Defensive Carry banner

1 - 17 of 17 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,192 Posts
raevan said:
a good case for officers carrying Tazers. it would have been over much sooner
Agreed, I'm not a big fan of Tazers for many of the situations in which they are used but this would have been a good time. Bean-bag rounds would also have been effective .

I'm wondering, do they not carry OC-spray? They could have just hosed the guy, at the very least it might have distracted/disoriented him enough to give them a good opportunity to get him with a baton.

There were several times at which, I feel, various officers were WAY too close to him (they didn't have to stay that close, where did he have to go?). Particularly at the beginning when the officer that was closest to the subject still had his weapon holstered. Then there was the spot about 1:20 into the vid. where he spun around and advanced on the officers, I think I would have popped him right there.

At least none of the officers were injured. Since the guy probably didn't die I'm sure that department/city is going to be shelling out a ton of money in the inevitable lawsuit .
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
19,004 Posts
Notice the fields of fire. Several times , if the officers were to shoot they would have traffic as a backstop. Also , if the BG were to get in the middle of em , no good shoot lanes could be used.
Over all they did o.k. Better non lethal weapons would have helped alot.
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
4,964 Posts
IIRC, this video is from quite a few years ago, and I don't think the Taser was in widespread (or maybe any) use then.

Matt
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
4,964 Posts
Yeah, he came close to getting the Mk 0 Taser (the lead version).

Matt
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9 Posts
There is a rule that a 21 feet or closer and lethol force is authorized. As far as tazers. One thing we are taught as we carry tazers. They are a tool not a replacement for lethol when it is warranted and the public sometimes fails to understand that. Why should I match a a non lethol weapon with a Lethol weapon ( Knife). When the electricity stops flowing the muscles release and guess what. The subject still has the knife.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
136 Posts
Our dept has tasers. I would have had a couple of officers draw tasers and deploy them. The remaining officers could cover with guns and fire as needed.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
950 Posts
The officer that squeezed off the round did a good job. He had to work with what he had. Being a Counselor the guy wanted to do die and escalated the situation until he got his result. I feel bad for the officer because you can see that he was truly distrubed by the whole ordeal. I hope and pray that he is ok. However, this is a good case for tazers because the interaction would have been over at the initial point of escalation. Kudos to the officer. :congrats:
 

·
Administrator
Joined
·
143,580 Posts
OC Spray....Taser...12 Ga Shotty loaded w/ Less Than Lethal.
So many other options.
I guess it's just easier to walk 2 Miles and yell "DROP THE KNIFE!" about 500,000 times.:confused:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,170 Posts
I would have gotten inbetween the suspect and the oncomming traffic lanes if there weren't houses and such off the highway. I also would have fired at the time the suspect spun around, but I would have grabbed the Rem 870 as I exited the vehicle.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
700 Posts
Tough situation. I think I would de-escalate. Everybody backs off and have someone arrest him an hour later. It's not like he's going anywhere. Of course I don't know the full story.

As I was watching it I actually think I would have tried to sprawl him into the ditch by bumping him off of the hood of a cruiser. Or drive by and smack him with a car door. Nothing serious, just a little love tap. Once he's down several of the officers could have rushed him on the ground. Still a tough call. So many things could go wrong, especially since he's holding a knife. I don't think so though, the way he's holding that knife, I believe he would drop down and away from his body trying to catch himself when he falls forward.

Regardless pretty good job, and nobody died. Could have been much worse.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
219 Posts
Have not seen this before, thanks for posting!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
23 Posts
My Solution :)

Sit in the unit, sip on some coffee, slow roll behind this fool as he strides his way down the highway. USe the bullhorn every now and then for the "Drop the knife" announcement. Call in for less-than-lethal whatever it may be or have someone suit up to make the approach if none available.

In the meantime, standby until the less-than-lethal arrives. Upon arrival, approach rapidly if using baton or club-type device. Once the victim makes any pivot towards the officer, deploy, deploy, deploy, deploy. Other officers assist to gain positive control of the knife.

If OC or whatever is used, self-explanatory. If the badguy doesn't drop the knife while being sprayed and commanded, deploy batons repeatedly until compliance.

I thought the officer doing the approach did a very good job on a rapid point blank shot when the suspect to the little swing with the blade.

This situation screams mentally disturbed or potential suicide by cop. My threory, end it quickly. It's easier said then done, but to drag something on like this could pose a danger to the public as it is a severe traffic hazard. The suspect is also exposing the officers to danger by forcing them to stay on the highway of foot. That is PC enough to deploy force short of lethal to stop this.

I'm a fan of controlled speed and solid decisions.

Cole
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
71 Posts
kenpotex said:
Agreed, I'm not a big fan of Tazers for many of the situations in which they are used but this would have been a good time. Bean-bag rounds would also have been effective .

I'm wondering, do they not carry OC-spray? They could have just hosed the guy, at the very least it might have distracted/disoriented him enough to give them a good opportunity to get him with a baton.

There were several times at which, I feel, various officers were WAY too close to him (they didn't have to stay that close, where did he have to go?). Particularly at the beginning when the officer that was closest to the subject still had his weapon holstered. Then there was the spot about 1:20 into the vid. where he spun around and advanced on the officers, I think I would have popped him right there.

At least none of the officers were injured. Since the guy probably didn't die I'm sure that department/city is going to be shelling out a ton of money in the inevitable lawsuit .
I totally agree with ya. I agree with the person who made the comment about the oncomming traffic being the back stop but when he approached the officer on the outside nearest to the guard rail I would have shot his ass as soon as he started to approach me like he did.
 
1 - 17 of 17 Posts
Top