Defensive Carry banner

1 - 20 of 39 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,306 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Over the course of my CCW activity I have carried everything from a 5 shot J frame revolver to a 15+1 capacity Glock 19. But I have wondered how many shots a civilian really needs available to be prepared for most threats?

I would be interested to hear the thoughts of other people on this question. Does your caliber choice influence the capacity you need? Do spare magazines allow you to have less in the gun itself?

For myself, I am currently content with 8+1 in a .45 caliber 1911 plus one backup mag.
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
18,108 Posts
I carry a Sig 45 when I play cop. I carry two extra mags on the belt.

Thus far, Ive never felt like a I needed anything else.

If get in to a shooting"war". I'm goin to the AR-15...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
370 Posts
Someone will say it so it might as well be me. Hits are what matter. However, few people practice to the extent that they can reasonably expect to connect with every shot. More rounds available=more opportunities to make a hit.

How many rounds in the gun are necessary and how many reloads are carried is dependant on the skill of the individual with the weapon in question.

But I have wondered how many shots a civilian really needs available to be prepared for most threats?
Most threats? Probably none. I would say the vast majority of situations are resolved without having to fire at all. Personally, I think planning for the "average" or "most likely" situation is foolish.

Does your caliber choice influence the capacity you need?
No. I think that it is a safe assumption that a threat will require multiple hits, regardless of the caliber, especially when discussing handguns.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
25,483 Posts
BH6 kindly saved me some typing - thx pal! :wink: You covered my intended post nicely.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,215 Posts
Like many I face that issue, my preferred carry is a Colt Customized Commander in a Sparks holster. But when I saddle up I usually have a Sig 229 in a Wild Bill No Such Agency. I've gotten really good with it and the 357 Sig is the flattest shooting round I've ever seen.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
139 Posts
I carry a Taurus m617 and a speed loader and I'm comfortable with that. I figure 14 rds. of 125gr fed jhp .357 can immobilize up to 3 bgs.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,170 Posts
I will carry a Kahr PM40 most of the time. With this I will either have 5+1 or 6+1 rounds of 40cal. I am comfortable with this but I am starting to feel it would be wise to carry a spare mag.

However my caliber choice does affect the number of rounds I will carry. If I am carrying a double stack high capacity 9mm, 40, or 357 SIG I won't carry any extra mags. But if I have a single stack 45 or 40 I will carry an extra mag. I feel much better if I can carry more than 10 rounds.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,674 Posts
I carry 13 + 1 in my Sig 228 plus a spare mag. However capacity doesn't really matter to me. I have a pistol that I feel very confident that I can consistently score hits in "The Triangle" at combat range. It is a good feeling though to know that I can "keep the hits coming if I need to".
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,076 Posts
Right now I have a Taurus .357 5-shot with four speed strips and two speedloaders. I also carry a Para 10mm with 17 in the mag, 1 chambered as well as a 17 and 18 round mag. So...39 rounds total for the .357 and 53 rounds for the 10mm.

But I have wondered how many shots a civilian really needs available to be prepared for most threats?
You won't know until you need them.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
615 Posts
I'm of the opinion that a 5 shot snubby carries all the ammo that you'll likely ever need. A survey of all civilian gunfights would show that much less than 1% of gunfights involved a party firing more than that. I don't have a source for this but I've seen a report before that averages somewhere less than four shots fired by all parties in a gunfight. I think reliability and potency of cartridge are much greater concerns than capacity. But that's just my opinion.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
489 Posts
While I have no ccw experience, nor any personal stories as backup, I think high capacity depends on a lot of variables. If a person had a good idea they would be defending their live to multiple perps, they probably will want the extra capacity. Most people, however, can probably be perfectly fine with a "low" capacity weapon.

From what I can tell it seems like most serious assualts typically only have one perp, so a typical person would be fine with the lower capacity. My brother, on the other hand, is a deputy, so sometimes backup takes 10-20 minutes to get to his location for backup, and he is strongly considering a higher capacity weapon because his history of dealing with perps has been that they are much more hostile in groups.

It would seem that the need or desire for high capacity or low capacity will be dependant on the persons perception of needs. Proof being in the wide selection of handguns forum members use. Some use pocket pistols and are perfectly content with the performance from these handguns. Other settle for nothing short of a service pistol loaded with the best of the best ammo, and then also carry additional magazines.

It would seem the most logical route on deciding if capacity is important to YOU is to simply ask yourself if you expect to defend yourself against single or multiple perps.

Anyways, thats just my two cents.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,828 Posts
pogo2 said:
I have wondered how many shots a civilian really needs available to be prepared for most threats?
A self-defense event and how many rounds one may need for it is totally unpredictable. Every one makes a judgement call; the majority of those who carry semi-autos seem content with 1 extra magazine.

pogo2 said:
I would be interested to hear the thoughts of other people on this question. Does your caliber choice influence the capacity you need?
No. I carry magazine capacity + 1 + a spare magazine in either a G21 (27 rounds of .45) or G27 (23 rounds of .40, using mags with +2 extensions).


pogo2 said:
Do spare magazines allow you to have less in the gun itself?
Logically yes, but I have tested all my magazines and am confident they function correctly loaded to capacity.

I have fired up to 31 rounds in an IDPA stage a couple of times, but I don't think I would ever need to fire 20+ rounds in an actual fight. The sole reason I choose to carry an extra magazine is back-up in case the first magazine's base plate were to come off and drop its cartridges at an inopportune moment.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
866 Posts
my taurus is 12+1 in .45 and I carry two spare mags for 24 more so I get 37 total to end it or get clear of it....:buttkick:

my only civilian "gunfight" I fired 1 round and that ended it!:yup:



:danceban:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
23 Posts
Bang Bang Bang Bang Bang Bang.......Dang...... :Six-shooter

Bang Bang Bang Bang Bang Bang Bang Bang Bang Bang Bang Bang Bang Bang.........That's better.......:High-cap semi-auto

Disclaimer: This post in jest only. This poster really would like a 5-shot S&W snubbie someday.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,857 Posts
I carry to spare mags for the simple reason of a broken spring in a mag. The amount of ammo I guess is equal to how much you really need to stop a threat. The thing is if your approached by more that two armed bad guys, I guess it's not going to matter how much ammo you have.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
726 Posts
Fortunately most of us will never have to find out how many rounds are needed. Also, most of us are aware of the importance of shot placement. In a real world situation, however, two possibilities come to my mind and have guided me in my choice of weapon.

First is the BG high on meth or coke and out of control. I'd favor several rounds available and keep firing until he's out of commission.

Second possibility is the encounter with two or three BG's circling me in a dark parking lot or someplace similar. I sure would want plenty of rounds for that scenario also.

Therefore, I favor .40 S&W for stopping power close to the .45, but with much more capacity. My HK carries 12 and I carry a spare. Hope I never have to find out if I chose wisely.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
23 Posts
older gunner said:
Fortunately most of us will never have to find out how many rounds are needed. Also, most of us are aware of the importance of shot placement. In a real world situation, however, two possibilities come to my mind and have guided me in my choice of weapon.

First is the BG high on meth or coke and out of control. I'd favor several rounds available and keep firing until he's out of commission.

Second possibility is the encounter with two or three BG's circling me in a dark parking lot or someplace similar. I sure would want plenty of rounds for that scenario also.

Therefore, I favor .40 S&W for stopping power close to the .45, but with much more capacity. My HK carries 12 and I carry a spare. Hope I never have to find out if I chose wisely.

Hear, hear, on these scenarios. Other than home invasion and car-jacking, this is what I'd mostly watch for and are the most easily spotted (and hopefully avoided).
 
1 - 20 of 39 Posts
Top