Defensive Carry banner

1 - 20 of 25 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,213 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
I'm so proud of my aunt. Some of you may recall we set my aunt up with a Bersa Thunder 380 almost a year ago for her self protection needs.

She's really gotten on the stick with it. She is saving her pennies for her CCW permit and has practiced a lot since then. She has very good eyes and excellent depth perception. The gal can shoot! She's been getting help and practice ammo from my uncle who is competent enough to be an instructor, and she has been shooting the crap out of that Bersa.

She has become so dedicated she has asked me to help her find a better gun! She has been at it long enough now to figure out what she'd like to change.

Her current gun is much to her liking except for a couple things that merit a new gun:

-She does not like having to manipulate an external safety. Her fingers are short and it makes it hard to do that. She wants either a decocker or a DAO gun.

-She doesn't like the blowback type mechanism because she finds it hard to reassemble the gun after takedown. She can rack the slide just fine however.

-She might consider the right revolver, but she prefers a slim semiautomatic. She says it points better.

-She wants to step up to 9x19. She feels like she can handle the recoil. That alone makes me giddy with glee. We'll get her up to a caliber that starts with "4" yet!

-Budget is important here. She will accept my help but not my money and I respect her wishes. She will have $100 and is willing to sell the Bersa. What I plan to do is purchase the Bersa from her for $200. She unfortunately knows how much the Bersa costs, so I can't get away with paying her any more for it. However I know that's more than anyone else will give her for it!

The good news is this still means we have crept up into about the $300 range so we're doing a little bit better. $100 makes a big difference when you're talking about handguns.

-The main thing she really likes about the Bersa is its size and form factor. She says the size/weight is just perfect and with the Hogue Handall Jr. on it, it feels like it's part of her hand. She also likes the light trigger.

Her current gun is 6 5/8" long and weighs 23 ounces. She won't want one significantly larger.

I thought about it and thought about it, and the best I could come up with was the Kel Tec P11. It has no external safety to manipulate, it's actually slightly smaller than her current gun which she will like, and it's chambered in 9x19.

I'm a little dubious about the quality. Now the good news is I can put it through its paces and make sure it's not a piece of junk, but I dunno about Kel Tec. I know that the Bersa isn't exactly the pinnacle of quality either but it does go bang every time you pull the trigger.

I'm wondering if a Taurus might be an option too, like the PT111 PRO perhaps.

The thing is, she really likes the single stack magazines, and the only single stack 9mms I'm familiar with are well outside her price range. The BHP and 1911 are fine platforms but not within reasonable limits here. The Kel Tec seems pretty thin at least.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
516 Posts
I have one word for you; Kahr.


A K9 would be about perfect (maybe a P9, but I'm partial to steel Kahrs). An MK9 might also be worth looking into. Just make sure its not a NYCPD trigger.

A K9 is 6" long and 23oz

EDIT: oops ... didn't see the price limit
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
17,352 Posts
ya need to figure out how to slide a few more $$ in so that ya can get her something like a kahr not a fan of the kel tec
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
19,008 Posts
I would look at a Kahr, I do not trust Taurus PT guns after mine Kb'ed. I was not impressed with Taurus after this incident. They did repair it, but didn't give any reason for the failure, just repaired it and charged me shipping. Also the slide showed lots of wear and slight pitting after less than a year of carry.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
737 Posts
If the Kel Tec is all she can afford, it will work, but it's extremely difficult to be accurate with one due to the stiff and gritty trigger. Mine has been very reliable, over 300 rounds with no failures of any type (that includes about 100 hollow points). I have placed an order for a Kahr and hope to recieve it by the end of the month, after that the Kel-Tec will be sold (I already have a buyer). I know they aren't cheap, but I really believe your aunt will be far happier with and better served by the Kahr. It's superior to the Kel Tec in every way except for capacity. Better trigger, better sights, lighter, thinner, better materials... the list goes on. If she can't come up with the money today, advise her to keep the Bersa for six months and put $20 a week into an envelope during the same time. By the end of the six months she'll have enough to buy a P9 outright, then she can use the sale of the Bersa to finance a good carry rig.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,468 Posts
Euc,
Again, I would recommend CDNN. Not everything they have makes the catalogue, so I would ask them about something like a S&W 3913, trade in. Even the CZ hi-caps feel slimmer than Glock, and you can sand down the grips, removing almost 1/4"-1/2" of the grip width. CDNN had the Beretta single stack (92 somethingorother), for awhile, too. I really like that one myself.... :cool:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
117 Posts
If you are going to a dealer that knows you, perhaps you could cut a deal with them in advance? Something like, my aunt is coming in, let her negotiate the price down to $300 and I'll pay the difference? Just trying to think outside the box...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,213 Posts
Discussion Starter #9
XD40 said:
If you are going to a dealer that knows you, perhaps you could cut a deal with them in advance? Something like, my aunt is coming in, let her negotiate the price down to $300 and I'll pay the difference? Just trying to think outside the box...
THAT is deliciously manipulative and evil. I like it.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
195 Posts
How about a used Kahr. I bought my K9 used (only slightly) for $360. It came with 4 magazines. It may take some looking but should not be to hard to find one.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,011 Posts
I like both roadrunner's idea and XD 40's benign deception. I agree for the money and the quality go with the Kahr. I hate the P11. You might try one at a gun show for dry fire purposes alone. If you can, you might try a used STAR model BM 9mm. Single stack 9mm with an 8rd capacity. I bought one in 1980 for about $150 and gave it to a buddy of mine in ROTC when he got married. And no, I wasn't very fond of his wife...for good cause. She was a shrew who eventually wound up pressuring him out of military service to pursue AMWAY! That failed and he became a landscape artist. He was on the list for Lieutenant Colonel when he left the army. Damn shame. He still has the wife, though. Hope he still has the gun.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
737 Posts
XD40 said:
If you are going to a dealer that knows you, perhaps you could cut a deal with them in advance? Something like, my aunt is coming in, let her negotiate the price down to $300 and I'll pay the difference? Just trying to think outside the box...
Good idea, except that it's illegal, per the definition of straw purchase. I'm not saying the idea is bad or that the law is right, but no reputable gun-shop will be able to go along with what you describe.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
17,352 Posts
mayeb you can talk her into letting you buy the gun and giving it as a gift tell her ya found a great deal in BFE or something ... that doesnt make it a straw purchase if it is given as a gift
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,134 Posts
with her doing the " buying" i dont belive it would come to straw purchace , it would be more a christmas gift ( allbet unknown ) and keeping requirements in mind i would look for a used kahr or used dak sig for her personaly
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,011 Posts
Straw Man Purchase?

Roadrunner said:
Good idea, except that it's illegal, per the definition of straw purchase. I'm not saying the idea is bad or that the law is right, but no reputable gun-shop will be able to go along with what you describe.
IIRC I think for the straw man purchase to take effect, there has to be an asportation as they taught me in law school. That is, the illegal "go between" must exchange the money and actually take possession with the specific intent ('nother legal term of art) to transfer that property to another person in contravention of state law. But the best idea is to run it past a District Attorney and be sure to tell the story of the Aunt who can't afford the payments. I think this is a legitimate gift and as long as the AUNT fills out the paperwork and takes actual possesion, I would think it to be alright. But check with an attorney in your jurisdiction!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,085 Posts
EX:
That's pretty much my take on it as well. If she's going to be the actual owner and she's the one filling out the paperwork then there shouldn't be a problem. Seems the situation would be closer to giving a gift certificate (without her knowledge) than to engaging in a strawman purchase.
Jack
 
1 - 20 of 25 Posts
Top