being new in the neighborhood that he'd make a better effort to be polite. Maybe he was playing "supercop" thinking he had some authority over you.

If someone got snotty with me like that, asking questions that were none of his business, I might have told him to mind his own (expletive) business.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,261 Posts
Good job Mike,
There are cities being sued now for stopping OCers for no reason, and he has no right to question you on your property.
I would find out his name, you just may see him again.:wink:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
483 Posts
He asked me why I had a gun on (XD .40 in a Blackhawk serpa). And in response, I asked him who he was and why it mattered to him.

Now get this, he says he is new in the neighborhood, is a police officer and wants to know if I have a permit.

That would have been the point I would have said hmmm....I am sorry but I am really busy right now but welcome to the neighborhood and have a nice day:wave:

But I don't fault you for your reaction to a putz:twak::bier:
 
1 - 20 of 80 Posts
Top