Defensive Carry banner

1 - 20 of 31 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
599 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
I've been manually putting a loose round in the chamber, sending the slide forward, then inserting a full mag. It sounds from the other thread that most insert mag, rack slide, then remove mag and add a round to the top.

What is the reasoning for that? Is one method better than the other?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,604 Posts
I've always been told to load the chamber from rounds in the magazine, something about messing up the extractor. It is fairly easy not to mention good practice to insert magazine, rack the slide, eject magazine, top off magazine, then re-insert the magazine. Another school of thought is to not top off the magazine after loading the first one, I prefer to top off my magazine-I don't wanna be one bullet short.

Joker1
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
66 Posts
Putting a round in the chamber and sending the slide forward stresses the extractor. The extractor is forced to ride over the rim of the case as the slide moves forward.

When the round is chambered from the magazine the case rim slides under the extractor as it is pushed forward by the slide and exits the magazine.

Chamber round from magazine - remove magazine and top off - is the way to go.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,746 Posts
It sounds from the other thread that most insert mag, rack slide, then remove mag and add a round to the top.
You didnt say what gun you have but this is the proper way to go +1. Dropping a round into the chamber then allowing the bolt to "slam" forward on an already seated round is not good on the extractor or bullet and may cause a slam fire. Riding the slide slowly forward by hand may cause the bolt to not be in full battery.

Semi auto's are designed to pick up a round from the magazine and chamber the round naturally. Dont ride the slide forward, allow the recoil spring to chamber the round.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
7,276 Posts
Yup, same here. I was under the impression that it is harder on the extractor due to the angle (or lack of might be a better descriptor) of the rim when it passes over it. I won't claim to understand why it would cause that much more stress on the extractor but I always chamber from the magazine just in case!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
245 Posts
Definitely a good way to break the hook off the extractor. The problem is you most likely won't realize it until you shoot the first round. Bad if you're at the range...beyond bad if you're in a fight for your life.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
624 Posts
Probably a little less awkward, less likely to get oil on your clothes, to rack the slide and then replace the bullet in the mag.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
459 Posts
I definitely wouldnt let the extractor "pop" over the rim, but being short on cash and defensive ammo I've started to sneak one in between the extractor and breach face then let the in-place round slip in the chamber. Making sure the slide is in battery is important, but I can't find any reason this way would cause harm to the gun, as it is likely less stressful on the parts than a regular chambering.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
149 Posts
Putting a round in the chamber and sending the slide forward stresses the extractor. The extractor is forced to ride over the rim of the case as the slide moves forward.

When the round is chambered from the magazine the case rim slides under the extractor as it is pushed forward by the slide and exits the magazine.

Chamber round from magazine - remove magazine and top off - is the way to go.
+1 on that. A lot less problem doing it this way. :smile:
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
471 Posts
I will be the dissenting opinion here. Repeatedly chambering the same round from the magazine may cause bullet setback. The force of the bullet being pushed against the feedramp repeatedly may cause the bullet to be pushed into the case causing a high pressure condition. So watch your rounds if you are repeatedly chambering the same round from the magazine over and over.

I have a Taurus PT-145. The extractor pivots on a pin against a spring. Because of this extractor design, extractor breakage from hopping over the rim of a chambered round is negligible. This is how I load my Taurus PT-145.

1. Drop round in chamber.
2. Ride the slide forward allowing enough force for the extractor to engage the rim of the round.
3. Pull back on the slide just enough to visually observe the extractor pulling the round from the chamber.
4. Push the slide forward back into full battery.
5. Ensure the slide is in full battery by observing that the back of the slide is flush with the back of the frame.
6. Insert full magazine, double checking full seating of the magazine.

I load my gun for the range the same way and never had a failure in 100's of trips.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
149 Posts
NavyLT.
Agreed, you are the dissenting opinion, however you raise a good point: "Repeatedly chambering the same round from the magazine may cause bullet setback."
I may be mistaken but the question was not about repeated chambering, but your point is correct. JMHO
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,469 Posts
I've heard pf shells in a SG being cambered that way, but not pistols.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
66 Posts
I used to always drop a round in, slide release forward and then insert magazine. This was on my S&W CS45 when I carried it. I did it this way for years and never had a trouble. The extractor on the CS45 is bevelled at 45 and it is on a spring.. to me, that says the gun is designed to handle that type of operation.

That said, when I started dating my now wife, who is a LEO, she told me to load mag, chamber, then top off the mag. That is how her department trains.

It's faster to drop the round in then put in the full mag, but for the reasons described in other posts, I do the load from magazine now. It's faster to work the magazine then to have a gun failure and have to fix it.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
211 Posts
If you've got an old mag that isn't reliable (or one that is being "rested" load a few rounds in it and use it to load the chamber, then drop it and insert your carry mag.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
163 Posts
I will be the dissenting opinion here. Repeatedly chambering the same round from the magazine may cause bullet setback. The force of the bullet being pushed against the feedramp repeatedly may cause the bullet to be pushed into the case causing a high pressure condition. So watch your rounds if you are repeatedly chambering the same round from the magazine over and over.

I have a Taurus PT-145. The extractor pivots on a pin against a spring. Because of this extractor design, extractor breakage from hopping over the rim of a chambered round is negligible. This is how I load my Taurus PT-145.

1. Drop round in chamber.
2. Ride the slide forward allowing enough force for the extractor to engage the rim of the round.
3. Pull back on the slide just enough to visually observe the extractor pulling the round from the chamber.
4. Push the slide forward back into full battery.
5. Ensure the slide is in full battery by observing that the back of the slide is flush with the back of the frame.
6. Insert full magazine, double checking full seating of the magazine.

I load my gun for the range the same way and never had a failure in 100's of trips.
bullets are cheap.
rotating your carry ammo is a good plan anyway
how often do you need to remove the chambered round

you can buy a gauge and check for setback, but you can't exactly check for extractor damage easily.

there is also the train as you fight theory. With your method, I think that is setting up a bad muscle memory issue or at least the possibility.

although slight, the possibility of a slam fire makes everything else immaterial for me.

load mag, rack slide, drop mag, insert new round
after doing that 4 or 5 times add that round to the range rounds box.
insures you are practicing with some defense rounds and keeps your defense ammo fresh
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
24,508 Posts
I've been manually putting a loose round in the chamber, sending the slide forward, then inserting a full mag. It sounds from the other thread that most insert mag, rack slide, then remove mag and add a round to the top.

What is the reasoning for that? Is one method better than the other?
How does the instruction manual for your gun read. I personally have never seen a manual that tells you to insert a round in the chamber then close the slide. If your manual says to load it that way then continue to do so, but I'll bet it tells you to insert loaded magazine then release slide.
 
1 - 20 of 31 Posts
Top