Defensive Carry banner

1 - 20 of 50 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
568 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Please read the entire post and answer the question at the end if you feel so inclined...just food for thought in these scenarios.

The thought of shooting another CCW'er coming to the sound of gun shots is often brought up as a scenario on these threads. Just look around on here and it is brought up in nearly every thread containing a scenario.

My thoughts on this-
The vast majority of you on here seem to take the stance of flight vs. fight when you are not directly involved in the situation. What makes you think that the other CCW'er believes differently. I understand that we can not possibly know this.
Also, does that really change your feelings on the situation? You could insert the possibility of another person legally carrying comming out of the woodwork and shooting you after you have eliminated a threat or it could be the other way around.

Are we going to constantly live in "fear" of this playing out? I can only address the factors that I can see...not the ones that I can not (like the possible BG accomplice in the back of the store).

QUESTION FOR YOU ALL- Have any of you seen proof of this type of thing being done regularly or irregularly? I have not, but I would be interested in being proven wrong as I may need to change my beliefs on this.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,342 Posts
QUESTION FOR YOU ALL- Have any of you seen proof of this type of thing being done regularly or irregularly?

No.

Regardless though, just because you've neutralized one threat, doesn't mean you drop your guard against any other threat that might present itself.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
568 Posts
Discussion Starter #3
No.

Regardless though, just because you've neutralized one threat, doesn't mean you drop your guard against any other threat that might present itself.
I agree that your guard must stay up. My practice/intention is to reholster once I feel area is safe. This is for when the police arive as much as anything else. I do not want to be a target when I do not feel there is a need to have my weapon drawn.
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
18,125 Posts
I have seen no proof of concealed handgun licensees shooting each other in dire circumstances.That doesent mean it hasn't happened, it just means I havent seen it.

But it could happen and it could happen very easily.

Consider the number of fatal shootings by Police that happen due to mistaken identity. Too common, we hear stories of Cops shooting other Cops in every kind of scenario that you can imagine.

Hopefully, this is something discussed in the class to receive the permit. I know that we do it here, and it is something that every single person needs to be aware of.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
181 Posts
I have not seen any evidence of this happening. I'm a civilian, I'm not heading in the direction of gunfire anymore. I'm getting those I care about out of the area. My concealed weapon stays that way unless I have no other option.

If I have the misfortune to be involved in the fight, I'll also have to remain alert in the aftermath for follow on threats. Living with the fear of being shot by another CCW holder would be low on my list of concerns at that time.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,858 Posts
If we all had CCW badges the likely hood would go way down!! J/K :danceban:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,858 Posts
Gun fire coming one-way. I am going the other. If I were involied and the threat was over I would reholster and still keep SA on high alert for BG friends,leo approaching hopefully wife or family member gave best descripition to dispatch and relayed correct info to LEO's.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,306 Posts

·
Banned
Joined
·
5,252 Posts
QUESTION FOR YOU ALL- Have any of you seen proof of this type of thing being done regularly or irregularly? I have not, but I would be interested in being proven wrong as I may need to change my beliefs on this.
Put me in a life or death encounter and anyone with a weapon IS A THREAT!

If Joe or Jane Blow rally forth to the sounds of guns those using said guns may very well perceive Joe and Jane as accomplices of the threat they have eliminated.

When you are alone in a self defense encounter you have no reasonable expectation of assistance coming to your aide. I have posted before that one of my biggest fears is being shot when I am off duty, by the on duty constabulary. Maybe I should change that to CCW Holder, or add it to my statement.

Also, they don't teach scanning for another threat after you shoot the first threat for grins and giggles. It is taught because badguys, like wolves, tend to travel in numbers that exceed one.

Look at the number of off duty LEO's that have been shot by the on duty LEO's when they respond to the sounds of guns fired by the off duty LEO. There are many such incidents.

When one is involved in a life or death encounter their perception is vastly "skewed" and the ability to rationally think things through at that moment has halted. The body is programmed to survive and does everything it can do ensure that survival. That's why you lose fine motor skill. Blood goes to the large muscle groups to enable you to fight the deadly tiger, or flee. Vision focuses on the threat and auditoy exclusion takes place in many cases.

Your best bet is, if you hear the sounds of guns is to get to cover, usually best accomplished by fleeing the scene, and summoning the on duty constabulary. While it would be unfortunate for a CCW Permit holder to be shot responding to the sounds of guns, it would be justifiable and very understandable IMO.

As an FYI, the off duty officer in the Trolley Square shooting was almost shot by the responding on duty officers. The heat of battle is no time to question someone and ask for ID.

Biker
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,974 Posts
F.A.S.T..... Fight ASSESS SCAN Top Off .... I echo what Biker said..." they don't teach scanning for another threat after you shoot the first threat for grins and giggles".
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
541 Posts
I truly understand the thought process to hide or flee the area where gunfire is, I only have one issue that I worry about for me.......

I have trained and trained with CQC, shooting, weapons training and so on, and it has been drilled into our heads that when gunfire erupts, you move to the gunfire and overwhelm it with superior firepower...

Here in lies the dilema, if this was to happen to me when I return to the states, how will I handle the situation, how will I adapt to being back in the states where that may not be the best answer????

All the training we do, I feel it may be a task in itself re-wiring the mindset, maybe not the warrior mindset as much so to speak...

Thats just something I think about from time to time!!!!:blink:
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
5,252 Posts
I truly understand the thought process to hide or flee the area where gunfire is, I only have one issue that I worry about for me.......

I have trained and trained with CQC, shooting, weapons training and so on, and it has been drilled into our heads that when gunfire erupts, you move to the gunfire and overwhelm it with superior firepower...

Here in lies the dilema, if this was to happen to me when I return to the states, how will I handle the situation, how will I adapt to being back in the states where that may not be the best answer????

All the training we do, I feel it may be a task in itself re-wiring the mindset, maybe not the warrior mindset as much so to speak...

Thats just something I think about from time to time!!!!:blink:
It is a conundrum, is it not?

Believe me, I do understand your quandry, as I have been there myself. All I can say is, it takes some significant "re-programing" on your part.

The methods that work on the battlefield are in many case contrary to what works best off the battlefield and vice versa.

Biker
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
916 Posts
If gunfire breaks out and is not directed towards you, common sense says to exit the area! If that is not practical under the circumstances, then find cover and be a good observer - IF you can do so without putting yourself or others in danger.

As a ccw holder you are not a LEO backup. You are not a reserve swat team member. You are and remain a private citizen. If you try to be what you are not, you or another innocent may end up dead.

As always there are exemptions to every rule. However, don't make the mistake of thinking ever situation is that exemption.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
166 Posts
I agree with going the opposite way of gunfire, as I think only police officers are allowed to engage and not retreat from such things (if they are not directly threatened), correct? The only thing that would screw with me later is if it turned out to be something horrible that I could have stopped, or made less horrible, like a man going nuts in a park shooting kids/parents and I could have came out right behind him and stopped the threat if only I had took a look around the corner before getting away and calling 911.... In that case I guess I would consider becoming a police officer then, right?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
635 Posts
Procedure is a big part of this. There are those that would run towards the gun fire and those that would run away from it. Personally If I am in the middle and see a guy coming towards me from behind me with a gun I won't type what I would do but I know what I would do. In my opinion that is why you should not run towards the gun fire. Engage the bad guy if you are in the thick of it but don't go looking for it. Just assume there is someone up there already. I know that sound bad but otherwise it is potential CCW chaos.
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
18,125 Posts
I think only police officers are allowed to engage and not retreat from such things (if they are not directly threatened), correct?
Police Officers have no duty to retreat
.
They do not have to be directly threatened.

Anyone that is threatened is reason for an officer to respond...and they are expected to.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,469 Posts
No, not me personally. But back in the 90's, there were a rash of cop on cop shootings in D.C. Plain clothed PO/ off duty, had a robbery brake out while standing in line at a fast food restaurant. Holding gun in one hand, and badge in the other. Uniformed LEO show's up and shoot plain clothed guy.

This is what happens when you have a total ban on guns. If a LEO sees you, they automatically think you're one of the bad guys.

Good job D.C. government, Keep fighting Heller. Idiots
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
166 Posts
Police Officers have no duty to retreat
.
They do not have to be directly threatened.

Anyone that is threatened is reason for an officer to respond...and they are expected to.
That's what I thought, thanks for confirming, HotGuns.
 
1 - 20 of 50 Posts
Top