[maddy345]

None of the shops in my area have a P228 or P229 in stock. I am ready to buy one online and have it transfered to a FFL near me but I want to get an idea of size first. Does anyone have both a P228 or P229 and a XD45 that they can take side by side shots of?

 

[jwhite75]

I have a 228, and have shot and handled the xd45. The 228 is much trimmer and sleeker, and in my opinion easier to conceal. witha good holster. It also has a much better feel and balance overall.

 

[45XDCCW]

Get the 228 (its lighter)

I just bought a new 228 as well, Couldnt ask for a better gun IMO

 

[Bob O]

This may help:

http://www.mouseguns.com/CompactCompare.pdf

Bobo